Talk:Mario's Shirt: Difference between revisions
Bloc Partier (talk | contribs) |
|||
| Line 41: | Line 41: | ||
I was actually waiting until some of my other merges were going to be settled, then I was going to set one up here. I was going to propose all of Mario's clothes be merged into a single article (possibly "Mario's Clothing"), with the exception of his hat (and apparently overalls), due to them affecting gameplay. [[User:Redstar|Redstar]] 15:49, 26 December 2009 (EST) | I was actually waiting until some of my other merges were going to be settled, then I was going to set one up here. I was going to propose all of Mario's clothes be merged into a single article (possibly "Mario's Clothing"), with the exception of his hat (and apparently overalls), due to them affecting gameplay. [[User:Redstar|Redstar]] 15:49, 26 December 2009 (EST) | ||
:I see what you mean, but I really don't see the point of having an article about his shirt. I mean, it's obviously there. We don't need to point out with an entire article the fact that Mario wears a shirt. By this logic, why don't we have [[Luigi's Socks]], since they can be seen in the artwork of [[M&L:SS]]? It's just silly to have a page dedicated to something so obvious and unrelated to gameplay. {{user|Bloc Partier}} | :I see what you mean, but I really don't see the point of having an article about his shirt. I mean, it's obviously there. We don't need to point out with an entire article the fact that Mario wears a shirt. By this logic, why don't we have [[Luigi's Socks]], since they can be seen in the artwork of [[M&L:SS]]? It's just silly to have a page dedicated to something so obvious and unrelated to gameplay. {{user|Bloc Partier}} | ||
::I don't feel an article on his clothing his necessarily necessary, but it is iconic and people created the articles for a reason, so it may be better to just salvage what information we can and put it all in one place. | |||
::Also, your proposal is stretched out farther than it should be. You really don't need a Part 2, especially since the article would undoubtedly be deleted upon merging. You might as well just have one section, with three options "Delete, without merging", "merge", and "Leave alone". As it is now, it can be a bit confusing. [[User:Redstar|Redstar]] 17:01, 26 December 2009 (EST) | |||
Revision as of 18:01, December 26, 2009
This looks a bit usless but surprisingly it's bigger than the Mario's Overalls page! Useless? Paper Jorge
Yes it should. The information should be moved to the Mario article, however, do not delete this until this has been succesfully done.Knife (talk)
Yeah it should be merged with Mario's Page.--Nintendorules 11:23, 3 July 2008 (EDT)
Aggred, per Paper Jorge. --Yowuza 13:26, 3 July 2008 (EDT)
why should it be merged all his other clothes have their own page-t76ef
I say that all the clothes be merged into on article.
Decision on Mario's Shirt and Other Articles
I believe we need a decision on this and related articles. I shall give many possible options, and one will, hopefully, be chosen.
Please note: you may vote for both Part 1 and Part 2 at the same time. If Mario's shirt is deleted, Part 2 will not be viable.
Proposer: Bloc Partier (talk) Deadline: 20:00, 9 January 2009
Part 1: Keep or Delete Mario's Shirt
Keep This Article: Mario's Shirt
Delete This Article: Mario's Shirt
- Bloc Partier (talk) -- It's an article about a thing that has almost no purpose in any game. It does not affect gameplay, unlike Mario's Overalls or Mario's Hat (see the events in Luigi's Mansion).
- Time Q (talk): Per Bloc Partier.
Part 1 Comments
Part 2: Merge
Merge Mario's Shirt with Mario
Do Not Merge
- Bloc Partier (talk) -- Mario's article does not need to be any longer.
Part 2 Comments
General Comments
I was actually waiting until some of my other merges were going to be settled, then I was going to set one up here. I was going to propose all of Mario's clothes be merged into a single article (possibly "Mario's Clothing"), with the exception of his hat (and apparently overalls), due to them affecting gameplay. Redstar 15:49, 26 December 2009 (EST)
- I see what you mean, but I really don't see the point of having an article about his shirt. I mean, it's obviously there. We don't need to point out with an entire article the fact that Mario wears a shirt. By this logic, why don't we have Luigi's Socks, since they can be seen in the artwork of M&L:SS? It's just silly to have a page dedicated to something so obvious and unrelated to gameplay. Bloc Partier (talk)
- I don't feel an article on his clothing his necessarily necessary, but it is iconic and people created the articles for a reason, so it may be better to just salvage what information we can and put it all in one place.
- Also, your proposal is stretched out farther than it should be. You really don't need a Part 2, especially since the article would undoubtedly be deleted upon merging. You might as well just have one section, with three options "Delete, without merging", "merge", and "Leave alone". As it is now, it can be a bit confusing. Redstar 17:01, 26 December 2009 (EST)
