The 'Shroom:Issue 236/Critic Corner

From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
CC-Banner2017.png

Director's Notes

Written by: Fun With Despair (talk)

Shroom FWD.png

Hey, wait what - why am I up here? What's going on? I gotta get outta here, this is too much pressure man. Whatever happened to just reviewing food... sometimes? Or the Poll Committee Discussion or...

Okay, okay. Time to lock in.

Hey everyone, I'm Fun With Despair - as you can uh, see from the author attribution up there. You might recognize me from the various other sections I've filled in for over the years, or you might not. If the latter's the case, then hello - and thanks for checking in on our little corner of orange. Anton's still reeling from last month's Half-Baked Reviews (the sugar in those things gives you a wicked hangover), so for this month and potentially December, I'll be handling Critic Corner in his stead. Rest assured, he'll return to us one day - but until then, hopefully I can help keep things critical in this corner.

Anyway, I'm sure he'll be happy to return to the news that Half-Baked Reviews once again took the title of Critic Corner's Section of the Month for October! Though, that's not to discredit our second and third place winners, the excellent new Primative's Propaganda, and Completion Centre respectively. Be sure to give them a read this month too, and check out our authors' forum threads dedicated to their sections. Oh, and as an ex-Poll Committee chairperson, I shouldn't need to remind you to go and place a vote for your favorite article! It's not only a way to honor your favorite articles in Section of the Month, but a great tool for writers to figure out what the people want.

Have a happy Thanksgiving if you're American, and try not to strangle your family members. If you're not American, uh... Well, it's just November. I guess that's kind of cool.


And now, for the usual:

As you probably know if you're a reader, Critic Corner's implemented a strategy aimed at smoothing over the process of getting one-off or limited-series articles into The 'Shroom without needing to go through the usual formal application process. If you've watched, played, eaten, or even just vaguely looked at something that's given you the spark of critical inspiration but don't really have any particular desire to commit to a regular, reoccurring section - then you're in luck. Ordinary, you'd want to send those one-offs privately to Anton, but while he's taking his well-deserved break, shoot me a message to me on the forum in his place, and we'll give it a feature here on the Critic Corner. Of course, if you later decide to turn that into a regular section, that's definitely still an option. If you've got any questions, don't be afraid to reach out. I don't bite, unless you're a chicken sandwich or one of the few edible foods in Newfoundland.

Of course, Critic Corner is always looking for new writers - and this little corner of The 'Shroom is plenty flexible. Do you have an opinion on anything? A character, a movie, the bench you sat on last Thursday? You probably do - so why not take a crack at writing for us? You don't need a long article, you don't need to try and match some of our most popular in terms of production value. We've got all levels of experience and all sorts of different article lengths here - just sitting down and creating something can be its own reward. Applying to write for The 'Shroom is easy, just visit the Sign Up page for info, and send an application to MightyMario on the forum. Any idea is welcome, we're just happy to have you. Until Anton returns, feel free to reach out to myself or the rest of our staff if you have any questions, concerns, or even if you just need a sounding board for ideas.

Section of the Month

CRITIC CORNER SECTION OF THE MONTH
Place Section Votes % Writer
1st Anton's Half-Baked Reviews 8 40.00% Hypnotoad (talk)
2nd Primative's Propaganda 5 25.00% Primative (talk)
3rd Completion Centre 3 15.00% Sentient freedom (talk)

Reviews / opinion pieces
✋🔺🤚
Wii would like to play
The gorilla better watch himself
Perfect batting record
Try again, monkey man!

'Shroom FM

Written by: MCD (talk)

Welcome once again to Critic Corner's most consistent music review section.

Vol. II

Angine de Poitrine - Vol. II

If you're not familiar with Angine de Poitrine, they're a duo with big papier-mâché heads and polka-dotted costumes, who came from another planet millions of years ago and play very angular math rock with a lot of microtones (i.e. the notes between the usual notes). They're also an absolutely massive live act at the minute, somehow - and this has led to some polarised reactions. Is the whole thing pretentious, is the music just noise? On the other hand, while it's all very technical, are the songs actually that interesting? On Halloween when they introduced a "new member" who only came out to play the triangle (badly), and for some reason some people got very angry about that? Anyway, the point is: on paper, Angine de Poitrine sound like a band you have to switch your brain on to enjoy, but really it's the opposite. The music is catchy, fun, energetic and jaunty, and well-constructed of course, but never really quite as "out there" as you'd expect. Which is maybe a bit disappointing if you were hoping for it to be more complex, but taken it for what it is, it's still enjoyable. I've managed to catch them live (twice on the same day) and it's not hard at all to see why they've gotten so big, the songs go extremely hard live. The second time I saw them was in a completely packed tent, right up at the front, very loud and intense, and it's mesmerising watching them navigate these complex notes and time signatures close-up. Unfortunately, the consequence of them being so good live is that the studio versions don't hit the same way. I've listened to Vols. I and II and I just about prefer the former, but there's really not a lot between the two. For Vol. II, "Fabienk" is a cool and jaunty opener, "Sarniezz" is a great example of their style at its best, and "Utzp" is bouncy and fun, and probably the most 'different' track to the usual - but then the rest just fades into the background a bit. They should at least include the bit where they get the audience to hold up their hands in a triangle shape and communicate in their own language.

Phoebe Bridgers - Lost Weekend

To get straight to the point, Lost Weekend is not as good as Phoebe's previous solo albums, but still much better than Boygenius. I appreciated a lot of what was going on here, it's hazy and atmospheric, definitely following on from her last album Punisher in that sense - both are mellow and tender, and very emotive as well. The big moments in songs like "Lost Boys" and "Bobby" are very lush and cathartic, though others like "I Can't Wait" can get a bit predictable with their structure. There's a bit more experimentation with electronic sounds here which is often interesting. Sometimes it really works - I was very intrigued by the title track, which starts off quiet and contemplative with cutting, confessional lyrics, and then right at the end bursts into this chaotic, glitchy outro. But at other times, like the club beat on "The Governer's Waltz" which barely fades in before it disappears again, it doesn't feel like these things are being utilised as well as they could be. I didn't like the autotune on "The Outside" at all, and being the first track, it's not a great first impression - though thankfully nothing after feels quite as out-of-place. On the whole, though, it's still well-written and constructed, and there are plenty of ideas here which I hope she explores more in future.

Day and Night

Carly Rae Jepsen - Day and Night

I hadn't been following this album cycle at all or listened to any of the singles beforehand. For her past few releases, Carly has released an album and then another one a year or so later with outtakes or other tracks from the same sessions, so it's interesting to see her just release one extra-long album this time. Day and Night is a double album split in a way that will be very familiar to fans of Mario Party 6. Nothing too surprising about how the album is split - Day has its bright pop songs, much calmer and breezier, and then Night is of course for the dancier club tracks. I think this split does work in the album's favour - the shift in the middle is noticeable but not jarring, and it means that both sides feel fresh and distinct, I never felt like the album was starting to lag which is impressive given its length. I wouldn't say there's as much here which stands out to me as her last album The Loveliest Time, definitely a few tracks on both sides that didn't do too much for me, but there's still a cool range of sounds and styles across both sides of this.

World News - In Purgatory

This is pretty neat. Nothing too groundbreaking, but some nice, breezy indie rock. I've seen a lot of comparisons here to all kinds of 80s and 90s bands and all of them have been wildly inaccurate. It reminds me a lot of early 90s indie rock, with its jangly guitars, and a nice, deep atmosphere. "Everything is Coming Up Roses" is definitely the highlight here for me - the chorus is really catchy and the instrumental break is sick.

Yoshi18 Reviews

Written by: Yoshi18 (talk)

Hey everyone! Welcome back to Yoshi18 Reviews! This time I'll review the Wii, as its 20th anniversary was 2 days ago, and I can't wait to review it! Let's get into it!

Wii

The Wii.

This was my first ever console. Not just from Nintendo, but just my first gaming console in general. This console introduced me to gaming as a whole. And I really gotta thank it for that. It turned me into the gaming fanatic I am today (and I'm glad I am). This console immediately introduced me to Nintendo's then-new mascots: the Miis! Except for Mario, Mii games (also known (officially) as the Wii series as all these games have "Wii" in their title) have been a pretty big part (actually half) of the reason of my love for the Wii. I spent just as much time on Mario as these games. I often had a hard time deciding whether I would play Mario Party 8 or Wii Party (as I said in the issues about these games). And while it seems like I'm mainly talking about games now, the amazing games on there is the reason I like the console (I mean, what other reason is there?).

A thing I can say about the console though is of course the most notable thing of it: the Motion Controls. It felt so fresh and new (I mean it was new at the time yeah). Not necessarily having to press any buttons but instead use your remote as if you're really performing the action that is being done on-screen. Another thing I really like about the Wii is its menu and Mii Maker music. You know, back when Nintendo actually had soul and gave them (their own) music. But yeah, this will always remain the best (Nintendo) console (for me). And while it may not be the best console for everyone, it is the most popular one and that's a fact. Despite the fact the Nintendo DS and Nintendo Switch (yeah and also the PS2 that totally doesn't deserve it, but that's another story for another time) sold better, the Wii will always be more popular, especially in meme culture.

It's not just that, though. Lots of big Nintendo YouTubers are keeping the Wii alive as well. They play games like Mario Party 8, Wii Party, Mario Kart Wii, Wii Sports, Wii Sports Resort and Mario Party 9. And all of these games, along with the Wii, are being kept all. So a big thank you to these YouTubers (and actually just YouTube in general, as I should of course also include meme culture), without you guys (and YouTube itself), the Wii wouldn't be nearly as popular as it is now! If it's this console, you can always expect Wii are gonna play!


Thank you guys so much for reading this review! The Wii means so much to me! Not just because of the childhood memories I have of it, but because it still does to this very day! While I haven't played on my actual Wii in about a year or three, I have Dolphin Emulator on my laptop and I often (for now only) play Mario Kart Wii on it. I also recently learned how to mod it, so now I'm also playing around with mods, which is real nice!

This is probably my favorite review to date! It's been wonderful looking back at this console and everything it has to offer! The Wii will always hold a special place in my heart! Happy 20th anniversary to the Wii!

SuperGamer18's Random Reviews

Yo, SuperGamer18 here! Welcome to SuperGamer18's Random Reviews™! This section will probably be unlike any other, because my focus is to cover niche, random stuff that you probably never heard of! But when I say niche, I really mean niche. So just relax, read, and probably find your next hyperfixation! /j? What kind of content will I cover? Mostly games, although I wouldn't rule out other forms of media (TV shows, movies, books, whatever), but I mean, this is a Mario wiki, right? You'd expect games, and games is what you'll be getting! 😛

Anyways, this time I'll be covering a game I happen to physically own. And that game is...

Donkey Kong for the Game & Watch

Alternate box art for Donkey Kong (Game & Watch). This is for the third North American release.

Yup, I'm starting with an oldie here. I happen to own the original version of this game (only the unit itself though...), so you'll see a few amateur pics here and there. You probably know this game if you're somewhat invested in the Game & Watch rabbithole, but hey, you might learn a thing or two from this, so let's begin!

What Is It About?

Honestly, if you were expecting complex lore, then I've got bad news for ya. The game is somewhat similar to the arcade game it is based on with the same name, so its story is about the same. Pauline got kidnapped by Donkey Kong and now Mario has to rescue her by climbing to the top. How about the gameplay itself? It is somewhat similar, but there's quite a few differences, mainly the fact that there's only one level, your movement is limited and you have to time your final jump four times before rescuing your lovely girl. More on that below.

Gameplay

Shroom236 DK G&W.jpg

The gameplay of Donkey Kong for the Game & Watch is as simple as you'd expect. As Mario (or the Rescue Man if you prefer calling him that here for some reason), you have to get to the second screen on top (Nintendo DS foreshadowing!?) while avoiding the barrels that the titular Kong throws by either jumping above them (provided you have some space above your head to jump), which gives you one point, or by simply not being in their way (for example by using the stairs), which will give you nothing. However, it doesn't end there. Whenever you get at the top, you have to flip a switch to activate a crane, and you still need to avoid some more barrels. Once you get to the crane, you have to time your jump in order to grab one of whatever the hell is holding him so high up. Here's a lil hint: the hook has to be pointing all the way to the left, otherwise you'll fall off. Every time you successfully do that, you have to repeat the cycle three more times, after which Donkey Kong will fall and you'll finally get Pauline. Does the game end there? No! You can keep going, but with an extra obstacle. A moving girder halfway through, which will give you less moments to time your jumps and your second ladder climb. This appears from the start if you select GAME B instead of GAME A. Oh, almost forgot to say! You get points every time you grab the hook and defeat Donkey Kong. The faster you do the former, the more points you'll get! I never got to 300 points in this game, but I'll tell ya what happens anyways. If you didn't lose a single time, you'll get double points until you lose! Tempting, isn't it? Otherwise you'll get an extra life.

Thoughts

What do I think of this game? Honestly, for what it is, it's kinda fun! You can entertain yourself for a while with this game, though it gets repetitive a bit fast, but hey, it's a fucking LCD game, you can't do much about that. The part at the end is a bit annoying, but to be fair, that's early 80's difficulty for ya, and it's somewhat justified here. If you played the original Donkey Kong, then this game's most definitely for you. My verdict?

7/10.

It's a good game if you're feeling like playing something simple for a bit, although even the actual Donkey Kong would be better at that. The graphics convey what they meant to well for the most part, but the audio's a bit loud. It's just some silly lil beeps, though, can't do much about that!

Bonus Stuff

I'll talk about the unit I have for a bit. So, it's full of scratches and other stuff, but the game is like, fully functional! Thank god, because beyond having to make the batteries stay in place, I don't have to do anything else here. I am absolutely NOT setting up an alarm with this thing though... Anyways, thanks to Primative for giving me the inspiration to cover this game! Let's see if I can find anything jolly to review next time... 👀 Ho, ho, ho... 🎅

Book Review

Written by: FunkyK38 (talk)

I Am The Night: The Ultimate Unauthorized History of Batman: The Animated Series
BookReview236.png
Author Daniel Dockery
Release date 2026
Genre Nonfiction
Pages 304
Available From

Greetings, readers, and welcome back to Book Review! This month, I will be looking at I Am The Night: The Ultimate Unauthorized History of Batman: The Animated Series, by Daniel Dockery!

Occasionally, I come across book advertisements on Facebook that come directly from authors or the publisher, in some cases. These are obviously ads, but if something strikes my fancy, I might check it out and see what it's about. I've found a few true gems this way, so I'm always willing to hear them out. This summer I found some ads from both the publisher MacMillan and author Daniel Dockery for the book, and it piqued my interest enough to place on my October bookstore run list. As a person who reads fiction the majority of the time, I make it a point to read at least 1 non-fiction book each year, and this year, this book is landing at number 6, so I'm definitely ahead for the year. So, what can we learn from this book? Let's find out.

Batman: The Animated Series came out following the release of Tim Burton's two Batman movies, Batman and Batman Returns. Warner Bros. wanted to capitalize on the success of the first movie, and the series was put into production before the second was released. The series was instrumental in getting the cartoon programming block on Fox started, and it's one of the most well-loved bits of Batman media released. I Am The Night explores not only the history of the series, but also the landscape of cartoons and comics at the time, and the creatives behind the project as well.

For this one, I'm going to break my review into two parts: the parts of the book focusing on Batman: TAS and the parts of the book focusing around what the rest of the world was doing at the time during the production of the series. We'll start with the Batman part first. Dockery does a deep dive into the production of the show, from the creatives like Bruce Timm and Eric Radomski doing sketches of Batman and Bruce Wayne to the hiring of composers and voice actors and additional writers and storyboarders. I was hooked on this book the whole way through. Dockery breaks up chapters into manageable sub-chapter chunks, so it's easy to read a few pages and find a place to stop if you need to go do something. The breaks also give Dockery a way to swap through different subjects- each chapter revolves around a subject, such as writing episodes or designing villains, but you'll also get glimpses at what else is going on at Warner Bros., or what's happening with Batman Returns as it enters filming and advertising at the time Batman:TAS is beginning production. I especially enjoyed the segments describing finding the voice actors. Kevin Conroy's hiring as Batman is pretty straight-forward, but Tim Curry (rest in peace) was actually considered for The Joker at one point, until the role was given to Mark Hamill after he voiced some smaller background characters. Harley Quinn was designed and modeled after Arleen Sorkin, who was a friend of writer Paul Dini, and who would go on to voice her for many years. Sorkin and Conroy are unfortunately no longer with us, and after Conroy's death four years ago, Mark Hamill also stepped down as the voice of The Joker, stating that his Joker couldn't go on after the loss of Conroy, his Batman. Dockery captures the entire exchange and it's definitely bittersweet.

What was going on in the world of animation while Batman:TAS was in production? Dockery has you covered there, too. The book runs through a timeline of Warner Bros. getting into making more cartoons- after Looney Tunes, what did they do next? Well, it involved Steven Spielberg, and this marks the second non-fiction I've read this year that has him walking through the plot (although in this one, he's definitely a background character.) What did they do after Batman:TAS finished up its run? Where did the writers and artists go next? What were other studios doing during this time? The Disney Renaissance was coming up hot, and Nickelodeon was starting up. Many different channels were beginning their cartoon programming block, starting with Saturday morning cartoons and moving to after-school blocks. At one point, Batman:TAS was even competing with 60 Minutes during Sunday evening primetime TV, which was wild to read about- when I think of "what's on TV on Sunday night" I'm definitely thinking of the news and football. I loved the way everything fit together. Dockery writes in a way that gives you enough information to answer your questions, but makes you want to keep reading to find out what he's going to tell you about next. I devoured this book in one day- it's full of good information and you walk away wanting to go watch the show, but you won't feel overwhelmed by it's length.

I'm so happy to be able to recommend this one to you after the last couple of reviews of disappointing books. If you're a Batman fan, or an animation fan in general like me, you will adore this book. If you need a non-fiction book to read for the year, try this one, you won't regret it. It would definitely make for a good holiday gift if you have a Batman fan in your life. Two thumbs way up for this book.

That's all for me this month, readers! See you next year for hopefully another great year of books!

Completion Centre

Written by: Sentient freedom (talk)

This box art has a lot of unused features from the final game, such as how the Golem looks and the hunter birds. The Golem looks different and the hunter birds are never seen in the final game.

Greetings everyone! So it's November right now, and that can only mean one thing! No, something wonderful doesn't happen on this month - it means that Rayman Legends Retold releases next month, so to celebrate I think it'll only be fitting if I do a 100% completion review on Rayman Origins!

Personal Pathway

Now, believe it or not, I actually do have memories of this game from when I was younger. I was playing a demo of the game on my older brother's PS Vita. It was definitely one of the best games I have played my life.

I think most of you already know the story of this game, because this game is very well-known - so instead I'll introduce you all to RetroAchievements. That site allows you to get achievements for games that do not have them, and I mastered the set for it, which took AGES! By the way, mastering a set means getting all the achievements on hardcore mode, which makes it so you're playing the game as if you were on the official hardware, meaning no save states or anything else that could make the achievements easier. Also, RetroAchievements will only work using emulators, so those of you rushing to your PS3s or Wiis... I'm sorry to disappoint you.

The achievements in the set follow a pretty straightforward pattern. There's an achievement per level for rescuing a nymph; per boss for defeating them; per world completed; per level for getting the Lum Medal, speed trophy and all Electoon Cages (which in turn actually gives the Lum Medals a purpose); per Tricky Treasure level for getting the skull teeth; for completing each mosquito level and boss (if there is one) without taking damage; for rescuing 10, 25, 50, 90, 130, 200 and all 246 Electoons in the game; for beating the Land of the Livid Dead; and for getting through that same stage without taking damage.

Annoying Atrium

But, the achievements that took me the longest time to get (and the ones which were an absolute pain) were the deathless achievements. These ones speak for themselves, you need to beat every level in its respective world without dying, quitting or restarting a stage. Those are Jungle Ray (Jibberish Jungle), Desert Ray (Desert of Dijiridoos), Ice Ray (Gourmand Land), Water Ray (Sea of Serendipity), Snow Ray (Mystical Pique), Plant Ray (Ticklish Temples), Composer Ray (Grumbling Grottos), Lava Ray (Luscious Lakes), Monster Ray (Angsty Abyss), and Metal Ray (Moody Clouds).

It should be noted that the Mosquito levels for each world (with the exception of Shoot for the Stars as it is part of the three-stage gauntlet for Moody Clouds) do not count towards these achievements, but the Tricky Treasure levels do. So that means if you want to get Plant Ray you have to beat Outta My Way, Up and Down, Climb Out, Still Flowing, Playing in the Shade and Poor Little Daisy all in a row without dying. I think you know why these achievements are annoying now.

But the achievement that took the longest out of all of them still holds up as the hardest achievement I have ever gotten, none other than Metal Ray. With an unlock rate of under 10% of people and 100 points, this achievement alone sets the tone for what agonizing pain this one will bring you.

So like the others, it is a deathless achievement - but in Moody Clouds, which had the hardest levels in the game due to it being the final world. That means you have to complete On Top of Old Smokey, Mecha No Mistake!, Tricky Temple Too, The Reveal, Get Away!, and Shoot for the Stars without dying. This seems easy, until you realize that each level has at least one thing which makes them dangerous to complete deathless.

  • On Top of Old Smokey: The precise platforming the the amount of hazards everywhere forces you to be EXTREMELY careful about what you do because all it can take is one poorly timed jump and it's back to the start.
  • Mecha No Mistake!: The same reasons as On Top of Old Smokey but the hazards and platforming are even more precise than that one.
  • Tricky Temple Too: It is a Tricky Treasure level so the annoyances for this one are obvious. The achievement for beating this level for the first time is even called "Kaizo Temple" and I honestly cannot think of a more fitting name.
  • The Reveal: Okay, in all honesty, this is the easiest level in this world as it is just a glorified boss rush. It is still absolutely possible to mess up here though.
  • Get Away!: This level takes platforming to the max, with you running up debris, making precise jumps and avoiding the saws.
  • Shoot for the Stars: You pretty much have to be alert at all times if you want to get through this level without dying. From the bombs, the small and big mechanical flies, the cannons and the red homing missiles, danger is everywhere here.

Oh and by the way, if you are going for this achievement, you HAVE to leave the three-stage gauntlet for last, and that's because upon completing Shoot for the Stars, you'll be teleported to the credits and from there the only way to leave is by either waiting them out (which kicks you back to the world map which resets the achievement) or to just pause and exit (which counts as exiting a level and thus resets the achievement).

And if you are wondering, the second most annoying achievement is getting the Lum Medal in Riding the Storm, but everyone had issues with that, so this isn't just a me thing.

Decision Dessert Place

If you want a new experience playing Rayman Origins, I absolutely recommend this set if you love good challenge. Just do expect to play the same levels over and over again for those deathless achievements.

Conclusion Centre

Just like the other games I went over, there isn't any substantial reward for getting 100%, though I guess the interactive credits when beating the Land of the Livid Dead at least counts for that. But hey, at least you get a message which congratulates you for mastering the set upon doing so!

Primative's Propaganda

Written by: Primative (talk)

Welcome back to my simian-scented soapbox! We're jumping from the early '80s of Donkey Kong's history to the mid '90s, with Donkey Kong (Game Boy)! But not before some 'naner-fueled nonsense for the Fall holiday, Kongsgiving!

Shroom236 Turkey Kong.png
Made only with vegetarian, banana-based turkey 💛
Shroom236 Kongsgiving Float.jpg
Tune in to watch Tiny's® Kongsgiving Day Parade!

Regarding the hidden message hunt, Power Flotzo found quite a bold message in the last article (they said it, not me) so Kongrats to them! For this issue, it will just be a vague question to hopefully not require additional hints via the forums or the Discord. The convoluted prompt is: What is the name of a game that's referenced here, where something is referenced by name but is actually from the future? When you harbor a guess, post it on the forum thread with your reasoning behind it!

Donkey Kong (1994)

North American box art for Donkey Kong on Game Boy
It's on, like... Donkey's palm!?

Donkey Kong, the Game Boy version, also known as Donkey Kong Game Boy and Donkey Kong '94, is an awesome remake of the original arcade game. It fully fleshes out the experience to serve as a handheld/home console release, builds on the base gameplay in several interesting ways, and is host to a solid amount of content. In a modern sense of the term, it serves as more of a "reboot" more of a remake, for the better. While there are some minor issues, like with control quirks and the replayability factor, it is largely a great time.

The title screen  (Super Game Boy version)
A Game Boy, with color!

It should be mentioned that this game served as a launch title for the Super Game Boy device on the Super Nintendo. The add-on could access extra assets on the Game Boy cartridge to add additional colors, game overlays, and improved sound bites to play through the SNES. Unfortunately, I currently don't have a legitimate means to access this extra content, as Nintendo Switch Online does not offer Super Game Boy functionality right now, even though it would be a great addition to the service. So, coverage of the game's presentation will be restricted to the classic "DMG" experience, aside from screenshots. Now onto this four-color fiasco of Pauline-plucking!

Gameplay


DKGB plays rather well, with clever level design and a fluid move set for our yet-to-be Super Mario here. It's fun to simply run around, perform copious backflips, and launch some showy handstand jumps. The backflip jump alone is a pretty major and powerful maneuver throughout the game. It's quite impressive how smooth this move feels in such a relatively constrained space. Entering the handstand position also offers a bit of horizontal movement, which can come in handy in a few later levels. Our plumber can now survive falls higher than his own height now, thankfully. After a minor fall, the player will briefly roll and drop whatever they were carrying in the direction they were facing. At a moderate height, the player will be stunned and can't move for a couple seconds. And after a major fall, Mario will sadly bonk his head and reach the big cloud level in the sky. To help prevent this demise, the ropes of Donkey Kong Jr. make their return, and let Mario show off his jungle-climbing skills to the monkeys first-hand! But like in the arcade game, and the later Donkey Kong Country games, they can feel a bit "sticky" to use. Our hero can also perform some impressive gymnastics by swinging rapidly from wires, offering a huge burst of vertical or diagonal distance. Also for climbing, Mario can now jump off of ladders and ropes, which also can be very useful, but he can't jump onto them in mid-air. While this can seem unintuitive, it makes some sense when considering that most levels are centered on routing keys throughout stage barriers.

Mario doing a High Jump from a Handstand
"That-a monkey can't-a move like 'dis!"

The objective of the majority of levels is to manually carry a comically-large key to a locked door to progress. This is a very similar process to unlocking doors in Doki Doki Mario (Bros. 2). Mario can also pick up some enemies and throw objects to defeat them like in the NES game. While holding an item, Mario can also be protected from one hit of a hostile entity and get stunned. Thankfully, there are some friendly monkeys and frogs to help the player find their way. However, regarding the key mechanic, SMB2 was more about finding specific keys, and not all of them were even necessary to finish a level. In DKGB here, the location of each key is always known, but it's about finding a valid path from the key to the door. This is the core "puzzle" element of the game's design. Sometimes the door will be obscured among identical fake doors, or outright blend into the background. Pauline's cries for help will actually serve a practical purpose to finding the way, especially in the Iceberg world. Also, when Mario drops a key, a timer activates that will cause the key to respawn at it's origin point if not picked up soon enough. Needing to transfer the key to different elevations or onto conveyors in the time window is a "key" (haha) element to test the player's reflexes.

Mario using the hammer
"He's-a lookin' to get-a whacked! Oh-hoo!"

While navigating each puzzle, several items can become vital for success. The Hammer returns here, of course, and now it has an amazing feature where Mario can throw the Hammer upwards to transfer it above platforms! The Hammer also gets a Super variant, which can break certain blocks in later levels. A deep-cut inclusion is the Poison Mushroom, named after the one in the Lost Levels, which really acts like the Mini Mushroom. There are also three level-altering blocks that add placeable temporary platforms, ladders, and springs to create an effective route for the key to reach the door. Some of these placements can interfere with other level mechanics, such as the placeable blocks being able to hold open the collapsible doors in Stage 5-11. These offer an new and interesting aspect to navigating the game, especially since their timers get reset each time a different one gets activated. These timers, combined with the key's idle timer, compound to give Mario a real run for his mon(k)ey across many levels. While the falling icicles aren't exactly an item, they can have the utility of one in that Mario can ride them while they slowly fall, which is pretty rad!

For the key-based levels, Mario will also be able to gather Pauline's three personal items. These will obviously grant the player some more points, but more importantly, they will activate a bonus mini-game after collecting all three and finishing the stage. This will either be a spin-the-wheel or slot machine game to score extra lives. The wheel game is relatively easy to score the highest payout of two or three lives, but I found the slot machine to be harder to master. There's no means to repeatedly practice the timing of the slots, it's no early-gen Game Corner slot machine, so fuhgeddaboudit! It's reasonable to expect one to two lives on average from entering either mini-game, so I recommend going for all items in each level to max out the life counter early. There are also a couple of different level types present in this remake.

A screenshot of 50m (Super Game Boy version)
50m is back and crunchier than ever!

Some other level types include simple "point A to point B" action stages, akin to the first three levels of Donkey Kong. The very first four stages here are a miniaturization of the arcade game, with 50m intact and 75m made simpler! A related callback is an identical level to that of Donkey Kong Jr.'s final level later in the game as Stage 9-4. Outside of World 0 and World 9, the linear stages generally crop up every four levels. Some of these levels may feature the big ape himself or his little guy DK Jr. performing time-based actions. Lumbering DK will sometimes smash the ground, which will cause deadly objects to fall randomly throughout a stage. This is a good extension of his typical barrel-throwing barrages. DK Jr. uses his wit over his fledgling strength, in that he will flip a switch that alters different level obstacles at random intervals. This mechanic isn't so different from the original 50m having its conveyors change direction on a monkey-based meter of time. These are great additions to the variety of obstacles found in both the puzzle and action-oriented stages. After every four levels, the total time score earned determines a number of extra lives be granted by increments of 100, plus an extra life for any final remainder under 100 seconds. Also, each level has a specific total time amount, which is a nice touch.

Stage 7-7 of Donkey Kong for the Game Boy
This place isn't squiddin' around!

A number of levels can have very clever placements of enemies and other objects, with a highlight being Stage 2-1 starting Mario on a ladybug, which non-verbally communicates to the player that they can safely stand on those bugs. Stage 7-1 sets up the walking fireball enemies to show the player how they can melt ice blocks by touching them. Also in the Iceberg, Stage 7-7 has a dastardly Blooper-like enemy that can pop up at the end of the intended level path, which gave me a good laugh. And Stage 7-11 can trick the player into thinking they soft-locked their game, but really they just need to wait for a fireball to walk around to free them from a self-imposed ice prison. Stage 8-8 has some rideable boulders, much like the ones in Super Mario Land. And the verticality of Stage 9-5 allows for Mario to make a sweet set of backflips to rapidly reach the top, which is a great reward for players who have mastered this skill by the late-game. A couple of levels that I found difficult or contrived were stages 4-6, 6-6, and 8-11, mostly for having tightly-timed sequences. Though, timing is always important when it comes to the boss battles with the great ape.

Screenshot of 9-9 from Donkey Kong.
It's a super simian!

The final level of each world will be a boss stage, aside from World 0. The boss stages take place on standard, Battlefield-like arenas where Donkey Kong throws barrels or similar objects, in which Mario needs to pick them back up and score three hits on the ape to win. The specific mechanic of using Mario's handstand to protect him from falling objects is very useful or outright necessary here. It feels gratifying to give the monkey his own medicine here, more so then just plotting his literal downfall by pulling out stage bolts. The final boss, found on Stage 9-10, is quite the spectacle. DK grows big, appropriating copious amounts of Super Mushrooms to become properly King Kong-sized. Mario must endure several phases, continuing to throw barrels at the kingly Kong, but also dodging more falling obstacles and two giant monkey hands from squishing him into lasagna sheets. The fight is very cool, but it does feel like it can drag on a bit. It's at least very appropriate that the Donkey Kong series fully delivers on a skyscraper-sized simian squabble!

Mario doing a Spin from a wire
*indiscernible Italian noises*

While the player movement model generally feels very good, there are a few shortcomings that can be a bit annoying. When Mario rolls after falling a medium amount of height, there is a delay before he can jump again. This is to slightly punish the player for falling, less so than outright stunning or killing them, but it can feel bad to be locked to that move or even cause the player to fall into an obstacle from a lack of control. Also, getting to grips with, well, physically getting to grips with the wires to perform acrobatics can take a little getting used to. At least for me, it took some trial-and-error to remember to hold the Up button in mid-air to grab onto a wire, and then hold it to perform a Spin Jump. I know that sounds kind of dumb of me, and maybe it is, but I was expecting for Mario to simply grab onto wires automatically, and not require another timed input for mounting onto them. An automatic move that is present occurs when Mario is near the very top of a ladder, where if the player stops moving, then Mario will finish climbing the ladder to the top on his own. I assume this is to prevent being stuck on ladders like in the original arcade game, but it can throw off a player the first time. Another possible "skill issue" is that I find that it's very easy to drop keys by falling a small amount of height. This does add to the game's challenge and puzzle navigation, but it can happen a lot during a playthrough. Also, it's not always obvious which characters are dangerous, which areas of them may be deadly, and if throwing objects at them will kill them. And the Hammer hitbox can feel a bit off at times, especially when trying to destroy the dangerous seeds that launch on Stage 8-7.

Big-City world's level select screen (Super Game Boy version)
"Heh, replay this, buddy!" 👊💥

The game's general structure seems to be missing a couple quality-of-life features, at least some that were present in Super Mario Land 2. Replay value would have been significantly boosted if it was more intuitive to replay levels by using the map screen. The player needs to exit the game, re-select the save file, and then roll back the playthrough sequence in specific four-level increments just to replay a level. This seems rather needless and complicated, especially if someone wants to hop around different levels across different worlds. This is better than having zero options to replay levels in the same save, but it is still not ideal. Mario Land 2, developed earlier by another core Nintendo team, had an appropriate layout for this mechanic through its map.

DKGB also does not appear to track performance metrics across levels very much. The only meaningful record that is tracked is the time score earned for each level, through a "report card" type of screen selectable from the in-game pause menu. It is possible to replay stages to boost these scores, but a full four-level set must be completed for the times to be overwritten. Also, collecting all three of Pauline's items is not documented after the given level. And the overall scoring system doesn't matter, since the game will never record the player's best score before powering-down the system or finishing the game. A high score would need to be manually written down before ending a play session or entering the final boss, as it isn't even shown in the ending sequence. It would have been nice gestures to have time score targets, item collection tracking, and a high score table to encourage replaying the overall game. These omissions can be common of other games on the system. However, it is still a bit disappointing, since this is a relatively late release for it. Again, I feel that Nintendo "knew better" for laying out these aspects of platformers on the Game Boy by the mid-90's.

Overall, the gameplay of Donkey Kong '94 is very strong and memorable. There are several callbacks and innovations upon the series' limited history at the time, as well as offering some foreshadowing for further additions in its successors. Dwelling on the fact that the game houses over 100 levels, it could seem like the game would drag on. But with how everything is organized and paced-out, it's really hard to put the game down. If anything, there are several mechanics that could have been utilized to a greater extent, which is a good takeaway for making the player leaving wanting more and not less.

Graphics


Super Game Boy North American Boxart Bundle
Get supped-up!

Constraining the visuals to their four-color rendition, and not using a Super Game Boy, the game fares rather well on a visual front. The level designs themselves are plenty "gamey", and don't resemble realistic structures of course. But some can incorporate the worlds theme by taking a plausible form using level blocks. Examples include a ship's mast being used for a boss encounter on Stage 3-8, and the side of a pyramid serving as a barrier in Stage 5-7. Many levels feature pleasant, scenic backdrops to the puzzling and platforming, especially those taking place outdoors. Some highlights include the luscious forest mountaintop shown in Stage 4-6, and some highly-detailed pyramids in the aforementioned Desert world. These are obviously enhanced by the Super Game Boy quite significantly, but even that 16-bit boost can't help that the full backdrop will likely be not fully viewable to the player during gameplay. There is quite often some "screen-crunch", obscuring parts of the level from view, which is a bummer for trying to appreciate a level's overall design and background graphics. This was largely unavoidable for the old Game Boy, but it especially noticeable when playing the game normally, and then viewing the full screenshots of levels like those available here.

The Game Over screen of Donkey Kong for the Game Boy when played on Game Boy Color or Game Boy Advance
Don't doubt DK!

A graphical feature that is not hindered by a lack of colors or pixels are the various cutscenes that play throughout the game. These feature some lovely, sprite-based slapstick when Mario and DK are butting heads. But more importantly, most of them, especially early on, serve a very useful purpose of illustrating how various game mechanics work. For example, the scene after Stage 2-4 shows that Mario can deflect falling barrels by being in a handstand position, in which he can then pick up the barrel and graciously barreling it back to DK. This is a vital piece of information to be used in several boss stages later in the game. These scenes can also show how the placeable blocks work, along with other level objects. All of these help to ensure the player is prepared for upcoming challenges, and not relying on them referring to the manual to progress. There is a strange scene after Stage 8-12, where it appears that Mario can run across lava while on fire, which can sometimes be possible in later games, but is not possible here. This may have been a cut mechanic that was left a remnant in this cutscene. Either way it's always funny to see the old bro get a bit torched.

Some nitpicks I have include some visual miscommunication with classifying certain objects. In the early levels that feature wires, they can be tucked away to not be obvious to the player, which is a bit odd. Specifically on Stage 8-1, it can be difficult to see the underwater platforms towards the center of the stage, where they may unintentionally appear as part of the background. Also throughout World 8, it can occasionally be difficult to discern water from lava, which should not be confusing to the player! On some lighter notes, it looks like the same "M" icon is used on the map screen here as it is used in Super Mario Bros. 3. The collapsible doors here look a bit like those from the classic Mega Man series. The little screenshots of Mario hopping around on the time score screens are nice. Also, I enjoyed seeing the hedgehog-like enemies on Stage 8-2, with the interesting design choice to allow the player to avoid releasing them by not destroying the collapsible blocks. It's as if Miyamoto himself was threatened by the release of some hedgehog!

Sound


The music and sound here, even the lower-quality DMG renditions here, are pretty good. Most world themes fit their aesthetic pretty well, especially for the Jungle world. Certain sound effects work their way into compositions like those for the Ship and Airplane worlds. The Airplane theme even sounds a bit like the James Bond movie theme! The rushed music that plays when a level's timer is running out goes hard. Most of the end-game music is quite good, serving as a good build-up to the final confrontation and reward for knocking out that silly simian. The unofficially named tracks "Scaling The Tower" and "Staff Roll" are very good for those purposes. I would even go so far to say that later composers that use Game Boy sound equipment like Jake Kaufman have directly sampled or at least taken inspiration from this soundtrack. Some negatives are that many songs are very short, can feature a weird squeaky sound bite, or sound like a drunken Mario hobbling through the wrong sewer pipe. However, there is very much one track to rule them all here.

Screenshot of 9-8 from Donkey Kong.
Rocky Kong! 🎸

The penultimate boss stage 9-8 features a track unofficially dubbed "Showdown At The Tower". This one-and-a-half minute tune absolutely blew my mind when I first heard it back in the day. I originally played the 3DS release of the game in the early 2010s, and I hadn't really heard a chiptune that evoked the sound of a specific, real instrument in quite the same way. It basically features a full-on electric guitar solo, one that ramps up repeatedly with ever-increasing speed and grace. I need to emphasize that this track has been burned into my cranky cranium for the better part of 15 years. In retrospect, it really is just a humble, bit-based ditty (a "bitty", as one may say), but no other song in this game, or any similar original first-party Game Boy games, has this kind of compositional progression. It is a largely unsung achievement for composer Taisuke Araki to have gotten this into the game. The full tune is actually easy to miss out on if you finish the boss battle too early, which is a bummer. It could have even been considered to be the final final boss music, but the way things are seem okay enough. If there's any single takeaway from this review, just know this song is really cool!

Regarding sound effects, it seems I kind of Mandela Effect-ed myself when I asked for Pauline to have a voice clip in the original Donkey Kong arcade game. She indeed has a voice clip now, but her cry plays both before and after every level, which gets a bit grating. I mean, I've never been kidnapped by a huge ape and his kid, so I can't properly sympathize with her freaking out, but it's not like Mario is going to skimp out on saving her! Diegetically, her cries do help Mario to discern the fake and hidden doors in some levels, so they at least have a purpose there. Overall, the sound design is functional and informative. One of my favorite bits is when Mario performs a double handstand jump. It sounds quite grandiose, as if he's gloating about his peppy, non-Mushroom-enhanced performance.

Story


Dust cover for Shogakukan's 「任天堂公式ガイドブック ドンキーコング」 (Nintendo Kōshiki Guidebook – Donkey Kong) (ISBN 4-09-102485-8)
It's wild and whacky, don't tell Wrinkly!

Despite the sweet lore drop at the very end of the game, there's predictably not too much to comment on story within the game itself. The basic plot is nearly identical as the original, but with a few more additions such as Donkey Kong Jr.'s direct involvement with Pauline's kidnapping. I guess it is interesting that the Kongs already know how to use different types of mushrooms? The big deal is that the final cutscene shows Mario becoming Super, thanks to Pauline tossing him a Super Mushroom and growing bigger. The background also shows that they have arrived in the Mushroom Kingdom at the end of the journey. This is a very cool ending, and it is rather uncommon across these mainline games for an actual connection between worlds like this, along with a basic chronology of events. Admittedly, I am obsessing over these small details, but it is all we got for world-building here! Related to world-building, there is the fact that the game's events have been adapted into two manga volumes, along with a bit in Super Mario-kun. From what little I've seen of them, they seem like rather odd and fittingly manga-style tales. In the end, it is a slightly more fleshed-out tale of manic monkeys and a super guy saving the girl.

Conclusion


Pauline, Mario, Donkey Kong, and Donkey Kong Jr. in the ending credits.
🎶 "Let's do the Donk-yssey!" 🎶

While this game does not completely replace the original, it certainly accomplishes a lot more as an overall experience and holds up quite well. Surprisingly, I would argue that the arcade game, by simple nature of its platform, is slightly more replayable than DK '94. This is not a very fair comparison for several reasons, but I do want to note that I spent about six hours playing the arcade game in working to beat difficulty mode #4, whereas the Game Boy game only took five hours to reach its definitive end. I also have much more nostalgia for this game over the arcade version, especially since I will remember the melody of "Showdown At The Tower" until this cranky old coot croaks! So I think it is interesting that I happened to spend more time with the arcade classic in more present day.

Regardless of any incorrect opinions comparing this to the original game, I entirely recommend Donkey Kong '94 to any fan of action games, the Super Mario series, and of course the Donkey Kong series. If Wrinkly was still around to school the young'uns, she would definitely assign the game as "required reading". Thanks for headstand-hopping back here!

Anton's Half-Baked Reviews

Written by: Hypnotoad (talk)
Art by: Woglril

The perfect flavor...

Fall 2026 - Part 2


I’ve made a mistake. I got too eager for a seasonal multi-parter that I ended up getting an overwhelming amount of treats again that I’m sitting here thinking about if I need to shove the reds and greens out of the way for December to continue the oranges and browns, which would really be juicy karma, wouldn’t it? Nevertheless, despite seeing so much innovation in Febreze scents and body washes, the autumnal food landscape seems to have slid back into a comfortable pumpkin spice hole, at least within my own local bubble and various bits of outreach to other regions. Maybe companies are too focused on what else they can turn into a hot honey or pistachio cash grab, unable to put any time or investment into maybe more maple, more cider, more pears, figs, blood orange even, it’s about time we give cranberries what they’re owed with greater year-end prominence. This is America and we’re known for overflowing options, plentiful abundance, and I demand more creativity and revolutionary action in my branded snacks!

McDonald’s McCafé Caramel Apple Pie Frappé


Could they not afford another scoop of topping?
Every now and then I’ll get something from McDonald’s because it’s just what’s there; I’m driving home from a club at 2am and I’m hungry and 20pc McNuggets with a prepper-quantity amount of dipping sauces alongside lava hot crispy heart attack salt fries and industrial strength Sprite is exactly what I need. Like any smart person, I’ve given my location and personal information to McDonald’s so that I can utilize their app for $1 fries and 20% off orders where–in a moment of suggestibility–I saw that there was a new seasonal ice cream-adjacent treat and I threw money at it, and now here we are. I can’t say I’ve gotten many Frappés from McDonald’s or really anything from their McCafé area since they ruined milkshakes, more often a Frappuccino from Starbucks, though they’re both in the realm of turning what a traditional frappé actually is into as close to a milkshake as they possibly can before utilizing ice cream.

There’s no timeline for the Caramel Apple Pie Frappé besides the release date of August 17th, 2026, but their Menu Spotter shows cookie butter and holiday flavors arriving October 27th and place on the website has already been taken over, so I’m sure it’s just a matter of remaining warehouse stock and what individual shops have hoarded. I think we as a society need to get tackle this problem two-fold: we need to get over ourselves and accept that in order to prepare for upcoming seasons and holidays that seasonal and holiday items will need to be available for purchase before those times arrive (i.e. Halloween decor is ok to appear in August, Christmas is ok in November, etc.), but also that these seasonal and holiday items need to be available throughout their respective seasons instead of disappearing soon into or before they really even bloom. We need to be knocking on McDonald’s corporate office windows making demands, we need to be holding their flavor scientists accountable, we need to pull out the pillories and make examples, it’s that serious.

This Frappé, along with the other drinks and beverages in this lineup, are all rendered on-theme with the same Caramel Apple Pie flavored syrup, and I’m not sure why it’s called Caramel Apple Pie because it tastes more exactly like a (fake, bit too sweet) caramel apple itself with the particular cold fresh sweetness rather than any baked or doughy elements. I’m not immediately sure what the crunchy stuff–billed as ‘crumbled apple pie bites’– on top actually was or what it was supposed to accomplish as it hits a similar gripe I have with every other drinkable treat that garnishes the whipped cream on top, that it needs to be able to blend well into the rest of the drink without compromising itself or any other part. Unfortunately, this one falls into a gripeable category as it just gets soggy and sinks, never giving any feel of pie crust beyond visible aesthetics, and does nothing to steer the candy apple fake flavor towards what it’s meant to be, but a saving grace is it also doesn’t really do much of anything to it at all unlike how Oreo pieces can clog up a straw. Other reviews look like they got A LOT more of the crumble slop on top of theirs while I had a pathetic offering, but still had the same complaints, and a similar conclusion: the drink would’ve been fine just as ‘caramel apple’ without any of the crunchy nonsense and still fit the seasonal bill.

I get that the point of this on their menu is to cut into the market and profit margins of more specialty coffee shops like Starbucks, Dunkin’, or local cafés by providing a cheaper alternative, but I think this is just one of those things where you just need to go to a proper place for it and leave the McDonald’s drive thru for something more simple and streamlined. I do appreciate that it’s not a pumpkin spice flavor, though, and helps to expand cultural consciousness of what fall and winter can offer, but all it really does is check off a box rather than actually tasting good.

M&Ms Pumpkin Pie


I love using seasonal M&Ms as filler decor
Over the last…oh god, decade plus…M&Ms has had multiple iterations of pumpkin spice, from the original Pumpkin Spice in 2013, Pumpkin Spice Latte in 2015, and White Pumpkin Pie in 2017. Perhaps now, in 2024 with the release of their milk chocolate Pumpkin Pie flavor that they have had return for the 2025 and 2026 seasons, Mars Inc. has gotten ahold of the cacao shortage crisis or perhaps realized that turning all beloved candies into a white vegetable oil homunculus only brings short-term net profits at the cost of consumer trust and good will.

Strange smell immediately from the bag, but honestly not as strong as their other flavors in this enlarged solid chocolate format are and not really anything unexpected. The flavor isn’t ‘pumpkin pie’, exactly, but it’s within the realm of believability. It’s fallish, fourth quartery, warm flavors of cinnamon and nutmeg though and it’s a particular kind of cinnamon, it’s got a tiny spicy cinnamon oil kick that you’d get in Big Red gum or cinnamon candies rather than a softer taste you’d get in, say, cinnamon rolls. I don’t like that I have to nitpick the wording of flavors but there’s significant nuance between pumpkin spice and pumpkin pie, and if something is called ‘pumpkin pie’ I want to be able to taste pumpkin and crust. Perhaps they wanted to avoid the big name association but it leaves room for misinterpretation and inaccuracies that sets the stage for disappointing people buying this imagining something they’re not actually going to get. That being said, these are in a similar vein as the last time I reviewed seasonal M&Ms, wherein the Toasty Holiday Peanut tasted uncanny and horrifically fake while the Holiday Mint was simple and straightforward; the Pumpkin Pie M&M’s strengths are entirely in its subtlety that allows a little bit of gluttonous munching that allows you to enjoy the little change in flavor without making you wretch and regret not just getting a standard bag.

Furthermore, on a more personal level, I’m sick of it and will fight to make it illegal to only have limited edition flavor information only available on websites for a month or two as it should all be archived for retention and reference purposes.

LaClare Creamery Pumpkin Goat Cheese


Any excuse to use my gator knife, really
One of my favorite parts of the holidays arriving is seeing all of the seasonal and limited time cheeses being brought in and displayed, and among them I caught a Pumpkin Goat Cheese by LaClare Creamery. LaClare Creamery always has unique and fun flavors that I unfortunately can never find, like, do I really need to go to Wisconsin to get my hands on their Lemon Bar flavor?? And their typical placement at mostly higher end mostly natural food stores makes them difficult to find unless you li