Category talk:Character themes
Proposal: Do not use possessive form for species theme categories[edit]
| This talk page section contains an unresolved talk page proposal. Please try to help and resolve the issue by voting or leaving a comment. |
Current time: November 20, 2026, 01:32 (UTC)
Per this discussion. Saying "Toad's themes" implies that every theme in such a category belongs to THE character Toad, despite many of said themes being associated with other Toad characters, and even some generic Toad NPCs, such as "Rescue Toad Theme". This goes against the entire rest of the wiki's coverage. In fact, some of these categories don't include any theme that is explicitly associated with a character. Take Category:Cheep Cheep's themes, for instance. It consists entirely of themes that play in locations that happen to be named after a Cheep Cheep. While areas being named after regular enemies are more than common in the Super Mario franchise, I don't think Cheep Cheep Falls is explicitly stated to be named after the playable driver (and even then, I don't know if I'd consider playable enemies as "characters"). EDIT: I have added an option to simply not use possessives for any character theme categories per the opposition votes.
Here is a list of categories affected by the first option:
- Category:Blooper's themes → "Category:Blooper themes"
- Category:Bullet Bill's themes → "Category:Bullet Bill themes"
- Category:Cheep Cheep's themes → "Category:Cheep Cheep themes"
- Category:Koopa Troopa's themes → "Category:Koopa Troopa themes"
- Category:Pianta's themes → "Category:Pianta themes"
- Category:Piranha Plant's themes → "Category:Piranha Plant themes"
- Category:Shy Guy's themes → "Category:Shy Guy themes"
- Category:Toad's themes → "Category:Toad themes"
- Category:Wiggler's themes → "Category:Wiggler themes"
- Category:Yoshi's themes → "Category:Yoshi themes"
Moreover, due to the above reasoning, I could see either this category being moved to "Character and species themes" or a separate "Species themes" category being created. I think I'm going to propose this separately at a later date, but feel free to discuss this in the comments.
Proposer: The Dab Master (talk)
Deadline: December 3, 2026, 23:59 (UTC)
Support themes: Only remove possessives from species theme categories[edit]
- The Dab Master's themes (talk) Pimary choice; per proposal.
- Yoshi18 themes (talk) Per Wandering Poplin below.
- Wandering Poplin's themes (talk) I understand the idea of not wanting to getting too deep into the character/species thing, a debate which Toad and Yoshi are no strangers to, but a title such as "[subject]'s theme" heavily implies a focus on a singular individual. Neither Captain Toad, nor the Rescue Toads are the "character Toad", the disclaimer at the top of that category's page is simply not enough.[1] Using the more neutral "Toad themes" could potentially apply to any Toad without getting caught up in as much of the resulting confusion, without necessarily contradicting any interpretation, nor does the name stray too far from Nintendo's "Toad" playlist. This same ideology also applies to the other characters, although few of them have the exact same situation as Toad and Yoshi do.
To cut a long story short, I feel that the current names are a bit confusing, and are causing more problems than they solve, and this seems to be the cleanest compromise we can offer.
That being said, I do think Camwoodstock's suggestion of removing the possessive from all similar categories (Example:Category:Mario's themes becoming Category:Mario themes) would also be a good idea for consistency, although I'm not sure whether that is strictly necessary. - The Real Color Splash Fan (talk) Per.
Support themes: Remove possessives from all character theme categories[edit]
- The Dab Master themes (talk) Secondary choice; per Hewer below.
- Poplin themes (Which may, or may not involve Wandering Poplin) Secondary vote, same reasoning as before. As stated, I'm not sure if this is strictly necessary, but the added consistency is definitely something worth considering.
- SolemnStormcloud (talk)
Secondary choice.Per all. - Hewer (talk) Second option. Or first, I don't have a strong preference between the two.
- Camwoodstock (talk) Per our original vote to oppose, we'd rather just cut out the middle-man of "jank born from drawing hard lines between character and species in a series that historically is not thinking that hard about it", and just equally remove the possessives from all. We don't really buy the argument of "Wario/Yoshi/Donkey Kong themes could also refer to the franchise" considering that could be solved by simply... Specifying which one in the category name? There's nothing saying we can't have a category for "Wario themes" and "Wario franchise themes", respectively.
- Wilben (talk) Per Hewer and Camwoodstock. Separating characters and species in a franchise that historically does not seem to put much thought (if any) on the subject doesn't seem like anything to get worked up about if you ask me.
Oppose's themes[edit]
- Hewer (talk) I'm generally not fond of making hard distinctions between "characters" and "species" because I feel it doesn't accurately reflect the more fluid nature of these concepts as they are used in the franchise (I detailed my thoughts on this in this discussion), and this is a case where I definitely don't think making such a distinction is necessary or helpful. Using a consistent format for all these category names is far easier and more logical while still not being incorrect (Cheep Cheep absolutely is a character, just one who there is often multiple of). Alternatively, I would also be fine with removing the possessive from all of these categories (e.g. "Mario themes" instead of "Mario's themes"), which would still solve the issue of "Toad's themes" being potentially misleading, without introducing an unnecessary inconsistency.
#Camwoodstock (talk) Per Hewer. The distinction between "character" and "species" on a wiki level is kind of a huge elephant in the room considering how loose Nintendo is with the distinction, and how much WikiJank™ can be sourced back to trying to confidently assert one over the other no matter how hair-pulling the results are. We figure it's probably for the best to just... Not pile on more to that, frankly? We'd be down for Hewer's suggestion to remove the possessive from all categories, though. If that was added as an option, we'd change our vote in a heartbeat.
#SolemnStormcloud (talk) Per opposition. Also, in the case of "Donkey Kong/Wario/Yoshi themes", there would be an additional ambiguity with the titular character (and species, in Yoshi's case) sharing their name with their respective franchise as a whole.
#The Real Color Splash Fan (talk) Primary choice. Moving every category would also be inconsistent with articles like Rambi's Theme and Count Cannoli's Theme, and I don't want them to be moved to Rambi Theme and Count Cannoli Theme, that's definitely not a good idea.
Comments' themes[edit]
Officially, "species" like Boos are considered to be characters. I think we should avoid differentiating between characters and species when possible, so I suggest that if this change is implemented, it should affect all subcategories, and the main category should keep its name. B700465189a9 (talk) 14:44, November 19, 2026 (UTC)
Another cause for my concern regarding this name-situation, is its effects on newer/uninformed editors.
Supposing User:John Doe has recently joined the wiki, and is working on a page for Toadette's theme.
If they see the Category:Toad's themes link from afar, without visiting the page themselves (meaning that they will not see the page's disclaimer in the description), what do you think they are more likely to assume about the category?
- Would it be "Oh, this is a category for all musical themes related to Toad, right?"
- Or would it be "Oh, this is a category for any musical theme which happens to be related to the Toad species, right?"
Obviously, it is quite likely that they are going to assume it is the former, and due to this belief, would not include the category on the page. And that's just the start of it.
- Perhaps they would go so far as to remove the category from the page if it is added in later, citing something along the lines of "Toadette isn't Toad" in their edit summary.
- Perhaps they would remove the category from other pages due to this confusion. Prince Mush certainly isn't Toad, after all.
- Perhaps, in some particularly rare and extreme cases, it could be the catalyst for an entire edit-war, which may ultimately result in the user getting a {{Warning}} or even a {{Block}} over an misconception which could have been avoided altogether.
Wouldn't it be better to avoid that situation entirely and simply pick a less easily-confusing title, instead of having to explain "So this category, which is literally named Toad's themes, is actually not about Toad's themes, its about Toad themes" to any average user who has this type of misinterpretation? Organization-wise, I would say that the less ambiguity there is about a category, the better.
(I could also use this opportunity to cite how this is another good example of why merging "[subject]-the character" into "[subject]-the species" and then treating the former as being wholly interchangeable with the latter isn't always that great of an idea, but I outright refuse to get dragged into another one of those debates...) Wandering Poplin (talk) 18:18, November 19, 2026 (UTC)
@Hewer @Camwoodstock I have now added the requested option.
The Dab Master 18:29, November 19, 2026 (UTC)
Would it be possible to add plural possessives for species as an alternative option? e.g. "Toads' themes" instead of "Toad's themes" or "Toad themes". That might be better than any of our existing options. —
SolemnStormcloud (talk) 18:58, November 19, 2026 (UTC)
- That would still introduce an unnecessary inconsistency between "characters" and "species", which is the main thing I want to avoid. Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 19:50, November 19, 2026 (UTC)
@The Real Color Splash Fan: I don't see why the names of this group of categories would have to match the conjectural names of some random articles? That's a completely separate matter. Hewer (talk · contributions · edit count) 22:07, November 19, 2026 (UTC)
Uh, @The Real Color Splash Fan, you do know this proposal is only tackling the names for the character theme subcategories, not the names for conjecturally named musical theme articles, right?
Wilben
(talk • edits) 22:19, November 19, 2026 (UTC)
References' themes[edit]
- ^ "Musical themes associated with and/or named after Toad and/or a member of the Toad species in the Super Mario franchise. These may include tracks listed in the official "Toad" character playlist on Nintendo Music." – Quote taken directly from the category as it is currently written.