Talk:Unbeaten spokesman
This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Unbeaten spokesman article. It is not a forum for general discussion of the article's subject. Comments such as "Mario is my favorite character" are not allowed and will be removed on sight. Please use the Mario Boards or our Discord server to talk about Unbeaten spokesman.
If you do have a question or comment about the article, please remember to sign your edit with ~~~~.
"Nintendo (evil group)" should have been moved to this title[edit]
This article was created to replace former article Nintendo (evil group) because of a proposal. However, this article is almost identical to Nintendo (evil group), with only minute changes. Given this, I think the proposal was handled incorrectly. In making an entirely separate article under "Unbeaten spokesman" the contributions of editors to the page is muddled in spite of the pages being the same. It makes more sense to move the article "Nintendo (evil group)" to "Unbeaten spokesman", because that way page history is preserved. Salmancer (talk) 22:51, December 22, 2025 (EST)
- As per this proposal, the page was rewritten and moved to this name, so I am closing this discussion. — Lady Sophie_17
(T|C) 12:50, January 1, 2026 (EST)
- But it wasn't moved. We know this because the history of Unbeaten spokesman doesn't say that this page was moved from Nintendo (evil group). A page that was actually moved would say it was moved in its' page history, as the history for List of buildings and decorations in Super Mario Run does. Normally, I wouldn't be this picky, but I am because there isn't a rewrite here. As the difference between the final revision with prose of Nintendo (evil group) and the first revision with prose of Unbeaten spokesman demonstrate, they are the almost the same article. I do not think this wiki should credit Rykitu as the writer of most of this page, as the page history of Unbeaten spokesman currently says when BubzieBobkat is the one who wrote most of this page.
- I am saying what happened was:
- Page text is copied from Nintendo (evil group)
- Page text is placed in Unbeaten spokesman with light modifications, replacing the page's redirect
- Nintendo (evil group) is changed into a redirect.
- When what needed to happen was:
- Unbeaten spokesman's redirect is deleted
- Nintendo (evil group) is moved to Unbeaten spokesman, which makes Nintendo (evil group) redirect to Unbeaten spokesman
- The text of Unbeaten spokesman is changed with light modifications, to match the page's new name of Unbeaten spokesman
- Because the latter preserves the correct page history for how the page was written. Uh, signing here.Salmancer (talk) 13:23, January 1, 2026 (EST)
- Oh, sorry for the misunderstanding. I will implemente these changes as described, then. — Lady Sophie_17 (T|C) 14:04, January 1, 2026 (EST)
- Oh, sorry for the misunderstanding. I will implemente these changes as described, then. — Lady Sophie_17
