MarioWiki:Featured articles/N3/Princess Peach

Princess Peach

Support

1. Ashley anEoTselkie (talk) :I think that this page is good writen,with detailed sections,the only bad thing is the Super Mario Kun section
2. Lord Grammaticus (talk)
3. Pinkie Pie (talk)
4. MarioYoshi2 (talk)

Oppose

1. Pinkie Pie (talk) You said "the only bad thing is the Super Mario Kun section". Why would you nominate a article when you said that something is messed up.
2. White Wolf (talk) Super Mario Kun- oh, that needs work! Vandalism!- Major page, major vandals. Plus a whole lotta people edit this, and a whole lotta people have stupid-looking grammar.

Removal of Opposes

White Wolf

1. Mario (talk) I've scoured through, what, 5+ Super Mario-Kun volumes, and Princess Peach doesn't play a huge role, since she doesn't really get a lot of "screen time", especially compared to Mario, Luigi, Yoshi, Bowser, Toad, and even Wario. Nevertheless, I've improved the section a bit, adding an image and a basic what-she-does thing. Now, with that out of the way, I've rendered these two opposes moot.
2. Yoshi876 (talk) Mine's gone, because I'm fine with the article now, also the article is semi-protected so vandals are less of a problem and even if there is bad writing it'll be removed quickly and so the article won't be affected.
3. Ashley anEoTselkie (talk)Sorry if I didn't help very much,I was working these last 5 days. @WhiteWolf any user can vandalize the page,and grammar it is only things to fix, it isn't a big Problem.Pinkie Pie, SMK section looks perfect now.
4. Pinkie Pie (talk) Mine's slashed. I agree with Mario, there is nothing wrong with the article now.
5. Electrical Bowser jr. (talk) I didn't see vandalism...
6. Phoenix (talk) Both the Super Mario-Kun section and the grammar have been improved, and potential for vandalism is not an issue that should prevent the article from being featured. The article now appears to meet Featured Article standards, meaning the remaining oppose vote would be invalid.

Comments

Yeah the Super Mario-Kun section definitely needs work. I'll find some time to add some info....and maybe get someone to read Japanese. Baby Luigi (talk)

Not putting these in the opposition because I'm not 100% sure if they're incomplete. But Mario Tennis Open may be lacking stats and Yoshi's Cookie could go into something about stats, but I'm not sure whether they're applicable in the game, same for Mario Excite Bike. Yoshi876 (talk)

Not sure about the others, but her Mario Tennis Open section isn't lacking statistical information as I don't believe that has any on Peach, but it's definitely lacking information about what type of character she is and some details about the Peach-related clothing in Mario Tennis Open. Seems worthwhile. Icemario11 (talk)

Added Mario Tennis Open info. Baby Luigi (talk)

Increased Mario Tennis Open info a little,Added her minor appearance in Mario Tennis GBC,and added Super Mario Kun Info.Pictures Of Super mario Kun are necessary???I have two,one of her old design in the comic,and one of her new design Ashley anEoTselkie (talk)

Yes, of course. Again I need to find time to do this. Baby Luigi (talk)

That is OK.I wish more info about her role.And I added her stats of Yoshi's,CookieAshley anEoTselkie (talk)

Oh, her role mirrors that with the games....with a Super Mario-Kun twist of course. Baby Luigi (talk)

I added image of Super Mario Kum cover.The only problem now is the M&LDream Team info.I don't know this game.The only thing that I know about it, is that is for 3DS,The user Agent Dave7 writed a script of the game,but now is deletedAshley anEoTselkie (talk)

I own and have beaten the game, so I could take care of the Dream Team section eventually. Icemario11 (talk)

Section has been expanded. All that remains is Super Mario-Kun and the quotes section, I believe. Icemario11 (talk)

I added some quotes.Poorly quotes,but all that i know Ashley anEoTselkie (talk)

Yeah, apparently there's a lack of quotes page for Peach. Kind of troublesome, but one could probably find some on the site if they look at list of quotes for games Peach was in. Icemario11 (talk)

@WhiteWolf, any article can be vandalized, and besides it's semi-protected so only logged in users can edit it. Yoshi876 (talk)

@WhiteWolf grammar is only a little problemAshley anEoTselkie (talk)