User talk:Soshi The Yoshi

Hey!

Hey, Sosh'! I'd've never expected you to register on the Mariowiki! Welcome aboard! -- FanOfYoshi at 12:25, June 9, 2024 (EDT)

About turning themes linked on the Template:Themes template into redirects and replacing them with section links

I have noticed that you've turned Cranky's Theme, Star World (Map Screen) and Business-Use Mario Name Entry to be redirects of Opening (Donkey Kong), Invincibility BGM and Ground BGM (Super Mario Bros.), respectively, and then replaced the redirects on {{Themes}} with section links. While that does make sense normally speaking, I don't think it's the right call in this case: the reason why these three themes in particular have been listed on the Themes nav template in the first place is because they're eligible to have their own dedicated article, as per Template talk:Themes/Eligible themes. Turning them into redirects and changing these links to section links on their original version kind of misses the point on why they're listed on the Themes template in the first place; might as well list any recurring variant of a theme if redirects were allowed on the nav template. That's why I've reverted these edits on the Themes template and tagged the redirects for rewriting/expansion. Ideally, the three redirects should be turned into their own dedicated articles while including their variants as listed on Template talk:Themes/Eligible themes, instead of plain redirects. Sorry for the inconvenience. rend (talk) (edits) 11:55, February 19, 2025 (EST)