MarioWiki:Appeals/Archive 1: Difference between revisions
mNo edit summary |
m (Text replacement - "Proposals\/Archive[ _]" to "Proposals/Archive/") |
||
(20 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{MarioWiki:Appeals/Archive/Template}} | |||
{ | |||
===Plumber=== | ===Plumber=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|warning|overturned|No sockpuppeting, no warning.}} | |||
*[[User_talk:Plumber/Archive_1#End_of_the_Line|End of the Line]] | *[[User_talk:Plumber/Archive_1#End_of_the_Line|End of the Line]] | ||
Line 24: | Line 15: | ||
===Superfiremario=== | ===Superfiremario=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|reminder|stands|Editing userspace too much ''is'' breaking the rules, and if the initial [[Template:userspace|Userspace reminder template]] isn't followed, harsher warnings can be used, and punishment can even be doled out if that doesn't work either. It's not invalid, so it stays.}} | |||
*[[User talk:Superfiremario/Archive 4#Reminder|This.]] | *[[User talk:Superfiremario/Archive 4#Reminder|This.]] | ||
Line 36: | Line 26: | ||
===Reversinator=== | ===Reversinator=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|warning|stands|{{User|Edofenrir}} made it pretty clear why you received your warning [[User_talk:Time_Q/Archive_7#Question_about_a_Warning|here]] and the Admin Board stands behind him.}} | |||
*[[User talk:Reversinator/Archive_5#Warning|This.]] | *[[User talk:Reversinator/Archive_5#Warning|This.]] | ||
Line 50: | Line 39: | ||
===Goomba's Shoe15=== | ===Goomba's Shoe15=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|warning|overturned|Checking contributions and undoing bad edits is not stalking, it's looking out for the wiki, which is a good thing.}} | |||
*[http://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=User_talk:Goomba%27s_Shoe15&oldid=1043400#Stop_stalking_me this] | *[http://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=User_talk:Goomba%27s_Shoe15&oldid=1043400#Stop_stalking_me this] | ||
Line 63: | Line 51: | ||
===Goomba's Shoe15=== | ===Goomba's Shoe15=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|reminder|overturned|Removing speculation is following policy: it's following the rules, not breaking them.}} | |||
*[[User talk:Goomba's Shoe15#Speculation|this]] | *[[User talk:Goomba's Shoe15#Speculation|this]] | ||
Line 76: | Line 63: | ||
===DKPetey99=== | ===DKPetey99=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|warning|stands|Ignorance is no excuse, and besides, you shouldn't outright revert an edit like that without taking it to the talk page, regardless of who made the edit.}} | |||
====DKPetey99==== | ====DKPetey99==== | ||
*I was given [[User talk:DKPetey99/Archive 1#A Warning to the people...|this]] warning for undoing [http://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=Mario_Party_DS&diff=928548&oldid=925090 this] edit. I am opposing this warning for two reasons: | *I was given [[User talk:DKPetey99/Archive 1#A Warning to the people...|this]] warning for undoing [http://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=Mario_Party_DS&diff=928548&oldid=925090 this] edit. I am opposing this warning for two reasons: | ||
Line 91: | Line 76: | ||
===Reversinator=== | ===Reversinator=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|warning|overturned|Calling a proposal "stupid" isn't very polite, but it's not flaming the proposer either. Also, this case isn't actually the same as the Warning Tucayo gave Reversinator because that was for his behaviour in general, whereas this is one isolated incident, which doesn't warrant a Warning in an of itself.}} | |||
*[http://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=User_talk:Reversinator&action=edit§ion=50 Here.] | *[http://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=User_talk:Reversinator&action=edit§ion=50 Here.] | ||
Line 105: | Line 89: | ||
===DK and Diddy Kong vs Bowser and Bowser Jr.=== | ===DK and Diddy Kong vs Bowser and Bowser Jr.=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|warning|restored|The warning should never have been altered in the first place: only admins have that right, and only if they have a good reason for it.}} | |||
*[http://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=User_talk:DK_and_Diddy_Kong_vs_Bowser_and_Bowser_Jr.&diff=1033420&oldid=1032513 This]. | *[http://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=User_talk:DK_and_Diddy_Kong_vs_Bowser_and_Bowser_Jr.&diff=1033420&oldid=1032513 This]. | ||
Line 118: | Line 101: | ||
===Arceus79=== | ===Arceus79=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|warning|stands|Deleting conversations is not allowed. Ignorance of talk page usage is no excuse for breaking policies and repeatedly reverting valid edits.}} | |||
*[[User_talk:Arceus79#Warning|this]] | *[[User_talk:Arceus79#Warning|this]] | ||
Line 131: | Line 113: | ||
===Paperphailurethemariomonster99=== | ===Paperphailurethemariomonster99=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|reminder|overturned|Both users were overreacting and issuing inappropriate warnings in this matter. Almost all of them have been removed, including this one.}} | |||
*[[User talk:Paperphailurethemariomonster99#Mhm.]] | *[[User talk:Paperphailurethemariomonster99#Mhm.]] | ||
Line 143: | Line 124: | ||
===Magikrazy51=== | ===Magikrazy51=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|reminder|overturned|While unnecessary, Magikrazy's comment was not intended as an insult. Furthermore, a first-time display of discourteous behavior is not punishable by a reminder according to the Courtesy policy.}} | |||
*[[User talk:Magikrazy51#Reminder 2|here]] | *[[User talk:Magikrazy51#Reminder 2|here]] | ||
Line 155: | Line 135: | ||
===YoshiKong=== | ===YoshiKong=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|userspace warning|stands|Your editing is better now, but at the time, the warning was deserved, and so it stays as a permanent record, just like with everyone else who's gotten one.}} | |||
*http://www.mariowiki.com/User_talk:YoshiKong#UserSpace | *http://www.mariowiki.com/User_talk:YoshiKong#UserSpace | ||
Line 171: | Line 150: | ||
===B.wilson=== | ===B.wilson=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|warning|stands|Reminders and/or Warnings given by an [[MarioWiki:Administrators|administrator]] or [[MarioWiki:Patrollers|patroller]] cannot be appealed.}} | |||
*[http://www.mariowiki.com/User_talk:B.wilson#Warning] | *[http://www.mariowiki.com/User_talk:B.wilson#Warning] | ||
Line 184: | Line 162: | ||
===Jazama=== | ===Jazama=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|reminder|overturned|Removing forum-like comments from talk pages is allowed.}} | |||
*[[User talk:Jazama#Reminder 2|Reminder]] | *[[User talk:Jazama#Reminder 2|Reminder]] | ||
====Jazama==== | ====Jazama==== | ||
* According to [[MarioWiki:Proposals/ | * According to [[MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive/29#Regarding Comments not Pertaining to Improving the Article|this proposal,]] it is perfectly acceptable to revert talk page comments if it is not about improving the article. | ||
====Chris Helper==== | ====Chris Helper==== | ||
*[NO COMMENT] | *[NO COMMENT] | ||
Line 195: | Line 172: | ||
===Prince Ludwig=== | ===Prince Ludwig=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|warning|overturned|While perhaps unnecessarily antagonistic in spots, Prince Ludwig's messages were not overtly insulting. Futhermore, [[Mariowiki:Courtesy]] states that a first-time display of discourteous behaviour is not worthy of a formal reminder, much less a warning.}} | |||
*[[User_talk:Prince_Ludwig#Warning_2]] | *[[User_talk:Prince_Ludwig#Warning_2]] | ||
====Prince Ludwig==== | ====Prince Ludwig==== | ||
Line 206: | Line 182: | ||
===JORDAN DEBONO=== | ===JORDAN DEBONO=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|warning|overturned|Editing an old revision and accidentally removing the comment made in the meantime is an understandable mistake.}} | |||
*[[User talk:JORDAN DEBONO#Warning (2)]] | *[[User talk:JORDAN DEBONO#Warning (2)]] | ||
====JORDAN DEBONO==== | ====JORDAN DEBONO==== | ||
*While there are no actual facts as for me to defend myself, the comment was not done intentionally, but rather through many edits to the page happening '''at the same time'''. When this happened, GreenDisaster, wrote his comment just after I had saved mine. When I came to ''publishing'', my own, I mistakenly deleted his. Nothing intentional was done. Yes, in the past I have done similar, but as I have repeatedly told different users, that was a time where all this wiki stuff was new to me. I didn't know how things worked. Once I stopped and restarted here, you can see I have changed a lot, answering TPPs and any problems users have, and the odd mainspace edit here and there. The gap proves this difference. I have disagreed with many users since I came back, but I have never deleted comments or anything of the sort. Why would I start with GD after all this time especially. This is my defense and I do hope you believe me. | *While there are no actual facts as for me to defend myself, the comment was not done intentionally, but rather through many edits to the page happening '''at the same time'''. When this happened, GreenDisaster, wrote his comment just after I had saved mine. When I came to ''publishing'', my own, I mistakenly deleted his. Nothing intentional was done. Yes, in the past I have done similar, but as I have repeatedly told different users, that was a time where all this wiki stuff was new to me. I didn't know how things worked. Once I stopped and restarted here, you can see I have changed a lot, answering TPPs and any problems users have, and the odd mainspace edit here and there. The gap proves this difference. I have disagreed with many users since I came back, but I have never deleted comments or anything of the sort. Why would I start with GD after all this time especially. This is my defense and I do hope you believe me. | ||
====GreenDisaster==== | ====GreenDisaster==== | ||
Line 221: | Line 193: | ||
===Prince Ludwig=== | ===Prince Ludwig=== | ||
{{AppealOutcome|warning|overturned|The warning was given to antagonize the user, although it was also claimed that it was a joke. Either way, it's unacceptable.}} | |||
*[[User_talk:Prince_Ludwig#Hey.]] | *[[User_talk:Prince_Ludwig#Hey.]] | ||
====Prince Ludwig==== | ====Prince Ludwig==== | ||
Line 232: | Line 202: | ||
---- | ---- | ||
[[ | |||
===YoshiandWaluigi=== | |||
{{AppealOutcome|warning|overturned|A user making mistakes is not the same as vandalism: no warning should have been given.}} | |||
*http://www.mariowiki.com/User_talk:YoshiandWaluigi#Warning | |||
====YoshiandWaluigi==== | |||
*I was given a warning from YoshiKong for continuously editing an article. This was because I was new, I didn't really know what I was doing and I wanted to make my edit perfect. I also accidentally edited the header which I didn't mean to do. However, he has now apologized to me and said I could appeal to the warning. | |||
====YoshiKong==== | |||
*I agree that the warning was undeserved. I initially saw the offense as vandalism but I should've asked questions first, rather than just assume. | |||
---- | |||
===GreenDisaster=== | |||
{{AppealOutcome|reminder|overturned|Removing reasons from support votes is enforcing the rules.}} | |||
*[http://www.mariowiki.com/User_talk:GreenDisaster#Reminder Reminder]. | |||
====GreenDisaster==== | |||
*I have received a reminder from MortonBoo because, on the [http://www.mariowiki.com/MarioWiki:Featured_Articles/N/Mario_Kart_7 nomination page] for ''[[Mario Kart 7]]'', he had left a reason with his support vote. Since the rules for article nominations state that support votes, excluding the starting vote, cannot have reasons, I removed the reason, but not the vote. Today, Morton has given me a reminder because I had removed his reason. As I have mentioned, it was against the rules, and I have been doing similar things to other users for quite some time. Why, after so long, should I get a reminder for doing this? | |||
====MortonBoo99==== | |||
*[NO COMMENT] | |||
---- | |||
===GalaxyFan=== | |||
{{AppealOutcome|reminder|overturned|No rules were broken.}} | |||
*[[User talk:GalaxyFan#Reminder]] | |||
====GalaxyFan==== | |||
*I was falsely given a reminder for not marking edits as minor when editing many pages at once over a week ago, when in actuality, I ''did'' mark them as minor. After I informed the issuer of the reminder, it was crossed out and he apologized, but the reminder was not officially removed. | |||
====TheRedOne==== | |||
*[NO COMMENT] |
Latest revision as of 10:34, September 13, 2021
Plumberwarning overturned Plumber
Paper Jorge
Superfiremarioreminder stands Superfiremario
Goomba's Shoe15
Reversinatorwarning stands Reversinator
Tucayo
Goomba's Shoe15warning overturned Goomba's Shoe15
Yoshiyoshiyoshi
Goomba's Shoe15reminder overturned Goomba's Shoe15
Plumber690
DKPetey99warning stands DKPetey99
I know the warning was issued January 15, and I joined December 11, but remember, I was blocked for 7 days. At the least, I'd rather have this become a reminder, because I was new to the wiki, again not knowing MeritC was a sysop. I was also unaware that undoing a sysop's edit is illegal. Rise Up Above It
Reversinatorwarning overturned Reversinator
Goomba's Shoe15
DK and Diddy Kong vs Bowser and Bowser Jr.warning restored to original form
DKPetey99I am appealing this last warning for DK and Diddy Kong vs Bowser and Bowser Jr. I originally gave him a warning for editing other user's comments. However, Reversinator changed it into a last warning. His reason being: "He has three reminders and a warning." Well, there is where you went wrong Reversinator. Kongs vs Koopas only got two reminders, one being an invalid reminder because the reminders he gave me were deleted. So, I don't think that a last warning suits this situation because he only has one warning and one reminder. I want this to be overturned into a warning because a last warning seems very inappropriate for this current situation. Reversinator
Arceus79warning stands Arceus79
WikiofSmash
Paperphailurethemariomonster99reminder overturned Paperphailurethemariomonster99
Mechawave
Magikrazy51reminder overturned Magikrazy51
Boowhoplaysgames
YoshiKonguserspace warning stands YoshiKong
At one stage, there were many individual edits made on my userpage. This is because, at the time, I was using my userpage as a sandbox, and practising applying tables and infoboxes, which i was planning to add to some 'Wario Land 4' stub articles (since there are alot!). So, I don't think that I deserve to have this warning permanently stuck on my talk page. New Super Yoshi
B.wilsonwarning stands B.wilson
Phoenix
Jazamareminder overturned Jazama
Chris Helper
Prince Ludwigwarning overturned Prince Ludwig
Electrical Bowser jr.
JORDAN DEBONOwarning overturned JORDAN DEBONO
GreenDisaster
Prince Ludwigwarning overturned Prince Ludwig
Master Bowser Jr.
YoshiandWaluigiwarning overturned YoshiandWaluigi
YoshiKong
GreenDisasterreminder overturned GreenDisaster
MortonBoo99
GalaxyFanreminder overturned GalaxyFan
TheRedOne
|