MarioWiki:Featured articles/Unfeature/N1/Donkey Kong Land: Difference between revisions

From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
mNo edit summary
 
(13 intermediate revisions by 8 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
__NOTOC__
__NOTOC__
===[[{{#titleparts:{{PAGENAME}}||4}}]]===
===[[{{#titleparts:{{PAGENAME}}||4}}]]===
{{UNFANOMSTAT
{{fa-archive|unfeature=yes}}
|nominated= 15:00, 30 July 2014
'''Donkey Kong Land''' was nominated to be unfeatured at 03:08, 15 August 2014 and passed at 22:08, 21 August 2014.
|passed=<!--When it is 5-0, put the time (such as 12:10, 11 December 2009) of the fifth support/removal of last opposet  by copying it from the history of the page.-->
}}
==== Remove Featured Article Status ====
==== Remove Featured Article Status ====
#{{User|Randombob-omb4761}} This article needs more images (Just look at the template on the article!), it has 6 missing images.
#{{User|Randombob-omb4761}} This article needs more images (Just look at the template on the article!), it has 6 missing images.
Line 10: Line 8:
#{{User|Ninelevendo}} The 6 images aren't my problem, this article just looks small. The tables aren't that useful and, if anything, make the article worse. There isn't a controls section and the rest of the article could be better. The article does need more images as well, not just 6.
#{{User|Ninelevendo}} The 6 images aren't my problem, this article just looks small. The tables aren't that useful and, if anything, make the article worse. There isn't a controls section and the rest of the article could be better. The article does need more images as well, not just 6.
#{{User|Vommack}} I thought it was good enough at first, but looking further at the flaws that have been brought up, I've changed my mind. Per BL and Ninelevendo.
#{{User|Vommack}} I thought it was good enough at first, but looking further at the flaws that have been brought up, I've changed my mind. Per BL and Ninelevendo.
#{{User|Tsunami}} OK, when I first opposed, I didn't read the article well. Now, I see that most of the article are '''tables'''. It's a bit like [[List of shops in Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars]], only that it was 100% tables. Those images missing make the article seem really incomplete. When a reader reads this "Featured" Article and sees only a part of the images... well, I would instead watch some videos. Oh, but hold on a second... there wasn't a rule? Yep, a rule that prevents Lakitu to be featured for a long time. Yes, that rule 5: '''''An article must not be tagged with any sort of improvement tag'''''. There is a image requested templat at '''top''' of the article. Technically, I'm switching sides like Vommack did. @Super Radio: Yes, the enemies sections are writed good, only that some images are missing. And the article totally lacks colors...
#{{User|3D Player 2004}} per Ninelevendo


==== Keep Featured Article Status ====
==== Keep Featured Article Status ====
#{{user|Tsunami}} Unfeaturing just because there are a few images missing? I know that missing images is an issue on an article, especially on one featured, but still you need to know that editing an image to get the ACTUAL sprite is difficult, especially in a black and white game. The issue can be easily resolved by putting images of the full screen to represent the subject. Done. Also, the oppose you did for [[Lakitu]], that says that it has a rewrite template, well, it isn't totally right to be an oppose in my opinion. One should check a page often when it is about to be Featured. I know that rule 5 says that no templates should be in the article, but in this article the template can be taken down like I said before. But rule 10 says that the images should be of good quality '''if avaible'''. You know, sprites are sprites, and they have to be like they are in the game, without missing any pixel. And those sprites are difficult to get. Still, remember that you can easily '''put images of the game screen  to replace sprites that are waiting to be made.''' And I find that, since this is your only issue found, and I think that the article is well written and stuff, your Unfeaturing propose is (no offense) a bit non-costructive. '''A Featured Article should have more issues to be Unfearured.''' Still, this is my point of view. Not all I said can be right and maybe my oppose can fall if you find another GOOD reason for why Unfeaturing this.
#{{user|Super Radio}} People were complaining about unwritten enemy sections. Here's your written sections. This article shall remain featured till the end of all. Capisci?


==== Removal of Support/Oppose Votes ====
==== Removal of Support/Oppose Votes ====
Line 28: Line 26:
::... and then I think to myself... CAN THE GAME BOY DISPLAY COLOR AT ALL???? Excuse me for clamoring, but c'mon man. The tables are gray because I wanted them to aesthetically fit the graphical limitations of the Game Boy. Besides, regarding the sprites, well... aren't they monochrome? Anyway, unless this is the answer you've asked for, I still have no idea what you mean by "hpgame" (trust me, I googled it). And maybe it's just you who thinks the tables/sprites are eye sore. -- {{User:Super Radio/Sig}}
::... and then I think to myself... CAN THE GAME BOY DISPLAY COLOR AT ALL???? Excuse me for clamoring, but c'mon man. The tables are gray because I wanted them to aesthetically fit the graphical limitations of the Game Boy. Besides, regarding the sprites, well... aren't they monochrome? Anyway, unless this is the answer you've asked for, I still have no idea what you mean by "hpgame" (trust me, I googled it). And maybe it's just you who thinks the tables/sprites are eye sore. -- {{User:Super Radio/Sig}}
:I look at it and just get hit with grey and black. There just aren't enough images in general anyway. (If the game boy didn't display colour, Pokemon would seem different.) hpgame is either a game on a HP, a hype game or a really bad typo. - {{User:Ninelevendo/sig}} 04:59, 11 August 2014 (EDT)
:I look at it and just get hit with grey and black. There just aren't enough images in general anyway. (If the game boy didn't display colour, Pokemon would seem different.) hpgame is either a game on a HP, a hype game or a really bad typo. - {{User:Ninelevendo/sig}} 04:59, 11 August 2014 (EDT)
::BTW, it's mainly the Level section I hate. The others still aren't the best, but are pretty good. - {{User:Ninelevendo/sig}} 05:01, 11 August 2014 (EDT)
@Randombob-omb4761 @Vommack I switched sides after re-reading the article. Now please delete my name from that, otherwise you will delete a supporter. {{User:Tsunami/sig}}

Latest revision as of 17:25, May 16, 2018

Donkey Kong Land[edit]

Smg2 icon bronzestar.png

This is an archive of a successful unfeature article nomination. If this page is unprotected, do not modify its contents, as it is an archive of past discussions.


Donkey Kong Land was nominated to be unfeatured at 03:08, 15 August 2014 and passed at 22:08, 21 August 2014.

Remove Featured Article Status[edit]

  1. Randombob-omb4761 (talk) This article needs more images (Just look at the template on the article!), it has 6 missing images.
  2. Baby Luigi (talk) Randomb-bobomb's reasoning is very weak as hell. But regardless, further analysis into the article reveals that the enemy and item tables are incomplete. Tsunami has stated that images should be there if "available", however, having 2/3rds of the sprites available and the others missing means that the results are inconsistent and incomplete. The rule about available images is mostly concerning unobtainable media such as Satellaview games and others. Donkey Kong Land is very obtainable to the general public so no images isn't an excuse for an incomplete table. Besides, Tsunami, ripping sprites don't work that way, especially if a game uses pre-rendered sprites which would be nearly nigh impossible to obtain by manual methods, so extracting image files from the game is an option, and considering how accessible it is to access Game Boy sprites thanks to older technology, it shouldn't be impossible to game-rip the sprites directly from the game.
  3. Ninelevendo (talk) The 6 images aren't my problem, this article just looks small. The tables aren't that useful and, if anything, make the article worse. There isn't a controls section and the rest of the article could be better. The article does need more images as well, not just 6.
  4. Vommack (talk) I thought it was good enough at first, but looking further at the flaws that have been brought up, I've changed my mind. Per BL and Ninelevendo.
  5. Tsunami (talk) OK, when I first opposed, I didn't read the article well. Now, I see that most of the article are tables. It's a bit like List of shops in Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars, only that it was 100% tables. Those images missing make the article seem really incomplete. When a reader reads this "Featured" Article and sees only a part of the images... well, I would instead watch some videos. Oh, but hold on a second... there wasn't a rule? Yep, a rule that prevents Lakitu to be featured for a long time. Yes, that rule 5: An article must not be tagged with any sort of improvement tag. There is a image requested templat at top of the article. Technically, I'm switching sides like Vommack did. @Super Radio: Yes, the enemies sections are writed good, only that some images are missing. And the article totally lacks colors...
  6. 3D Player 2004 (talk) per Ninelevendo

Keep Featured Article Status[edit]

Removal of Support/Oppose Votes[edit]

Comments[edit]

@BabyLuigi Oh well. I didn't know. I don't look into the engine of the game or something, so I don't know how sprites are obtained. Not at all. This means that I could easily get the images of MPIT cards in other easier ways instead of editing screenshots? At least I learned something... and for the controls, I don't know why they aren't there. They can be easily found in sites such as GameFAQ. I'll add them as soon as possible, still, I must choose a way to incorporate them. I don't know how they work in game and I don't want to write fakes. YoshiCGicon.pngTSUNAMIArtwork of Plessie with the four playable characters, from Super Mario 3D World.

Well the Spriter's Resource sprites are scant as I suspected. It's better if you take a screenshot of them via emulator. BabyLuigiFire.png Ray Trace(T|C) 14:59, 31 July 2014 (EDT)
OK, but I cannot until August 10th. I'm in vacation without PC and I don't think that emulators for tablet exist. YoshiCGicon.pngTSUNAMIArtwork of Plessie with the four playable characters, from Super Mario 3D World.
They most certainly do. What type of Tablet have you got? (I took this from my iPad) - Ninelevendo's Sig Image 20:05, 7 August 2014 (EDT)
Android, Samsung Galaxy Tab 2. But there are two days before I will return, so I don't think it's worth downloading one. If you must play with the virtual keyboard, I'll pass. YoshiCGicon.pngTSUNAMIArtwork of Plessie with the four playable characters, from Super Mario 3D World.

@SuperRadio It's funny how nobody observes the enemy tables written just for the sake of this article being featured. -- -- KOOPA CON CARNE

Yes, we have tables, but they make the hpgame seem like the game boy can't display colour at all. They are an eye sore. - Ninelevendo's Sig Image16:21, 10 August 2014 (EDT)
... and then I think to myself... CAN THE GAME BOY DISPLAY COLOR AT ALL???? Excuse me for clamoring, but c'mon man. The tables are gray because I wanted them to aesthetically fit the graphical limitations of the Game Boy. Besides, regarding the sprites, well... aren't they monochrome? Anyway, unless this is the answer you've asked for, I still have no idea what you mean by "hpgame" (trust me, I googled it). And maybe it's just you who thinks the tables/sprites are eye sore. -- -- KOOPA CON CARNE
I look at it and just get hit with grey and black. There just aren't enough images in general anyway. (If the game boy didn't display colour, Pokemon would seem different.) hpgame is either a game on a HP, a hype game or a really bad typo. - Ninelevendo's Sig Image 04:59, 11 August 2014 (EDT)
BTW, it's mainly the Level section I hate. The others still aren't the best, but are pretty good. - Ninelevendo's Sig Image 05:01, 11 August 2014 (EDT)

@Randombob-omb4761 @Vommack I switched sides after re-reading the article. Now please delete my name from that, otherwise you will delete a supporter. YoshiCGicon.pngTSUNAMIArtwork of Plessie with the four playable characters, from Super Mario 3D World.

Retrieved from "https://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=MarioWiki:Featured_articles/Unfeature/N1/Donkey_Kong_Land&oldid=2436557"