MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
- For talk page proposals, see MarioWiki:Proposals/TPP archive.
| Color | Outcome |
|---|---|
| green | Passed; change was made and is currently enforced. |
| gray | Passed, but change has not yet been made. |
| yellow | Passed, but is no longer enforced or applicable. |
| brown | Did not reach a consensus; no change was made. |
| orange | Did not achieve quorum; no change was made. |
| red | Failed; no change was made. |
| blue | Failed, but proposed changes are currently enforced. |
| pink | Canceled by the proposer. |
| purple | Canceled by the wiki staff. |
| teal | Canceled and immediately put into effect. |
Proposals by decade
2020 proposals
| #1 • Compile Play Nintendo puzzle activities and merge existing relevant articles into a single page, Bye Guy (ended January 16) |
| #2 • Delete the "tense" template, Trig Jegman (ended February 18) |
| #3 • Creation of a new template to indicate color-correcting metadata, Trig Jegman (ended February 19) |
| #4 • Delete Template:No license, Trig Jegman (ended March 1) |
| #5 • Delete Category:User eo, Trig Jegman (ended March 5) |
| #6 • Add categories to the MarioWiki babel for Bengali, Urdu, and Hindi-speaking users, MarioManiac1981 (ended March 16) |
| #7 • Delete Category:User ka, Trig Jegman (ended March 22) |
| #8 • Create a "character/species" infobox, Doc von Schmeltwick (ended April 16) |
| #9 • Create a template for citations, Bye Guy (ended May 1) |
| #10 • Decide how to organize the colored Toad characters, Mario jc (ended June 18) |
| #11 • Abolish the no-signature policy, NSY (ended July 4) |
| #12 • Split the attacks from Paper Mario: Sticker Star and Paper Mario: Color Splash, Scrooge200 (ended July 4) |
| #13 • Split the enemy variants from Wario World, Bye Guy (ended July 11) |
| #14 • Split the item lists from Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars, Doc von Schmeltwick (ended July 12) |
| #15 • Cover fan-made Super Mario Maker courses highlighted by Nintendo, Bye Guy (ended July 28) |
| #16 • Remove the PipeProject and PipeProject Talk Namespace descriptor tags from the recent changes, DarkNight (ended August 3) |
| #17 • Redefine the scopes of Category:Undead and Category:Deceased, Pokemon (ended August 6) |
| #18 • Delete the Paper Mario: Sticker Star sticker variation articles, Toadette the Achiever (ended September 13) |
| #19 • Allow blank votes in proposals as an implied "per all", Waluigi Time (ended September 14) |
| #20 • Rename Chanterelle to Pop Diva, Archivist Toadette (ended September 28) |
| #21 • Reorganize the images in Template:Levelbox, DarkNight (ended September 30) |
| #22 • Create articles for minor locations in Super Mario Sunshine, The Mansion (ended October 30) |
| #23 • Decide where to cover Cheese the Chao, BBQ Turtle (ended November 25) |
| #24 • Decide where to cover Froggy, BBQ Turtle (ended November 25) |
| #25 • Create a category for actresses, MightyMario (ended December 12) |
| #26 • Reorganize the Mario Kart series sponsor lists, Archivist Toadette (ended December 13) |
| #27 • Delete the remaining lists of episodes featuring certain characters, MightyMario (ended December 27) |
2021 proposals
| #1 • Allow image/media categories by website, Koopa con Carne (ended January 2) |
| #2 • Allow the use of italics for boat names and fictional media, Bazooka Mario (ended January 9) |
| #3 • Split the tour appearances of Mario Kart Tour courses, Koopa con Carne (ended March 5) |
| #4 • Indicate which images are from pre-release versions of games outside of pre-release and unused content articles, Scrooge200 (ended March 27) |
| #5 • Remove non-Mario characters from the trophies, Assist Trophy, stickers, and Spirit pages, Doomhiker (ended March 28) |
| #6 • Use shorthand names for the Donkey Kong Country series animal friends, Keyblade Master (ended April 5) |
| #7 • Rename "places" categories to "locations" categories, The Mansion (ended April 12) |
| #8 • Use closed captions as spelling sources for Mario cartoons, Grandet Omate (ended April 20) |
| #9 • Apply usual naming rules to Mario Kart course names, Koopa con Carne (ended May 21) |
| #10 • Do not allow WildBrain to be used as a source, PanchamBro (ended May 23) |
| #11 • Combine the four pages on Mega Pi'illos into one "Mega Pi'illo" page and change the original four pages to redirects, Casual Koopa (ended May 25) |
| #12 • Use a unique archive color for proposals that fail to reach a consensus, 7feetunder (ended June 1) |
| #13 • Use a hybrid of prose and bullet points when listing changes on articles for ports, remakes, and remasters, 0blivion (ended June 5) |
| #14 • Decide how to handle Super Mario Odyssey sub-locations, 7feetunder (ended September 28) |
| #15 • Decide how to categorize Bowser minigames in Mario Party Superstars, WildWario (ended November 16) |
| #16 • Define the scope of "Other appearances" sections, Koopa con Carne (ended November 18) |
| #17 • Decide if media filenames from Nintendo's websites qualify as sources for subject names, Koopa con Carne (ended December 28) |
| #18 • Make new templates for frequent reminders, Alex95 (ended December 29) |
2022 proposals
| #1 • Allow an external link to Zelda Dungeon Wiki and/or Triforce Wiki in the External links section of some The Legend of Zelda-related articles, Results May Vary (ended January 3) |
| #2 • Create "Unused appearances" sections in history, Waluigi Time (ended January 11) |
| #4 • Split or merge Mario Kart Tour variants, Tails777 (ended January 21) |
| #5 • Merge Spiky John with Spiky Tom or merge both to Koopatrol, Remembered Old Buddy (ended February 1) |
| #6 • Merge the Wrecking Crew and VS. Wrecking Crew phases, Spectrogram (ended February 16) |
| #7 • Merge the Wrecking Crew and VS. Wrecking Crew phases into a list article, Spectrogram (ended February 24) |
| #8 • Create a stat table template for Mario Kart DS karts, ShootingStar7X (ended March 3) |
| #9 • Do not consider usage of classic recurring themes as references to the game of origin, Swallow (ended March 9) |
| #10 • Create a collective article for the Sonic the Hedgehog animal friends that cross over with Mario, BBQ Turtle (ended March 20) |
| #11 • Merge some complete BJAODN articles with collections, Somethingone (ended April 1) |
| #12 • Establish a guideline for the number of files in Media sections on game articles, DannyTheDingo (ended April 5) |
| #13 • Allow certain fan works by former Nintendo staff, Koopa con Carne (ended April 6) |
| #14 • Always use past tense when describing pre-release and unused content, DannyTheDingo (ended April 8) |
| #15 • Forbid "special symbols" from being used in article titles, Spectrogram (ended April 12) |
| #16 • Determine if Pinball should receive full coverage or be considered a guest appearance, Spectrogram (ended April 15) |
| #17 • Classify Art Style: PiCTOBiTS as a guest appearance and give it its own page, Jacklavin (ended April 19) |
| #18 • Allow articles on non-Mario subjects to link to their main Fandom wikis in their External links sections, Results May Vary (ended April 20) |
| #19 • Determine The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening as a guest appearance and create articles covering it and its Mario-related subjects, Results May Vary (ended April 20) |
| #20 • Overhaul the no quorum proposal rule (#8), 7feetunder (ended April 21) |
| #21 • Create a The Legend of Zelda series article and/or a "Related series" category, Results May Vary (ended April 21) |
| #22 • Create a Smash Bros. DOJO!! images category and/or an Official screenshots category, Results May Vary (ended April 22) |
| #23 • Create an article for Classic Mode, Results May Vary (ended April 23) |
| #24 • Remove Zelda Wiki as an interwiki link, Results May Vary (ended April 28) |
| #25 • Split Mario Kart Tour character variants or merge kart/glider variants, Tails777 (ended May 4) |
| #26 • Use a table for internal names separate from the names in other languages table, Somethingone (ended May 14) |
| #27 • Prioritize "data-rendered model" images, Waluigi Time (ended May 25) |
| #28 • Change Monobook's background image to the one used on the Vector skin, PanchamBro (ended May 27) |
| #29 • Remove the dktable-brown class, Waluigi Time (ended May 27) |
| #30 • Make tables, templates, and other areas in the mainspace compliant with WCAG 2.1, PanchamBro (ended May 29) |
| #31 • Discount resized enemies from Mario Kart Tour as "big" variants of the base enemy, Koopa con Carne (ended June 9) |
| #32 • Trim extraneous Game & Watch coverage, Waluigi Time (ended June 10) |
| #33 • Decide how to cover Mario Kart Tour bonus challenges on course articles, Koopa con Carne (ended June 30) |
| #34 • Do not use Mario + Rabbids "introductory taglines" as top quotes in articles, Swallow (ended July 24) |
| #35 • Stop considering reissues to be a reference to the original game and vice versa, Wikiboy10 (ended July 26) |
| #36 • Fix how we handle infobox relations on generic species, Somethingone (ended July 31) |
| #37 • Decide on the article titles for the golf courses from Mario Golf (GBC) and Mario Golf: Advance Tour, 7feetunder (ended August 8) |
| #38 • Merge city course and Kalimari Desert layouts, Ahemtoday (ended August 13) |
| #39 • Remove the 15th infraction for why a reminder can be issued (changing American spellings and grammar conventions to British standards), Mari0fan100 (ended August 22) |
| #40 • Change "NS" to "Switch", Teh Other (ended August 26) |
| #41 • Merge unrelated to Mario objects and items in the Smash Bros. series, Spectrogram (ended August 26) |
| #42 • Decide what to do with Greenhouse, Spectrogram (ended September 2) |
| #43 • Merge or delete Super Smash Bros. series general technique articles, 7feetunder (ended September 3) |
| #44 • Split Bowser's Castle (Mario Kart Arcade GP) and Bowser's Factory, as well as Castle Wall and Bowser's Castle (Mario Kart Arcade GP DX), Arend (ended September 3) |
| #45 • Merge the List N entries, including F-Zero Racer, Spectrogram (ended September 5) |
| #46 • Move Flying Goomba and Para-Goomba, but not Parabomb, LadySophie17 (ended September 5) |
| #47 • Stop considering a coverage-related proposal "implemented" before the information gets added to MarioWiki:Coverage, Spectrogram (ended September 8) |
| #48 • Make classic course prefixes in titles consistent for Mario Kart courses/stages, RealStuffMister (ended September 10) |
| #49 • Change how RPG enemy infoboxes classify role, Doc von Schmeltwick (ended September 18) |
| #50 • Merge Super Smash Bros. series bosses into a collective article, Spectrogram (ended September 21) |
| #51 • Merge the Kings and Queens categories, Wikiboy10 (ended September 27) |
| #52 • Merge Mario Party Advance "generic species representative character" articles that share English names back into their respective "species" articles, Doc von Schmeltwick (ended September 22) |
| #53 • Rename the WFC information box for Mario Kart courses, Skipper93653 (ended October 9) |
| #54 • Remove "Koopa" and other name particles from Koopaling article titles, Koopa con Carne (ended October 16) |
| #55 • Create Category:Mario + Rabbids Sparks of Hope Sparks, ThePowerPlayer (ended October 17) |
| #56 • Remove or split trophy/spirit cameos from latest appearances, Windy (ended October 20) |
| #57 • Consider Paper Airplane Chase to be a part of the Mario franchise, Spectrogram (ended October 22) |
| #58 • Standardize citations for archived pages, ThePowerPlayer (ended October 24) |
| #59 • Include last non-Smash appearances in infoboxes, Windy (ended October 28) |
| #60 • Merge all non-Mario Super Smash Bros. stages into a collective article, NSY (ended October 29) |
| #61 • Merge most of the articles listed in the Diamond disambiguation page, Koopa con Carne (ended October 29) |
| #62 • Include the Visual Editor as an editing option, Johnjohn2001 (ended November 1) |
| #63 • Remove the list and table exception from MarioWiki:Article size, Somethingone (ended November 5) |
| #64 • Decide when to substitute the meaning/explanation of a foreign name with a hyphen, Koopa con Carne (ended November 14) |
| #65 • Remove external links to Zelda Dungeon Wiki and/or Triforce Wiki, PanchamBro (ended November 18) |
| #66 • Partially unban citing the English version of the Super Mario Bros. Encyclopedia as official names for subjects, LinkTheLefty (ended November 26) |
| #67 • Include physical appearance in an infobox, Windy (ended December 2) |
| #68 • Rework the Mario Kart 8 Deluxe category into a subcategory of the Mario Kart 8 category covering only Deluxe-exclusive content, Ahemtoday (ended December 5) |
| #69 • Revise previous Game & Watch proposal to retain classic game information, Waluigi Time (ended December 17) |
| #70 • Change the Poll Committee Chairperson election month from June to February, Fun With Despair (ended December 24) |
2023 proposals
| #1 • Classify Sonic Lost World as a guest appearance, Spectrogram (ended January 13) |
| #2 • Merge Subspace Emissary and Adventure Mode stages from the Super Smash Bros. series, Spectrogram (ended January 21) |
| #3 • Make changes on Yoshi franchise articles, Teh Other (ended January 21) |
| #4 • Create redirects with console prefixes for Mario Kart courses that lack them, Ahemtoday (ended January 27) |
| #5 • Classify StreetPass Mii Plaza as a guest appearance and trim it accordingly, Spectrogram (ended January 28) |
| #7 • Merge "Yoshi (platform series)" and "Yoshi (puzzle series)" into "Yoshi (franchise)", Teh Other (ended February 2) |
| #8 • Include the Visual Editor as an editing option, Spectrogram (ended February 26) |
| #9 • Discourage drive-by templating, Glowsquid (ended March 6) |
| #10 • Trim the Smash Bros trophies page, Glowsquid (ended March 8) |
| #11 • Change the way Super Smash Bros. fighter lists are organised, Koopa con Carne (ended March 8) |
| #12 • Merge Mario Kart Tour kart and glider variants or split character variants, Tails777 (ended March 12) |
| #13 • Overhaul the staff ghost section of race course infoboxes, Ahemtoday (ended March 24) |
| #14 • Clarify a statement in the January–February 2023 proposal regarding Super Smash Bros. series fighters through a footnote, Koopa con Carne (ended March 26) |
| #15 • Add level maps for levels with no maps, SONIC123CDMANIA+&K(B&ATSA) (ended April 11) |
| #16 • Trim and merge Smash spirits and stickers, Spectrogram (ended April 20) |
| #17 • Create an article for Punch-Out!! (NES), Wikiboy10 (ended April 20) |
| #18 • Merge every Super Smash Bros. stage into game-specific lists, GuntherBB (ended April 26) |
| #19 • |