Talk:Chancellor

Merge with Minister?

If the two characters are the same name in Japan, and even in the American games they both look very similar (moustache, green spots, etc.) and play similar roles in the goverment, should we merge the two pages into one? Stumpers! 09:40, 14 August 2008 (EDT)

Well, there's no confirmation on them being the same character. They do look similar, though. If they had had the same name everywhere, then they could've been the same person (Thus I have merged the two Merlon pages). I don't know what to say. IMO, they seem like the same person(How'd he get demoted to Minister in PM, I dunno), but hard to say. Marcelagus (T • C • E)

Previously, we've had this problem with Kamek. NoA named him Kamek instead of following NoJ and naming him after his species. We wondered: should Kamek be merged with Magikoopa because his Japanese name is the same? We decided not to based on Yoshi, Birdo, and Toad, major players who are named after their species. This is a little different though. Still, we didn't create separate articles for Princess Toadstool and Princess Peach. Stumpers! 14:48, 14 August 2008 (EDT)

Well... it's kind of hard, because as of phtsical appearance, the main thing is the design on their mushroom, and their Moustache. The mustaches are different colors in each game(What, did he get older in PM?), and as for mushroom design, there's just so many others with the same pattern. (As you can see, Herb T. even has the mustache going on). I think there still might be some info/proof lacking just yet to merge these articles. There might be an in-game hint of somekind, loosely connecting the two characters, but as for now, there's no sure way of knowing.

File:TheGreenToadT.PNG File:Battle T.PNG Marcelagus (T • C • E)

For now I think just linking to the other article is fine. I'd like to do as little conjecturing as possible. ;) Stumpers! 15:24, 14 August 2008 (EDT)

The Minister and Chancellor have the same title in Japan - Kinoko Daijin (Mushroom Cabinet Minister). I think it's safe to say that they're the same character, and remember, if NoA tampers with it, he technically wasn't demoted. LinkTheLefty 15:14, 12 November 2008 (EST)

Toadsworth

Since Stumpers wanted to know when Toadsworth was referred to as a chancellor: In Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door, Goombella tells the player that Toadsworth is the Mushroom Kingdom's chancellor. At least she does so in the German translation (and the German translation is based on the Japanese original). --Grandy02 17:00, 12 November 2008 (EST)

Thanks, Grandy! I suppose it would make sense: the Chancellor becomes the Minister, and then Toadsworth took over his old position, perhaps? Stumpers! 19:23, 12 November 2008 (EST)