Editing Talk:Dinosaur
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision | Your text | ||
Line 57: | Line 57: | ||
I'd like to revisit this with a fresher mindset in light of the [[Talk:Nossie|changes]] since the last proposal. | I'd like to revisit this with a fresher mindset in light of the [[Talk:Nossie|changes]] since the last proposal. | ||
I pointed out three things the article generically covered during the last proposal above: '''the humanoid dinos in the ''[[Super Mario Bros. (film)|Super Mario Bros.]]'' film''', which as of now are already covered at [[Dinohattanite]], '''the Apatosaurus in [[Dino Dino Jungle]] and elsewhere''', which as of now | I pointed out three things the article generically covered during the last proposal above: '''the humanoid dinos in the ''[[Super Mario Bros. (film)|Super Mario Bros.]]'' film''', which as of now are already covered at [[Dinohattanite]], '''the Apatosaurus in [[Dino Dino Jungle]] and elsewhere''', which as of now are already covered at [[Nossie]], and '''the dinosaurs from the ''[[Super Mario World (television series)|Super Mario World]]'' cartoon''', of which the case I make here will be detailed in the next few sentences. | ||
All in all, I'd say the biggest point of contention is the ''Super Mario World'' case; I already contacted {{user|Doc von Schmeltwick}} about it, and even she isn't sure herself. Therefore, I'd say there's currently no consensus for or against creating an article on those specific dinosaurs, and that's a discussion independent of this proposal. | All in all, I'd say the biggest point of contention is the ''Super Mario World'' case; I already contacted {{user|Doc von Schmeltwick}} about it, and even she isn't sure herself. Therefore, I'd say there's currently no consensus for or against creating an article on those specific dinosaurs, and that's a discussion independent of this proposal. |