Talk:Super Mario Bros.: Difference between revisions

From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
(North American release date change)
Line 100: Line 100:
*The NES was test-marketed that Christmas in NY. Only 50K of 100K units sold, so they went to LA the next February. It's pretty certain that SMB was not available in NY, but it possibly could have been available in LA. Supporting this is an ad from the LA Times in 13/3/86 that supposedly mentions SMB. (It's pay-to-view, so no one knows for sure - all we know comes from the descriptive text that comes with the Google result.)
*The NES was test-marketed that Christmas in NY. Only 50K of 100K units sold, so they went to LA the next February. It's pretty certain that SMB was not available in NY, but it possibly could have been available in LA. Supporting this is an ad from the LA Times in 13/3/86 that supposedly mentions SMB. (It's pay-to-view, so no one knows for sure - all we know comes from the descriptive text that comes with the Google result.)
*So it is reasonable to conclude that SMB was released to the entire country sometime after that LA Times ad. Similar ads and full-blown news stories start to widely appear in August. The first mention in any English-language media is a 19/8/86 Reuters story in the Philadelphia Inquirer and several other newspapers.  
*So it is reasonable to conclude that SMB was released to the entire country sometime after that LA Times ad. Similar ads and full-blown news stories start to widely appear in August. The first mention in any English-language media is a 19/8/86 Reuters story in the Philadelphia Inquirer and several other newspapers.  
Conclusion: If SMB sold in the US at the same rate as Japan, then that would point to a 4 or 5/86 release date, but we have no proof of that so far. But for the moment, I think a) the 18/10/85 date is pure hokey (and upon contacting Nintendo, they don't even know where they got it from) and b) an '86 date seems pretty likely. So there's my case. [[User:Toadfan|Toadfan]] 22:07, 27 August 2009 (EDT)
Conclusion: Now, Mario games can be released almost simultaneously in all regions, and Nintendo knows they will sell well. But it was different in 1985. Nintendo had no idea how SMB would sell in Japan, and it would have been silly to throw money at a US version without ensuring it had strong Japanese sales first. SMB did sell well in Japan, and (to quote one of the participants in the linked discussion) "sales take time, they don't happen immediately." By the time Nintendo realised it would be a good idea to come to the US, it was already 1986. The 18/10/85 date is pure hokey. Nintendo doesn't even know where they got it from. So there's my case. [[User:Toadfan|Toadfan]] 22:07, 27 August 2009 (EDT)

Revision as of 11:17, August 28, 2009

This article is part of PipeProject SMWikify, an attempt to Super Mario Wikify (for this article – Un-Wikipedia-fy) on the Super Mario Wiki. If you would like to participate, you can edit the article attached to this page, or visit the PipeProject SMWikify page, where you can join the project and/or contribute to the discussion.
PPSMBS Logo.PNG This article is part of PipeProject Super Mario Bros. Series, an attempt to improve upon any and all articles pertaining to the Super Mario Bros. series on the Super Mario Wiki. If you would like to participate, you can edit the article attached to this page, or visit the PipeProject Super Mario Bros. Series page, where you can join the project and/or contribute to the discussion.

Since the Glitches section only has one glitch (Minus World), and there is an article for this glitch, shouldn't we just remove the glitch section in the article entirely? Waluigi Freak 99 17:49, 9 September 2006 (EDT)

Or put a link to the Minus World and take out the section...whatever suits you. -- Son of Suns

Enemies section

Shouldn't there be some sort of section for the enemies in the game? After all, the instruction booklet included such a section, and it would seem fitting here. --Alan Redgown56 15:09, 24 December 2006 (EST)

Yes it fits here. Paper Jorge

Mario Deluxe

It says on the page Super Mario Bros Deluxe was only availible in Japan. But that cant be, that was the first mario game i ever played and it deffinately wasnt in japanese. My sister got it for a gift.Widkid85 10:51, 11 February 2007 (EST)

Done. Removed false information. Knife (talk)

Unwikifying

Could the person who put the sign there please tell us what has been dumped? I want to help you guys fix this article, but I don't know where to start! -Stumpers

The introduction needs to be completely rewritten, as well as the attacks and moves section. -- Son of Suns
Thanks. I'll see what I can do. Maybe this weekend? -Stumpers


Came out of a pipe?

What does it mean by they came out of a pipe. They lived there all there life. The Brooklyn thing has never been stated in a game.
The preceding unsigned comment was added by Pal101 (talk).

Disambuigation

This page should be a Disambuigation for SMB, Mario Bros., and Super Mario Bros. (movie). Comments?

Max2 (talk)

No. This is by far the most common use of the phrase "Super Mario Bros.", while the meanings of things like Yoshi's Island all are used commonly enough. The movie can be linked to with {{articleabout}} or something similar, and Mario Bros. (talking about the game?) has a quite different name. - Cobold (talk · contribs) 16:52, 8 August 2007 (EDT)

no! The brothers themselves, who are called the Super Mario Brothers many times! Max2 (talk)

Max has a good point. I would be in favor of the move of this page to Super Mario Bros. (game) and linking the disambiguation page to the Mario and Luigi articles. Oh, and for the record, plenty of casual gamers call this game Mario Bros. I know we cater to the hardcore crowd, but it would prevent any confusion. Stumpers!

Story section

Is their any source the story is taken from? - Cobold (talk · contribs) 10:53, 28 October 2007 (EDT)

Super Mario Bros. instruction manual. -- Son of Suns

play it

YaYz0rZ! i found a link to play the ORIGINAL!!

i got to the minus world here
The preceding unsigned comment was added by BlueYoshter (talk).

List of Levels

In the "list of levels" section, there are several links to non-existent pages. If I make these pages existent, does that count as SMWikifying? Or does it count as helping this page in any way? — Stooben Rooben Either way, I'm making the pages.

I don't know, but I have another question: Why is the underwater area in 8-4 secret? I think you have to go/swim through it to reach Bowser, don't you? I don't know how it is in 5-2, though. And BTW, sorry if that sounds impolite (I don't hope so), but your world pages sound a li'l bit opiniated. (e.g., the word "oddly" or considering Hammer Bro. as the most hated enemy in the game) :( See Talk:Main Page#Opiniated Language. --PaperStriker 09:28, 17 January 2008 (EST)

No, that's not impolite! I'm still learning what not to do around here. As for 8-4, it isn't secret and I'm changing that on this page, and leaving it out when I make the article. I'll change the opinionated words though...you're kind of right on that. Thanks. — Stooben Rooben *goes to fix boo-boos*

Trivia section

One of the two trivias of SMB is that "contrary to popular belief, it is possible for the player to jump over the flag in certain levels of the game," or something. This is not the first place I've heard this rumor, but for some reason there are no pictures of this trick, or list of levels that you can jump over the flag. Has anyone been able to do it, cuz if not we might have to consider deleting this trivia. Glitchmansig.PNG Glitchman (talk · contribs) Glitchmansig.PNG

It is possible in The Lost Levels because of the new spring-boards there, but in Super Mario Bros. it is only a glitch and can go to the List of Glitches page with further elaboration. - Cobold (talk · contribs) 16:49, 25 January 2008 (EST)

Gallery Images

Ok, why is there artwork in the gallery that isn't even from the game this article is about? The Gravitator 02:00, 6 September 2008 (EDT)

I've removed some of the artwork that was obviously from a different game. Thanks for noticing, though. Marcelagus (TCE)

No problem. Isn't that image of Peach from a different game too though? I thought her hair has a different color back in the original game. The Gravitator 13:33, 6 September 2008 (EDT)

She always had gold hair out of game. Much like the Brown/Orange Yoshi thing - color limitations caused in-game sprites to differ from out-game artwork. Stumpers! 20:14, 6 September 2008 (EDT)

Beta Mushroom Music

This guy corrupted Super Mario Bros. and I noticed whenever he gets a mushroom or fire flower, it makes a different tune that's not glitched up. Here is the link --> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CuL0Ij0RU10&feature=related --Onestop 16:46, 13 October 2008 (EDT)

He used a Game Genie code. Therefore, obviously it shouldn't be included in the article. Stuff without Game Genie, such as the infamous World-1 glitch or stuff, should be added. Also, if the guy corrupted it, it makes it his own video, which is not nnintendo related. Other comments? Super-YoshiMust...eat...sig...Talk? C???

stubby

stubby imo --XyzCoRy123ABC 21:08, 16 October 2008 (EDT)

...How? Wtf? A Stub is like 3 sentences with an image template and a couple of categories in it. This isnt a stub. Super-YoshiMust...eat...sig...Talk? C???

Per S-Y. If you wanna complain about stubs, go here. — Stooben Rooben 21:14, 16 October 2008 (EDT)

Stars on Level List?

I've been wondering, why are there stars on Worlds 3 and 6? Mr.C

North American release date change

I have changed the North American release date (formerly listed in the infobox as 18/10/1985) to "1985/1986". (In fact, it should probably be changed to just 1986.) It was impossible to release the game in Japan on 13/9 and then turn around and release it in the USA one month later. A discussion is currently taking place at Wikipedia (wikipedia:Talk:Super Mario Bros.#North American Release Date) and here's what I can gather from reading it:

  • SMB was released in Japan on 13/9/85, as we know.
  • Nintendo approached New York retailers around the same time in order to get their products in store for Christmas. It is thought 18/10 is the day they started this. SMB was not even a pack-in in Japan yet. The Christmas shopping season started on 29/11 that year.
  • During the same three months, sales of SMB boomed in Japan. Then-Nintendo president Hiroshi Yamauchi decided to pack-in SMB with the Famicom in late November or early December. Then, he decided to bring it to the US. Which means US game development commenced in December 1985, pretty much ruling out a 1985 release date.
  • The NES was test-marketed that Christmas in NY. Only 50K of 100K units sold, so they went to LA the next February. It's pretty certain that SMB was not available in NY, but it possibly could have been available in LA. Supporting this is an ad from the LA Times in 13/3/86 that supposedly mentions SMB. (It's pay-to-view, so no one knows for sure - all we know comes from the descriptive text that comes with the Google result.)
  • So it is reasonable to conclude that SMB was released to the entire country sometime after that LA Times ad. Similar ads and full-blown news stories start to widely appear in August. The first mention in any English-language media is a 19/8/86 Reuters story in the Philadelphia Inquirer and several other newspapers.

Conclusion: Now, Mario games can be released almost simultaneously in all regions, and Nintendo knows they will sell well. But it was different in 1985. Nintendo had no idea how SMB would sell in Japan, and it would have been silly to throw money at a US version without ensuring it had strong Japanese sales first. SMB did sell well in Japan, and (to quote one of the participants in the linked discussion) "sales take time, they don't happen immediately." By the time Nintendo realised it would be a good idea to come to the US, it was already 1986. The 18/10/85 date is pure hokey. Nintendo doesn't even know where they got it from. So there's my case. Toadfan 22:07, 27 August 2009 (EDT)