MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive/56: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 82: | Line 82: | ||
What happens when there are two or more products that can be considered the base game? Is the version with higher resolution given priority for the infobox or do both releases get an infobox image? An example would Captain Toad Treasure Tracker's Switch and 3DS release, specifically the Super Mario Odyssey based levels. [[User:Salmancer|Salmancer]] ([[User talk:Salmancer|talk]]) 16:38, September 30, 2020 (EDT) | What happens when there are two or more products that can be considered the base game? Is the version with higher resolution given priority for the infobox or do both releases get an infobox image? An example would Captain Toad Treasure Tracker's Switch and 3DS release, specifically the Super Mario Odyssey based levels. [[User:Salmancer|Salmancer]] ([[User talk:Salmancer|talk]]) 16:38, September 30, 2020 (EDT) | ||
::If there are noticeable graphical changes, then we could try to fit both in the box. (BTW, '''I'll''' archive this at around 4:00 WST.) {{User:DarkNight/sig}} 17:51, September 30, 2020 (EDT) | ::If there are noticeable graphical changes, then we could try to fit both in the box. (BTW, '''I'll''' archive this at around 4:00 WST.) {{User:DarkNight/sig}} 17:51, September 30, 2020 (EDT) | ||
=== Determine if Link's Awakening is a guest appearance === | |||
On the ''Super Mario Wiki'', coverage on articles has the limit on both crossovers and guest appearances. A good example is [[Wario]] appearing in ''[[Densetsu no Stafy 3]]''. Because Wario's role is essential to the game (he assists [[Assist Trophy|Starfy]] in the eighth stage), it gets an article. [[List_of_Mario_references_in_film#Wreck-It_Ralph|Wreck-It Ralph]], on the other hand, doesn't get an article because while [[Bowser]] did make a physical appearance and he is visible, his role is too minor for an essay. Then comes ''[[zeldawiki:The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening|The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening]]''. Currently, on the wiki, that game only gets referential coverage because the "only" Mario elements in the game are that many of the enemies are Mario enemies, and no actual physical Mario characters play a significant role. | |||
Except, that's not true! While I never played the game myself, there is one moment in the game that needs a mention. At one point in the game, [[Link]] can meet [[zeldawiki:Mamu|Mamu]], who is also known as [[Wart]]. This moment is him as he shares his Japanese name with him and looks like he does in the Mario games. Not only that, he teaches Link the "[[zeldawiki:Frog's Song of Soul|Frog's Song of Soul]]", '''meaning he plays an integral part in the game's plot. | |||
''' | |||
Unless this is an entirely different character from Wart, it's a character who has the same Japanese name as him, has the same appearance, and impacts the game's plot. Not to mention, Wart has become a ''Mario'' character at this point and not a ''Dream Factory'' character. As for how we would handle the article, if this does get approved, we'd list both the original game and the remake as one article since they're similar enough. Like all guest appearances, only the Mario elements will be mentioned in the article. | |||
'''Proposer''': {{User|Wikiboy10}}<br> | |||
'''Deadline''': October, 9, 2020, 23,59 GMT | |||
==== Guest appearance ==== | |||
#{{User|Wikiboy10}} Per proposal. | |||
==== Cameo appearance ==== | |||
====Comments==== |
Revision as of 16:06, October 2, 2020
Either rename Chanterelle to Pop Diva, or rename Master Poet to SimonTemplate:ProposalOutcome This proposal's title sums it up. I know this is just one example, but this has been bugging me for quite a while since it's super inconsistent as to how we deal with these characters' names. For clarification, both of their Tattles refer to them by their stage names, and their real names are only occasionally brought up a few times at best. Proposer: Archivist Toadette (talk) Rename Chanterelle to Pop Diva
Rename Master Poet to Simon
Do nothing
Comments
@Waluigi Time: Yeah, I guess the initial name of this proposal confused you a bit. Reworded for accuracy. (T|C) 17:31, September 21, 2020 (EDT) Upload images from the base game along with remakesTemplate:ProposalOutcome So what we're going to do is replace the images from games like SMAS and SM3DAS with ones from their base game, but still keep the images in their gallery, like this: Template:Levelbox Proposer: DarkNight (talk) Support
OpposeCommentsI think the proposal would be better worked out if it was drafted as a change to the image use policy. I think your points need a bit more fleshing out before we can officially apply it, since the title itself is a bit too vague for my tastes. There is a bunch of other articles that do bother me since they use images not in the original game, such as Super Mario Bros. and its use of All-Stars map images but I generally agree with the premise of the proposal nonetheless. Ray Trace(T|C) 18:11, September 23, 2020 (EDT)
Question, would you prefer the non-base game's image also in the infobox along with the base game's instead of being in the gallery? --DarkNight 00:02, September 24, 2020 (EDT)
I recommend two template boxes next to each other or something like merging the two in a box if possible. -- HUMPNUT!!! 18:33, September 29, 2020 (EDT)
What happens when there are two or more products that can be considered the base game? Is the version with higher resolution given priority for the infobox or do both releases get an infobox image? An example would Captain Toad Treasure Tracker's Switch and 3DS release, specifically the Super Mario Odyssey based levels. Salmancer (talk) 16:38, September 30, 2020 (EDT) Determine if Link's Awakening is a guest appearanceOn the Super Mario Wiki, coverage on articles has the limit on both crossovers and guest appearances. A good example is Wario appearing in Densetsu no Stafy 3. Because Wario's role is essential to the game (he assists Starfy in the eighth stage), it gets an article. Wreck-It Ralph, on the other hand, doesn't get an article because while Bowser did make a physical appearance and he is visible, his role is too minor for an essay. Then comes The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening. Currently, on the wiki, that game only gets referential coverage because the "only" Mario elements in the game are that many of the enemies are Mario enemies, and no actual physical Mario characters play a significant role. Except, that's not true! While I never played the game myself, there is one moment in the game that needs a mention. At one point in the game, Link can meet Mamu, who is also known as Wart. This moment is him as he shares his Japanese name with him and looks like he does in the Mario games. Not only that, he teaches Link the "Frog's Song of Soul", meaning he plays an integral part in the game's plot. Unless this is an entirely different character from Wart, it's a character who has the same Japanese name as him, has the same appearance, and impacts the game's plot. Not to mention, Wart has become a Mario character at this point and not a Dream Factory character. As for how we would handle the article, if this does get approved, we'd list both the original game and the remake as one article since they're similar enough. Like all guest appearances, only the Mario elements will be mentioned in the article. Proposer: Wikiboy10 (talk) Guest appearanceCameo appearanceComments |