Talk:New Super Mario Bros. U Dokodemo Game Collection
This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the New Super Mario Bros. U Dokodemo Game Collection article. It is not a forum for general discussion of the article's subject. Comments such as "Mario is my favorite character" are not allowed and will be removed on sight. Please use the Mario Boards or our Discord server to talk about New Super Mario Bros. U Dokodemo Game Collection.
If you do have a question or comment about the article, please remember to sign your edit with ~~~~.
Resplit[edit]
| This talk page section contains an unresolved talk page proposal. Please try to help and resolve the issue by voting or leaving a comment. |
Current time: November 16, 2026, 19:41 (UTC)
To preface, I know there is debate over the color variant thingy. I will address this further down.
Presently, the game articles for each game in this and the Mario Kart 8 Dokodemo Game Collection have been merged into this one article. There was a discussion in which this was suggested, but said discussion was never resolved, and then this merge happened without any other prior discussion. I don't believe these should be merged; even if color variants should be, these are all unique games and should not all be merged.
For starters, they are all named individually on their respective flyers. These are not all one thing, they are many small things under one banner. This is also inconsistent with how we cover other games of this type, as Ramp Game and its cohorts were not merged (nor do I think they should be), and we still have wanted articles for a whole bunch of other games of this variety.
As for the color variants, I can understand merging them, but there is not a whole lot that these things could probably do to differentiate themselves from one another (that is, the Blue version of X game from the Red version of X game), given their size. Even so, the artwork used on each game is completely different from one another, and each game is named separately on the flyer.
So I will provide three options;
- Resplit into eight articles.
- Resplit into four articles.
- Do nothing.
Proposer: Nelsonic (talk)
Deadline: November 30, 2026, 23:59 (UTC)
Resplit everything[edit]
Resplit games, merge color variants[edit]
Do nothing[edit]
- Camwoodstock (talk) Personally, we think these are fine all merged together. These are marketed, and distributed, as though each one is equivalent to one another. There's being a part of a series, like the Super Mario Bros. Watches, and then there's... Literally being distributed via a gachapon. And unlike the Super Mario Bros. Watches, playing one really is meant to be roughly similar to playing any of the others. This isn't to demean these things, mind you, but we feel like if these are being distributed as though all 8 of these games really are that alike, it only makes sense to document them as such.
Super Mario Wiki Dokodemo Comments Collection[edit]
Eager splits lead to poor articles. The previous Dokan ni Shoot (Blue) article does not have enough substance to support its own article; all of the information about the toy can be gleamed from looking at two images. As a result, the relevant information can be packed into a single article's table quite nicely. I wasn't aware of the articles for the toys that came with the Donkey Kong cereal, but they also suffer from quality issues. For example, the articles cite an image of the back of the cereal box that can no longer be accessed. These toys don't even seem to be mentioned on the article for the cereal itself. I would rather have one good article than four subpar articles. B700465189a9 (talk) 06:58, November 16, 2026 (UTC)
- @B700465189a9 I can still access the box image. I'm pretty sure Worthpoint just sometimes doesn't let you see an image from a direct link. I can understand what you're saying, but the quality of the articles could be improved; part of the reason they're based on images is because I don't actually own most of the stuff I write about.
Nelsonic (talk edits)
07:08, November 16, 2026 (UTC)
- Does having nine articles instead of one inherently improve the overall quality of the articles? Without demonstrating the improvements you mention, this proposal is toothless. B700465189a9 (talk) 07:14, November 16, 2026 (UTC)
- @B700465189a9 I mean, I can't think of an example off the top of my head, but I'm sure there is one. I personally don't think the Ramp Game, Rivet Game, and Elevator Game articles are half bad, so that could maybe be an example. I am trying to err on the side of consistency; these are presently the only games on the list to be merged, and none of the other ones should be either [I'm aware that's a different topic, one that is unlikely to come up, though].
Nelsonic (talk edits)
07:18, November 16, 2026 (UTC)
- @B700465189a9 I mean, I can't think of an example off the top of my head, but I'm sure there is one. I personally don't think the Ramp Game, Rivet Game, and Elevator Game articles are half bad, so that could maybe be an example. I am trying to err on the side of consistency; these are presently the only games on the list to be merged, and none of the other ones should be either [I'm aware that's a different topic, one that is unlikely to come up, though].
- Does having nine articles instead of one inherently improve the overall quality of the articles? Without demonstrating the improvements you mention, this proposal is toothless. B700465189a9 (talk) 07:14, November 16, 2026 (UTC)