MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/Rosalina

From the Super Mario Wiki
Smg2 icon bronzestar.png

This is an archive of a successful featured article nomination. If this page is unprotected, do not modify its contents, as it is an archive of past discussions.
Rosalina was nominated to be a featured article at 15:05, 15 August 2008 (EDT) and passed at 18:39, 5 September 2008.


Rosalina

Support

  1. SSBstarman.jpgStarry Parakarry 35px - Good article with plenty of lots of detailed info, good amount of pics (for the size of the article), good opening paragraph, all of her stats, relationships and abilities are listed. The article actually has a LOT of info for her appearing in only two games.
  2. A very good article. The personality section may be a little bit short, but Rosalina is a bit of a mysterious character. WK
  3. 35pxRosalina 30px - Good and detailed article.
  4. per everyone CHAOS YAYZOR!!!Mini-MoSTABBED WITH A FORK!Yap-BoxBOW DOWN TO THE KOOPAS RITE NOA!!!
  5. per Mrsdaisyluigi! Luigidance.gifLuigi3000File:DaisyLove.png
  6. InfectedShroom (talk) - Okeydoke, looks good. And I find it quite humorous that there is a relatively long paragraph about her athletic wear. XD
  7. Excellent article, per all. Luigi MH3on3.pngZ3r0 Tw0Zerotwo.jpg
  8. The article is nothing but info and beauty.
    The preceding unsigned comment was added by Rainbow Yoshi (talk).
  9. Storm Yoshi (talk) - Good long article. Especially for a character with only two appearances :o
  10. Karatekid5 Signiture.pngCovers and explains everything. Well detailed too.--Black Belt of the Mushroom Kingdom 18:46, 24 August 2008 (EDT)

Oppose

Comments

LOL, Sorry about that! Thanks for telling me about that! SSBstarman.jpgStarry Parakarry 35px

I updated her interaction with other characters section so that the Luma and Mario sections are MUCH longer! Hope that's better! SSBstarman.jpgStarry Parakarry 35px

Um, Super Mario Fan, how can Super Mario Galaxy not be long enough when it's a bunch of paragraphs but Mario Kart Wii be good enough when it's only 1 paragraph? Besides, that Super Mario Galaxy section is REALLY long! What exactly do you want us to expand? SSBstarman.jpgStarry Parakarry 35px


I believe I know what Super Mario Fan is talking about, Starry Parakarry. Although the Super Mario Galaxy section is long, most of it is about the storybook section. I think Super Mario Fan is saying more needs to be added about Rosalina's role in the plot other than her storybook section. Do you understand what I am saying? I mean, just look at how short the Cosmos Protector (or whatever it is) section is compared to other sections. WK

Yeah what White Knight said anyways I deleted my oppose as you can see above so it's OK. 22360415-149x149-0-0 ++The+SpongeBob+SquarePants+Movie.jpg Boo der dash 180px-MaskedDedede.png

It's past 19:39, 5 September 2008. Pikax signature.PNG Pikax (talk) 08:14, 6 September 2008 (EDT)

I'm sorry to ask but, um, how exactly do you get this to be taken down? I've done it before but my mind is going blank and I can't find out how to do it from any of the instructions. Sorry and thanks in advance! SSBstarman.jpgStarry Parakarry 35px
It's taken down when a sysop deletes it; which is, in most cases, TimeQ. He said he'll be back today so this and the SM64 nomination page should be gone soon. Marcelagus (TCE)
Thanks for noticing. It's not deleted, it's just moved (the ".../N/..." in the article title is changed to ".../A/..."). You may also do it yourself, in case you notice a nomination page that isn't moved yet. Time Questions 15:54, 7 September 2008 (EDT)