Talk:Blue Shell

From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search

This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Blue Shell article. It is not a forum for general discussion of the article's subject. Comments such as "Mario is my favorite character" are not allowed and will be removed on sight. Please use the Mario Boards or our Discord server to talk about Blue Shell.

If you do have a question or comment about the article, please remember to sign your edit with ~~~~.

Wrongo[edit]

Wrongo this article is. Super Mario World is NOT the only game where Troopas wear Blue Shells. In Mario vs. Luigi mode of New Super Mario Bros., a Koopa is wearing one in the winter course. — The preceding unsigned comment was added by Dodoman (talk).

This article needs to be moved to Spiny Shell.User:Xterra1/sig

Not all Blue Shells are of the Spiny variety. -- Son of Suns

Well, the Buzzy on the "Not to be confused with ..." is referring to the enemies that appearing in the mario series. I hope you like it all. 180.249.2.7 23:35, 23 August 2014 (EDT)

MKDD[edit]

In Mario's Circuit there are these poles that have Blue Shell On Them. Should we add this?Fuzzy in New Super Mario Bros. UYoshiGo99Artwork of a Yoshi egg on a tilt. It is unknown whether this artwork was released with a certain game or not. Also used as a profile icon for the Nintendo Switch from version 1.0.0 to version 19.0.1.

Unorganized[edit]

There needs to be another headline for it's appearances in mainstream Mario games. The article doesn't feel right without it. --Walleo 16:42, 31 May 2012 (EDT)

Mario Kart 7 Koopa Cape[edit]

Koopa cape is a retro track in mk7 and a blue shell can be driven through. mario kart 7 should be the latest appearance and not bowsers inside story. it is not a giant blue shell, because that is from mario strikers charged. and this shell is much bigger. either leave my edit or make a new article called "Humongous drivable through blue shell".

turtlelordX TurtlelordX (talk) 18:17, 17 November 2014 (EST)

Yoshi Wings[edit]

Can I write that Yoshi gets Wings if he eats a blue Shell in SMW? BTW, I`m new at the Wiki.... --New Super Mario Maker (talk) 09:21, 24 July 2015 (EDT)

It's already stated: "It can make any Yoshi fly instantly upon putting one in its mouth." The wing detail isn't present, although that's an easy fix. Sprite of Mario's icon in Mario Party DS It's me, Mario! (Talk / Stalk) 14:32, 24 July 2015 (EDT)

Blue shell is not in oddessy[edit]

It isn't on the page Wariopig (talk) 17:59, 3 June 2018 (EDT)Wariopig

But it is on the page. It says one of the Roving Racers wears a Blue Shell. Marie costume pose in Super Mario Maker Mario JC 21:58, 3 June 2018 (EDT)
As does the Trace-Walker in the Snow Kingdom, but it doesn't appear as a distinct item. Doc von Schmeltwick (talk) 23:32, 3 June 2018 (EDT)

Rewrite Requested[edit]

A Rewrite was reqested so I rewrote it and I want to see if it meets quality standards. Also, I want to know if I should remove the Pirate Goomba line (Blue shells are blue koopa troopa shells) in the opening. — The preceding unsigned comment was added by PrinceFluff (talk).

...What?[edit]

Wait, it says that blue shells show up in Tennis Aces, but it doesn't say where. And now I'm curious, because I beat the game, but I haven't seen them. Can we get that info on here? Magolor04726 (talk) 21:53, February 26, 2020 (EST)Magolor04726

I plan on expanding this article in the future, but um yeah Blue Koopa Troopa, a swap-able color in Mario Tennis Aces goes inside its shell and dashes inside of it instead of running, that's what it's referring to. You would get that colored Koopa Troopa in the Online Tournaments. --Gamermakerguy (talk) 22:31, February 26, 2020 (EST)

Why does the shell now have spikes and wings in games like MK8? -Oct 31 10:29 I know i'm late but I believe that this is a good question and people deserve to know *hint hint game theory— The preceding unsigned comment was added by 76.23.212.22 (talk).

That's the blue Spiny Shell, which has existed since Mario Kart 64. It's already listed in a hatnote on this article. Toadette icon from Captain Toad: Treasure TrackerFont of Archivist Toadette's signature(T|C) 22:32, October 31, 2020 (EDT)

Split Blue Shell and Blue Shell (Mario Strikers)[edit]

Brown Block This talk page proposal has already been settled. Please do not edit this section or its subsections. If you wish to discuss the article, please do so in a new section below the proposal.

Do not split 2-10
They are fundamentally entirely different items. They also look very different.

Proposer: Shyguy85 (talk)
Deadline: August 30, 2024, 23:59 (UTC)

Support[edit]

  1. Shyguy85 (talk) Per proposal.
  2. SeanWheeler (talk) Why does the Mario Kart item have a separate page?

Oppose[edit]

  1. DryBonesBandit (talk) Saying they look "very different" only applies to Mario Strikers Charged, where they look icy, so the "difference in appearance" argument doesn't really make sense. Besides, they have different abilities in literally every game they appear in not counting remakes, so this proposal's arguments are not strong enough in my opinion to warrant a split.
  2. Super Mario RPG (talk) These are Blue Koopa Shells featured in different contexts.
  3. Tails777 (talk) I was about to support on the grounds that two games treat it as a power-up and one as a weapon, but then I remembered that the Fire Flower is basically the same thing, just without a slight visual change.
  4. Waluigi Time (talk) Per all.
  5. Mario (talk) There's likely plenty of other items with shared appearances and different functions (Spiny Shell). Blue Shells only got really an appearance change in Mario Strikers Charged, the sequel of the game that provided Blue Shells that do the same thing, but look more like standard blue shells.
  6. ThePowerPlayer (talk) The Blue Shell from Mario Strikers Charged is still a blue shell, is referred to as such by the game, and looks identical aside from the shell texture.
  7. FanOfRosalina2007 (talk) Per all.
  8. PaperSplash (talk) Per all.
  9. Pizza Master (talk) Though the Blue Shells of NSMB 1 and Strikers 1 function differently, they look the same in both games and are likely the same item. This would be like splitting Ice Flower and Ice Flower (Super Mario Galaxy).
  10. Sparks (talk) Per all.

Comments[edit]

Let's look at every appearance of this Blue Shell item and see how different they are:

  • Super Mario World - Worn by Koopas and used by Mario the exact same way as any other Koopa Shell; but if any Yoshi puts it into its mouth, it can fly, much like after a Blue Yoshi puts a Green Shell in its mouth.
  • Super Mario Strikers/Mario Strikers Charged - Thrown like any other Shell in the game; can freeze targets.
  • New Super Mario Bros./Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story - Transforms Mario into Shell Mario (the ONLY time a Blue Shell doesn't work like any other Koopa Shell in the game); it allows him to shell dash, but he cannot kick the shell away like other Koopa Shells.
  • Super Mario Galaxy - Visual-only difference; when Cosmic Mario picks up a Koopa Shell, it turns blue. Otherwise, it's just a regular Koopa Shell (worn by Koopas and can be thrown but also allows for better and more precise underwater movement)
  • Super Mario 3D World - Visual-only difference; when Toad enters an empty Koopa Shell, it turns blue, much like how it'll turn red if Mario enters it, pink if Peach enters it, or cyan if Rosalina enters it. Otherwise, it's just a regular Koopa Shell (Worn by Koopas and can be thrown but also allows players to enter it and shell dash)

This tells me that a Blue Shell's effect varies between games and is not just a Strikers quirk. Most of the Blue Shells do share the commonality of working just like any other color Koopa Shell in their respective games but with an additional effect... but so does the Blue Shell in Strikers so that doesn't make it distinct enough to warrant a split. In fact, I feel like the New Super Mario Bros. one actually warrants a split MORE than the Strikers one purely because you cannot kick it away like any other Koopa Shell in that game, making it actually more different from the other shells of that game than any other Blue Shells of their respective games... but then again, its ability, the shell slide, is precisely what you expect from a Koopa Shell anyway, and that very same ability is given to any player carrying ANY Koopa Shell in Super Mario 3D World (where Blue Shells only are a thing because they needed to color-code a Blue Shell worn by Toad), making it STILL not distinct enough to warrant a split.
As for visuals, almost all of them look nearly identical, looking just like any other Koopa Shell but in a blue hue instead of green or red; it's the exact same blue hue across all of these. Strikers Charged is the only time they actually don't share that look, being cyan and frosted instead. But it works exactly the same as in Super Mario Strikers, in which they do still look exactly the same as any other Blue Shell, so I don't think this one appearance change warrants a split. It's like splitting the Super Mario World Fire Flower because they turned into tulips there for some reason.
Ergo, it doesn't really warrant splitting. It's all varied effects that have SOMETHING in common aside from the color, and the one time it actually looks different is also from a sequel of a game in which it has the same effect (meaning it's intended to be the same item) and yet looks EXACTLY THE SAME as the other Blue Shells anyway.
So, in conclusion:

ArendLogoTransparent.pngrend (talk) (edits) 12:00, August 18, 2024 (EDT)

If they are similar enough but with different functions, why not merge the Spiny Shell (blue) into this article? Everyone calls the Mario Kart item a Blue Shell and it's another blue Koopa shell. Only difference is the spikes and wings. SeanWheeler (talk) 19:33, August 30, 2024 (EDT)
That ain't a Koopa Troopa's shell, that's a Spiny's shell. It doesn't matter what "everyone" calls it. Doc von Schmeltwick (talk) 19:36, August 30, 2024 (EDT)
It's been pretty much called Spiny Shell consistently as possible despite common lexicon misnaming this item as "blue shell". I am also one of the few people who calls that thing a Spiny Shell. Sprite of Mario's icon in Mario Party DS It's me, Mario! (Talk / Stalk) 19:41, August 30, 2024 (EDT)

Split the power-up?[edit]

I think the Blue Shell from NSMB and Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story should be split. First, because it's the same power- up with the same form and mechanics, and second, most (if not almost everyone) who searches for Blue Shell searches for the specific power-up that transforms you into Shell Mario. Seeing that it is consistent between two games (that aren't even part of the same series) and its likely going to be searched more than the other Blue Shells on the page, it should be split imo. It could be split as Blue Shell (power-up) or we could split it and instead rename this page as Blue Shell (object). I think this situation is overall similar to Buzzy Shell (helmet) and Spiny Shell (helmet) Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 01:25, October 10, 2026 (UTC)

Such a split would leave us in a bind, as we don't know if the Blue Shell model in the files of Mario Kart 7 is supposed to be like the power-up or not. Any pitch for splitting the page should also decide which page the Mario Kart 7 section here ends up. Salmancer (talk) 01:45, October 10, 2026 (UTC)
"A model of a Blue Shell exists in Mario Kart 7's game files." Doesn't help that much either. I'd say that as we don't know how it would act, it should be left here with the other different Blue Shells. Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 01:50, October 10, 2026 (UTC)
I would definitely support splitting the NSMBDS powerup. Its current situation heavily reminds of the situation that the "Colored caps" used to be in, for all the wrong reasons... Wandering Poplin (talk) 03:06, October 10, 2026 (UTC)

Split (proposal)[edit]

Brown Block This talk page proposal has already been settled. Please do not edit this section or its subsections. If you wish to discuss the article, please do so in a new section below the proposal.

do not split 3-3-7

See the discussion above. I want to split the power-up that allows the player to become Shell Mario, which appeared in two games : New Super Mario Bros. and Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story. There are plenty of reasons for this.

First, obviously , it acts very differently from the rest of the blue shells here, as the rest are more like objects/items ; this one is a power-up. Second, in its two appearances, it is visually and mechanically identical and consistent , which is incredible considering that the two games aren't even part of the same series in any way. Third, most (if not almost everyone) who searches for Blue Shell is more likely to be searching for the specific power-up with two significant appearances in two well-known games than for the rest of the minor objects on the page. I would dare to say that this is the Blue Shell.

Aside from being blue, there is zero indication that this Blue Shell is even remotely the same as the rest on this page ; even the Japanese name just calls them shell instead of blue shell. Being consistently different from the rest of the shells on this page, and being the more likely to be searched, I propose to split them. Similar to the proposal that got Buzzy Shell (helmet) and Spiny Shell (helmet) split. Depending on the consensus of this proposal, maybe we should revisit those and similar cases.

I know that another proposal about splitting the Mario Strikers Charged blue shell was made, but this case and proposal, in particular, are fairly different.

Proposer: Mr. Sorbetti (talk)
Deadline: October 24, 2026, 23:59 (UTC)

Split as Blue Shell and rename this page as Blue Shell (object)[edit]

  1. Mr. Sorbetti (talk) Per proposal.
  2. The Real Blue Shell Fan (talk) Primary option. Per proposal.
  3. Wandering Troopa (talk) Secondary option. Mind you, this is the one I would actually prefer to succeed, but I would also imagine that the below option is more aligned with wiki policy. (probably)

Split as Blue Shell (power-up)[edit]

  1. Mr. Sorbetti (talk) Per proposal.
  2. The Real Blue Shell Fan (talk) Secondary option. Per proposal.
  3. Wandering Shellcreeper (talk) Primary option. Ideally, I would like to give the NSMBDS power-up priority in terms of the title, But on the other hand, the non-transforming Blue Shell has appeared in more games, and is overall more recognizable. (Second only to the frequently mis-nammed Spiny Shell)

#Wilben (talk) The regular Blue Shell object has more appearances than the power-up, so it would be the subject that will be "more likely to be searched for or linked to" per MarioWiki:Article naming#Shared titles.

Do nothing[edit]

  1. Hewer (talk) I think this is more accurately a case of the same thing in different roles. The NSMB item absolutely is a blue Koopa Troopa shell (it was even called "Blue Koopa Shell" in an NSMB guidebook, and you can shell dash with it just like you do with the Koopa Troopa shells in 3D World), which makes it the same subject as everything else being covered on this page. Splitting it would mean failing to give the reader a full history of the item on one page. It would be like splitting Bullet Bill because it's an item in the Mario Kart series and an enemy in other games, or splitting Bowser because he's a playable character in some games and a boss in others. I don't understand why the fact that it functions the same in Bowser's Inside Story has anything to do with it being distinct from the other things on the page. The argument of "people will search for the power-up" also makes no sense, you're speaking as though those people will be disappointed to end up at this page even though it already covers the power-up information they'd be looking for. If anything the split is just a net negative for navigation because it's equally convenient for people who do want power-up information and less convenient for people who want the other appearances. I also think that the Buzzy and Spiny helmet splits were a mistake, I opposed those as well.
  2. Arend (talk) Much like I stated in a prior proposal about splitting the Mario Strikers Blue Shell, I don't think the NSMB one warrants a split per se. The main ability you get from the power up, the shell dash, is something you expect any Koopa Shell to work like, including the blue Shell in Mario World, and is also a move you can do with any shell in 3D World (especially since when Toad enters a shell to perform this ability, it turns blue).
  3. Wilben (talk) Per Hewer and Arend. We don't split the Bullet Bill and Bob-omb items in the Mario Kart series and the Super Smash Bros. for having different roles, so why would we split this?
  4. Iand255 (power-up) (talk) Per all.
  5. Pseudo (talk) Per all, it comes from a blue Koopa and everything.
  6. Xiahou Ba, The Nasty Warrior (talk) Per Hewer.
  7. Tails777 (talk) Like the previous proposal, I was tempted to support this, but there are still a few reasons why I feel it's best to keep it all in one article. As per last time, the Fire Flower is also an item and a power-up, yet we don't split its functions there. Second, in a bit more of a possible look to the future, having all the information on one page for the Blue Shell would probably be better if there was ever a time we end up creating articles for other multi-colored subjects. Regardless, I do agree in some way with the idea, but I feel the reasons to keep it all together are just a bit stronger.

(Comments)[edit]

For the record, I am willing to change the identifier of the first option if there is a recommendation. Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 18:41, October 10, 2026 (UTC)

Considering the Blue Shell is an item in Super Mario Strikers and Mario Strikers Charged, and can be carried in Super Mario World, I'm pretty sure that option one should result in a "Blue Shell (item)" page, not a "Blue Shell (object)" page. Salmancer (talk) 20:29, October 10, 2026 (UTC)
"(item)" wouldn't sufficiently distinguish it from the power-up though (not that I have a better idea for an identifier). Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 20:34, October 10, 2026 (UTC)

As an aside, the idea that "almost everyone who searches for Blue Shell is more likely to be searching for the power-up" is almost certainly wrong, they'd more likely be searching for the Spiny Shell. Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 21:20, October 10, 2026 (UTC)

@Hewer Though similar, the SM3DW is not the same as the NSMB and is not comparable that much. While the item from SM3DW is sort of considered a power-up, it is very different from an actual power-up and from the NSMB Blue Shell. Also, unlike that shell you mentioned, in SM3DW, that shell is the only kind of shell found in the entire game. In NSMB, there are two types of shells: the one you get from Koopas that you can throw and the power-up one, which is also different from the SMW Blue Shell that is almost the same as the other shells in the game. Another thing, I am not actually opposed to splitting different roles per series, but that's different from this. Here, the same mechanic appears in two games of two totally different series, which I surely point out in the proposal. Either way, I think that I cannot convince you to support this proposal if you disagree with the aforementioned Spiny Shell (helmet) and Buzzy Shell (helmet) proposal and, in general, these kinds of splits, so I just wanted to point out some things. Also, I still maintain my point that this Blue Shell is more likely to be searched than the other blue shells on this page, though with the MK Spiny Shell, I'd say it is unsure. Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 21:29, October 10, 2026 (UTC)

My point in bringing up the similarities with the 3D World shell was just to point out that the NSMB item is indeed a blue Koopa Troopa shell, and therefore fits on the page about blue Koopa Troopa shells, contrary to your claim in the proposal that "there is zero indication that this Blue Shell is even remotely the same as the rest on this page". And again, the fact that Bowser's Inside Story references the item's function from NSMB just isn't an argument, it indicates nothing regarding the actual subject of the debate (whether the NSMB shell is the same as the one from other games). It would make sense to bring that up if I was trying to argue that the item in Bowser's Inside Story is different than the one in NSMB - but I'm not arguing that, I'm arguing that it's the same item. Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 21:47, October 10, 2026 (UTC)
Oh, I see. When I am referring to the fact that these are not the same, I mean that yes, these are blue Koopa shells, but they are not the same shell as the other blue shells in the sense that they are obviously not related to them in any way other than being blue and pertaining to blue Koopas. I would dare to say that the fact they are blue like the normal blue shell is entirely coincidental and not intended to represent the same object (or something similar), as it could be with the normal shell. This blue shell could have been of any other color, but the fact that it was chosen to be blue should not necessarily tie it on the same page with the other blue shells. Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 22:05, October 10, 2026 (UTC)
They're not related to them in any way other than being directly related to them? Huh? Being blue Koopa Troopa shells is the thing that connects all the appearances covered on this page, so the fact that it's blue (and is even called "Blue Shell") is absolutely relevant. It's the same on the other shell pages, we definitely wouldn't cover (for example) the Super Mario and Mario Kart appearances of Green Shell on the same page if it weren't for the shared colour. Even just on this page, how is the Mario Strikers Blue Shell more related to the Super Mario World one than the NSMB one is? Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 22:18, October 10, 2026 (UTC)
Not really. The thing that connects these pages is that they fulfill a similar function. The Strikers Blue Shell is more related to the SMW one in that it uses its color for a specific mechanic/purpose (which the NSMB one doesn't do, other than maybe differentiating it from regular shells). It also serves the same function as the other colored shells in that game by also being an item (which, again, the NSMB one doesn't). Hear me out: the fact that the Blue Koopa Troopa only appears in one stage of a side mode, and that its only real function is to give the Blue Shell power-up in NSMB, gives me the impression that the Koopa is of that color because the shell is of that color, not vice versa. Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 22:47, October 10, 2026 (UTC)
It's still a Blue Shell, doesn't matter why they chose to make it one. And it is possible for the same subject to serve multiple roles in a single game - to use Bullet Bill as an example again, Mario Kart DS and Super Smash Bros. for 3DS feature it as both an enemy and an item. In Super Smash Bros. Brawl, Donkey Kong is both a playable character and a stage hazard. In Super Mario Galaxy, Luigi is both an NPC and a playable character. In Super Mario World, Big Boo is both an enemy and a boss. In Super Mario Odyssey, Bowser is both a boss and a playable capture. And so on. Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 01:19, October 11, 2026 (UTC)

@Arend I don't think that the concept of a Blue Shell power-up that appears in two games from different series is very similar to the one from Strikers, as that one pertains to the same series. The shell from SM3DW is fairly different from the Blue Shell, as pointed out above, as the Blue Shell acts more like a traditional power-up while the shell from SM3DW is found elsewhere in the game. Also, the shell is blue-colored with Toad because it is his color, not for other particular reasons. Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 21:35, October 10, 2026 (UTC)

Specifically regarding the point about Super Mario 3D World, I'd say that the role of shells and their Shell dash ability in that game might more analogous to how the Propeller Box imitates the function of the Propeller Block or Propeller Mario from New Super Mario Bros. Wii.
But overall, I agree with the opinion that the NSMBDS Blue Shell doesn't have much in common with the SMW Blue Shell or the MSC Blue Shell beyond "being a Blue-colored Koopa Shell which (usually) belongs to a blue-colored Koopa Troopa." Wandering Poplin (talk) 21:50, October 10, 2026 (UTC)
Again missing the point of why I brought up the 3D World shells. The proposal tried to suggest that the NSMB Blue Shell is unrelated to the other things on the page, which is false as it is a blue Koopa Troopa shell, and the subject of this page is blue Koopa Troopa shells. (That's why I brought up shell dash, which is a reference to the functionality of Koopa Troopa shells.) The only difference that the NSMB item has from the other appearances of blue Koopa Troopa shells is its function, and I don't think that should warrant a split for the same reason I don't think we should split Bob-omb into "Bob-omb (enemy)" and "Bob-omb (item)". Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 22:01, October 10, 2026 (UTC)
I notice you keep mentioning the fact that its power-up function is shared between separate series like it's a deciding factor, but I don't see how it is - just off the top of my head, Bullet Bill as an item appears in both the Mario Kart series and the Super Smash Bros. series. And that's arguably a bigger difference in role, being sometimes an enemy and sometimes an item, compared to this, which is always an item but has varying function. Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 22:18, October 10, 2026 (UTC)
I don't think the MK and SMB Bullet Bill are the "same" item. They have different functions and different uses. Also, as I said, I'm not actually opposed to splitting, for example, Bullet Bill (Mario Kart series item) or Goomba (Super Mario Maker series course element) from their respective main pages, especially the second one, as it could provide more information without bloating the Goomba page. Either way, I think it's important to note because it demonstrates that this item is much more distinct than other elements whose roles merely vary by series. Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 22:47, October 10, 2026 (UTC)
Then perhaps Bob-omb (also an item in both Mario Kart and Smash) would've been a slightly better example than Bullet Bill. But the Bullet Bill item in Smash is directly based on the one in Mario Kart (turning the user into a big Bullet Bill that charges ahead to attack), it has "different function" only because it's in a fighting game instead of a racing game. It's absolutely the same item in the same way that any Smash item that was adapted to fit the game is the same as what it's based on (Fire Flowers let you use a stream of fire instead of throwing fireballs, Super Mushrooms increase size much more and are temporary, etc.). Not to mention the fact the Smash games themselves tell us directly that these items come from Mario games. Anyway, I guess your willingness to split individual appearances of a subject regardless of whether they are the same subject would be a core disagreement between us, as I would rather have articles that provide comprehensive coverage on every appearance of the thing they're about. I don't agree that splitting is helpful for providing more information, you can just put that information on the merged page. It's not "bloat" if it's just relevant information about the subject, articles can be long without being bloated. Though that's not really relevant for this proposal as the Blue Shell page isn't long. Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 01:19, October 11, 2026 (UTC)
I think Bob-omb is also a bad example. Anyone would expect a Bob-omb item to be throwable and explode (there are various games, see PPTOK). Also, I would point out various differences between both items. Like how the SMB one can become an obstacle if left untouched for too much time, or how the MK one, after being thrown, walks and pursues the nearest player before exploding. I don't think that an item/enemy/object in Smash is the same as the origin/inspiring item. Yeah, it is based on the same subject, but not necessarily on the same item. I think the primary function of any shell item that most players expect is not to get inside it and use dash shell; instead, it is to be a throwable object, like it is in the Super Mario series, Mario & Luigi series, Mario Kart series, and even the Smash Bros series. Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 16:19, October 11, 2026 (UTC)
I think that is reaching an unreasonable degree of expecting an item to have no difference whatsoever between different appearances (which are often in entirely different genres). At that point you might as well split Spiny Shell between the winged and wingless versions, or split Bowser between Super Mario Bros. and Super Mario Bros. 3 because his attack pattern is completely different. Instead I think being able to describe in a single article how a subject varies between appearances is better for organisation and more true to the flexible and evolving nature of many of the things in this franchise. If the way an item works in a certain game really is contrary to what "most players expect", then that is interesting information that should be documented in that article. (Also, I'll again point out that the Smash games themselves directly tell us that these are the same items from Mario games. The trophy descriptions of things like Super Mushroom, Poison Mushroom, Fire Flower, etc. directly discuss the items' differing properties between Smash and the original games. So if the games themselves are telling us that these are different appearances of the same items, surely it would be more accurate for the wiki to reflect that?) Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 18:27, October 11, 2026 (UTC)
There are always differences between appearances. That said, I don't think the Bullet Bill item from SMB is necessarily inspired by the MK iteration of Bullet Bills as items. Either way, I think this conversation is getting off point. I don't think both blue Spiny Shells should be split, and the same goes for Bowser, as I do not think these examples are anywhere near the Blue Shell power-up. The differences between the Blue Shell power-up and your Bullet Bill and Bob-omb examples are primarily two. First, the Blue Shell has an entirely different function from common shells in both games, contrary to their appearance in SMW and Strikers, where it has parity with the other shells, as they have the same function (being an item) but with some differences. Second, although you compare Bullet Bills and Bob -ombs with the Blue Shell power-up, there are significant differences to justify objection or discussion over it. This is very different from the Blue Shell power-up, where in its two appearances, it is very clearly the same iteration of the object, even giving the same form. Also, as a side question. Do you think that if this proposal fails, both Spiny Shell and Buzzy Shell helmets should be revisited? Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 02:59, October 12, 2026 (UTC)
For point one: As has been discussed, things can have drastically different roles between games, depending on the needs of each game. Bowser is sometimes the main villain and sometimes a playable character, those are completely different roles. Yet his appearances are still iterations of the same thing. For point two: We're back to that nonsensical argument again? Yes, the Blue Shell is the same between those two games, I never tried to suggest otherwise. That doesn't in any way disqualify it from also being the same Blue Shell from its other appearances. It would be like if I said that Monty Mole has the exact same sprite and function between Super Mario World and Super Mario Maker, so therefore it is a different subject to Monty Mole from other games. I don't get what the correlation there is supposed to be. For side question: I would like the helmets to be re-merged, yes, but I do respect the democratic decisions of proposals, and given that the proposal to split them passed by a wide margin, I'd be unlikely to pursue it unless there was evidence that consensus could shift in that area. Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 08:15, October 12, 2026 (UTC)
While I do not think Bowser is a great example, I think I am following your thoughts. Yeah, the Blue Shell power-up is an iteration of Blue Shells, but with consistent appearances and mechanics between games (that I do not think are that comparable to Bowser or other large articles in general). I am not saying that this is a wholly different object; I am saying it is an iteration of Blue Shell with significant different appearances to justify an article. For the second point, I am not saying that you said that they weren't different; I was just clarifying that they are clearly the same iteration in a way that cannot be discussed, contrary to Bob-ombs or Bullet Bills where there can be an argument made. I think that depending on the consensus of this proposal, there could be a discussion over the helmets, which can lead to a proposal to be consistent with the Blue Shell power-up. Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 15:21, October 12, 2026 (UTC)
The article covering that iteration of Blue Shell already exists though, it's covered just fine on this article. And it's quite a quick one to scroll through, it's not like this a super long article where the power-up is drowning in a sea of other information. So I don't get why you feel the inclusion of three other games where Blue Shells appeared is harming this article's ability to cover the power-up role it had twice. (And yeah, I would support a proposal to re-merge the helmets.) Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 15:43, October 12, 2026 (UTC)
To be fair, the "Shelmets" co-exist with their "normal" counterparts in Super Mario Maker and its sequels. Whereas the NSMBDS Blue Shell has, thus far, not appeared in the same game as its non-powerup counterparts.
I feel that this is kind of an important distinction to make. The SMM Shell-Helmet things aren't that comparable.
(I also do not want to see this kind of misguided precedent lead to the colored caps potentially being merged with their "normal" counterparts again after all the trouble I went through trying to split them.) Wandering Poplin (talk) 16:23, October 12, 2026 (UTC)
I would normally be inclined to agree with that kind of argument, but in the context of Super Mario Maker I think the shelmets are more like a different state that the shells can have. They're as distinct as things like unchained Chain Chomp, lit Bob-omb, and angry Wiggler. Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 17:13, October 12, 2026 (UTC)

@Wilben Because we split Spiny Shell (helmet) and Buzzy Shell (helmet)? Also, those examples are very different; those are per series. The Blue Shell is not per series; it is in two different games. Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 23:06, October 10, 2026 (UTC)

The vote you're replying to already pointed out that its examples are not "per series", they're shared between the Mario Kart and Smash series (both of which have also featured enemy Bullet Bills alongside the item). Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 01:26, October 11, 2026 (UTC)