MarioWiki:Appeals/Archive: Difference between revisions
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
m (Protected "MarioWiki:Appeals/Archive": Archive ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite))) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 133: | Line 133: | ||
:My entire thing is, even if I take you at face value, the closest rule RickTommy's edit could've come close to breaking is edit warring, and that's a strong '''maybe''' on the matter. And assuming that IS the case, why not discuss it with them on the article's talk page or their own talk page, rather than [https://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=User_talk:RickTommy&diff=2720590&oldid=2714880 leaving a message insinuating that your spelling is the only possible spelling, and that attempting to posit otherwise would result in "harsher consequences"?] It's that "my way or the highway" tone in particular - which, AGAIN, I noticed you have been told about multiple times previously - that, in my opinion, prompted and warranted the warning. | :My entire thing is, even if I take you at face value, the closest rule RickTommy's edit could've come close to breaking is edit warring, and that's a strong '''maybe''' on the matter. And assuming that IS the case, why not discuss it with them on the article's talk page or their own talk page, rather than [https://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=User_talk:RickTommy&diff=2720590&oldid=2714880 leaving a message insinuating that your spelling is the only possible spelling, and that attempting to posit otherwise would result in "harsher consequences"?] It's that "my way or the highway" tone in particular - which, AGAIN, I noticed you have been told about multiple times previously - that, in my opinion, prompted and warranted the warning. | ||
---- | |||
===Toadette the Achiever=== | |||
{{AppealOutcome|reminder|overturned|While valid points, a message on the user's talk page that <u>clearly</u> notifies them would have been a better follow-up to an easily missable edit summary for a matter like this than a reminder.}} | |||
*[[Special:Diff/2837104|Here]]. | |||
====Toadette the Achiever==== | |||
*While I agree that the concern being brought up is definitely valid, I feel that it's much too early to receive a reminder over, as stated within the second paragraph of the [[MarioWiki:Courtesy|courtesy policy]]. This is especially considering the fact that I was never previously warned not to use a "copy-paste" kind of content creation in the past. | |||
====Bye Guy==== | |||
*[https://www.mariowiki.com/index.php?title=Banana_Barrels&diff=2775403&oldid=2775391 You were told before] and I figured that an informal warning should be followed by a reminder. However, the former is an edit summary that you might have simply not seen, so I'm not sure if it counts. | |||
