Talk:Parrot: Difference between revisions

Line 1: Line 1:
==Delete this page==
==Delete this page==
{{TPP}}
{{SettledTPP}}
{{ProposalOutcome|passed|11-0|delete}}
So, this page is pointless. Literally every single subject in this article is already covered on an independent page elsewhere; there is ''nothing'' in this page that isn't made redundant by the simple existence of another page, and nothing could change that simple fact. The article doesn't cover generic subjects in the slightest, so it certainly cannot be argued on those grounds (and the only generic parrot I could find is the stuffed, non-sentient prop used by [[Co M.C.]] in a single [[Club Mario]] segment; the suggestion that this alone is enough to support the entire article is asinine). This is even more clear-cut than the deletion of [[Talk:Giraffe#Delete_this_page|Giraffe]], since at ''least'' there were generic giraffes to cover. If you need to know about every parrot of note in the franchise, [[:Category:Parrots]] already exists in a perfectly usable form. At best, this article only exists to pad out the species parameter of pages, and that's not good enough to keep it.
So, this page is pointless. Literally every single subject in this article is already covered on an independent page elsewhere; there is ''nothing'' in this page that isn't made redundant by the simple existence of another page, and nothing could change that simple fact. The article doesn't cover generic subjects in the slightest, so it certainly cannot be argued on those grounds (and the only generic parrot I could find is the stuffed, non-sentient prop used by [[Co M.C.]] in a single [[Club Mario]] segment; the suggestion that this alone is enough to support the entire article is asinine). This is even more clear-cut than the deletion of [[Talk:Giraffe#Delete_this_page|Giraffe]], since at ''least'' there were generic giraffes to cover. If you need to know about every parrot of note in the franchise, [[:Category:Parrots]] already exists in a perfectly usable form. At best, this article only exists to pad out the species parameter of pages, and that's not good enough to keep it.


12,681

edits