Talk:Big Urchin

From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search

This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Big Urchin article. It is not a forum for general discussion of the article's subject. Comments such as "Mario is my favorite character" are not allowed and will be removed on sight. Please use the Mario Boards or our Discord server to talk about Big Urchin.

If you do have a question or comment about the article, please remember to sign your edit with ~~~~.

Mega Urchin[edit]

Mega Urchins are a sub-species of Urchins that appear in the game New Super Mario Bros. Wii. They act exactly like regular Urchins, by floating back and forth in the water, except that this ones are larger and could only be destroyed with a Starman, since other attacks don´t affect them. Even Koopa Shells can´t destroy them. Mega Urchins first appear in World 4-1. They mostly appear along with regular Urchins. — The preceding unsigned comment was added by SuperMarioFan2010 (talk).

Talk pages are for talking about how to improve the article. If you have info, just add it in the article. Or if you're just testing your edits, go to MarioWiki:Sandbox. Marie costume pose in Super Mario Maker Mario JC

Trophy in Super Smash Bros. for Wii U[edit]

The trophy for these are called "Big Urchins". Should we move the page or create a redirect instead? BabyLuigiFire.pngXiahou Ba(the Nasty Warrior) 15:29, 23 November 2014 (EST)

Is there even a source for Mega Urchin's name or...? I guess it's a good idea to ask in that one thread in the forums. Sprite of Mario's icon in Mario Party DS It's me, Mario! (Talk / Stalk) 15:35, 23 November 2014 (EST)

Remove MP10 info[edit]

Brown Block This talk page proposal has already been settled. Please do not edit this section or its subsections. If you wish to discuss the article, please do so in a new section below the proposal.

remove Mario Party 10 information 10-4

Unlike other big/mega/large variants of enemies, which are just the same enemy but bigger, Big Urchins have a different consistent appearance throughout all the games they have appeared in, even in the Wii U era. So, the large generic Urchin that appears in MP10 shouldn't have been added in the first place. They aren't even called "Big Urchins" anywhere.

Okay, so I think I might make this proposal more elaborate. I think the opposers don't understand the principle of this proposal. The reason why I'm making this proposal is because Big Urchins are not generic large variants of preexisting subjects. They are entities with a consistent design across all of their appearances, which has even granted them appearances outside of the games, as can be seen in the LEGO set and the mural above. You know why Big Urchin gets this treatment while other large subjects do not? Because they are not the same. This page is not about large Urchins; it is about a specific type of Urchin with a consistent and unique design, which I don't think you can say or apply to any other large variant. Heck, even the page starts with "A Big Urchin is a colossal species of Urchin with puffed cheeks that first appears in the game New Super Mario Bros. Wii." Their puffed cheeks and tubby appearance are what give them an identity. Just like Sledge Bro not being converted into a generic page about large Hammer Bros, or Banzai Bill not being converted into a generic page about generic large Bullet Bills. These are not generic large enemies.

I see some opposers arguing that maybe the developers didn't have the model, which I honestly don't think is a compelling argument. First, we don't have any proof of this whatsoever. Second, Mario Party 10 borrows a lot of things from New Super Mario Bros. U (a game where Big Urchins made a notable appearance), see Dragoneel, Waddlewing, Fliprus, Goombrat, Grrrol, Nabbit, Torpedo Ted, and several others. Why, of all things, would Big Urchin be the only exception? It doesn't make sense. You know what does make sense? This large Urchin being a generic larger enemy used for gameplay purposes, which Mario Party 10 does three different times. They needed a larger enemy in Fruit of the Doom, so they made one. Was it a Big Urchin? No, it was just a large Urchin. It wasn't called Big Urchin, didn't look like Big Urchin, and wasn't treated like Big Urchin—yet it was included here 11 years ago without prior discussion and without images. Now we have an image: is this a Big Urchin? No. Is it a large Urchin? Yes.

Having a unique, consistent, and distinct appearance from others is what allows the existence of pages like Snowman and Snowman (generic) or Penguin and Penguin (generic). Or even things like this proposal can be made because of their different designs and appearances. If we dismiss the visual identity of this enemy, we might as well rewrite the entire page to convert it into a generic large enemy page as well. Also, if we keep the info on this page, it will be with a conjectural merge, as pointed out below.

Proposer: Mr. Sorbetti (talk)
Deadline: October 31, 2026, 23:59 (UTC)

Support[edit]

  1. Mr. Sorbetti (talk) Per proposal.
  2. Mega Wandering Poplin (talk) Sigh... Yet another instance of "unusually sized-character-variant-X being haphazardly slapped in a page about large-character-variant-Y," generifing the article and comparing apples to oranges pears. We've seen dozens of instances of this exact situation on the wiki recently, and I'm running out of unique ways to express my thoughts on the issue each time it occurs. Per proposal.
  3. Illuminoid (talk) Per all.
  4. Wilben (talk) Per all.
  5. large-The Real Color Splash Fan-variant-Y (talk) Per all.
  6. Xiahou Ba, The Nasty Warrior (talk) The urchins here in the minigame just look like typical bigger variants like the slightly bigger than normal Amps in Shock Absorbers or the different penguin sizes in Pushy Penguins really. The Big Urchins here are so much bigger than the ones in this minigame and have different eyes, and they have a different spikes layout. Makes more sense to leave this page talking about only the colossal ones than include the unnamed slightly bigger ones typical of Mario Party minigames.
  7. Arend (talk) Big Urchin is one of those rare instances of a bigger version of an enemy which actually has a (slightly) different design, much like Bomber Bill. This was introduced in New Super Mario Bros. Wii, which came before Mario Party 10, so there's not really a reason to think this slightly larger Urchin that doesn't really look all too different otherwise is the same thing; especially considering Big Urchins tend to be consistently about three times larger than a regular Urchin across all their appearances (yes, even in Jamboree), whereas this one is only roughly twice its size.
  8. Mariuigi Khed (talk) Per all
  9. Urchin18 (talk) Per all.
  10. The Dab Master (talk) Per all.

Oppose[edit]

  1. LinkTheLefty (talk) Gonna be honest, I'm frankly not seeing what the big difference is besides mainly the face is a bit different? Spike length seems roughly the same. Actually, comparing footage of MP10's Fruit of the Doom with SMPJ's Dragoneel Slayers from the same developers, the size scale between them seems about the same too. This is probably a case where different developers just weren't provided the textures yet and simply resized and accidentally made a nonstandard design. Seems more prudent to use {{conjectural merge}} if need be rather than outright delete info.
  2. Hewer (talk) Per LinkTheLefty, I don't think the slightly different face is really such a drastic difference that this can't have been intended as the same thing (other variants have gone through much more drastic design variations, Big Cheep Cheep comes to mind). They're larger Urchins that appear alongside small ones in the same minigame, I don't see the issue with covering them here.
  3. PipesTheVlob (talk) I would agree with this if it weren't for the fact there are also normal-size urchins in the same minigame, that makes things a bit more complicated, in my personal opinion. Per all
  4. Harold Harefoot (talk) A Big Urchin is a Big Urchin Per all.

#Camwoodstock (talk) Per LinkTheLefty. This feels more like CAProduction just didn't have the Big Urchin model with the puffy cheeks, and just made do. Especially considering, for whatever reason, Super Mario Party Jamboree's Big Urchins are given the right to passage, despite them being basically identical to Mario Party 10's? ...Not that we'd really support it even if this was being applied evenly to both, but we will let the record show we can't think of a single reason to prune the 10 entry, but not the Jamboree entry.

Comments[edit]

@LinkTheLefty Is the face a little bit different? It's almost its main difference aside from size, being a tubbier variant instead of just a generic larger one. Clearly, I don't think there is "much of" a size difference between the large Urchin and Big Urchin, as that is what brought the info about large Urchin here in the first place. "This is probably a case where different developers just weren't provided the textures yet and simply resized and accidentally made a nonstandard design" I don't think so, they just made a large Urchin, not the Big Urchin (wich they actually brought in Jamboree with a new model). Regarding "weren't provided the textures yet", the game uses a lot, lot of NSMBU stuff, so they clearly had no issue with using that Big Urchin texture, but they didn't, and I don't think that should be discarded (especially when every game, aside from this specific one, uses the unique design). Ultimately, the info is not going to be deleted; I'll just move it to the Urchin page. I think this is way better than using a conjectural merge IMO. Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 23:20, October 17, 2026 (UTC)

Okay, but this isn't like Big Amp, where you have to squint to see the difference in MP5. If the Mario Party series' big-sized Urchins and Big Urchins are functionally the same thing, wouldn't it make more sense organizationally to keep that info together? Plus, we don't have all the info available to us, as there's a guide. If we find out later that the info in it contradicts the proposal's outcome, we'll have to make another one at some point eventually. LinkTheLefty (talk) 23:45, October 17, 2026 (UTC)
In any other instance, I would agree to keep this information on this page, because large variants of enemies tend to look identical to their normal counterparts. However, this is a different case. I think you are overlooking the physical differences here, differences that have been consistently maintained across many appearances, even prior to Mario Party 10. I would argue that the main distinction is that if you were to scale a Big Urchin down, you would still be able to identify it as a Big Urchin, whereas the large Urchin in MP10 just looks like a Urchin. If we find that the info in the guide contradicts the proposal, then we can simply make another proposal; I don't see any issue with doing so. Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 23:55, October 17, 2026 (UTC)
In the NSMB games, Big Urchins tend to be at least three times as large as regular Urchins (which is about the same size as Mario), and I think this is consistent with Smash Bros and Color Splash too. That larger Urchin from Fruit of the Doom is only roughly twice as large. ArendLogoTransparent.pngrend (talk) (edits) 23:52, October 17, 2026 (UTC)
Agreed. This "Big Urchin" is visibly smaller than most depictions of "Big Urchins", almost resembling a hypothetical Hefty Urchin in terms of its scale.
I don't think every instance of "Bigger version subject A" is also an appearance of "Big subject B", and while it would be convenient to have both subjects covered in one place, I wouldn't necessarily say that it would be "better." Wandering Poplin (talk) 23:54, October 17, 2026 (UTC)
I was referring to the size difference between MP10 and Mario Party Jamboree, as Link pointed out, but otherwise you are right. Big Urchins in the rest of the games tend to be significantly larger than standard big variants Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk)

@Camwoodstock The Big Urchins in Super Mario Party Jamboree are not identical to the ones in Mario Party 10. The Big Urchins in Jamboree have the puffy cheeks they usually have. Peach costume pose in Super Mario Maker Wilben Ashley costume pose in Super Mario Maker (talk • edits) 19:22, October 18, 2026 (UTC)

...Okay, duly noted, we apparently need to check the actual video quality before we assert this stuff, because it got garbled the first go-around, whoops. We can see it now at least. We could still honestly go either way on this split, but we'll at least withdraw our vote considering it's predicated on. The YouTube Compression Algorithm. ;P Camwoodstock-sigicon.png~Camwoodstock ( talk ☯ contribs ) Camwoodstock-sigicon2.png 16:35, October 19, 2026 (UTC)
This is not a split proposal, though. Its objective is to remove the MP10 info from here and place it in the Urchin page. Sorbetti Mr. Sorbetti (talk) 00:39, October 21, 2026 (UTC)