Talk:Bean: Difference between revisions

:::::::Let me rephrase that; read Waluigi Time's reason for selecting Option D. There's a page that lists all the mushrooms from Mario Party and Mario Kart, instead of having separate articles for each one. Why don't we split that too? I don't see the benefit of creating more articles to manage when we'd be perfectly fine having one big article. I see your reasoning, but I feel it's just unnecessary work, and I feel most people would agree. --[[User:MikhailMCraft|MikhailMCraft]] ([[User talk:MikhailMCraft|talk]]) 14:45, September 27, 2019 (EDT)

::::::::I'd actually like to call Waluigi Time's vote into question as well (and TheDarkStar's "per" vote along with it). How on earth can you classify short, near-identical articles as "unacceptable", especially when they've been accepted by the community in the past? (See [[Double 1-Up Mushroom]], [[Super Cheese]], [[Ultra Cheese]], [[Max Cheese]], [[Miracle Cheese]], and [[Cheesy Drumstick]] as examples.) Additionally, a key part of the argument is flat-out invalid; [[Dash Mushroom]]s are separate, and the RPG Mushroom argument is helplessly vague (if this is about classifying Mushrooms between the ''Paper Mario'' and ''Mario & Luigi'' series, then it's definitely irrelevant). Granted, the ''Mario Kart'' series Mushrooms aren't separate yet; however, there has been some [[Talk:Golden Dash Mushroom|talk about whether to merge them into the existing Dash Mushroom article]] due to obscure yet quintessential similarities. {{User:Toadette the Achiever/sig}} 15:08, September 27, 2019 (EDT)

I concur that the "single letter difference" for the item type you forget to use in the first place seems seems excessive. My vote above cam before that was noted. [[User:Doc von Schmeltwick|Doc von Schmeltwick]] ([[User talk:Doc von Schmeltwick|talk]]) 15:05, September 27, 2019 (EDT)