Talk:Cape Feather

Line 1:

Why is the feather from Super Mario RPG on here? It doesn't provide a cape at all. Either it should be removed from the article or the whole article should be moved simply to "Feather". ~ [[User:Joshi|Joshi]] 04:40, 24 April 2009 (EDT)

== "Wing Feather" ==

Why is the Feather that turns Mario in [[Wing Mario]] in SM64DS merged to Cape Feather? I know they're both feathers, but they look different and turn Mario into something else. Although both Power-Ups (Cape Mario and Wing Mario) make Mario fly, they have different attributes (Cape Mario: The cape on Mario's neck, Wing Mario: the wings on his cap), and the method of flying is different as well (Cape Mario: First a Jump, then up & down simulative (if I'm correct), Wing Mario: Triple Jump, then steer (Up = Dive, Down = raise) (again, if I'm correct)). I don't think I'll start a proposal yet, but I think to do either these things with this "Wing Feather":

*Split it from Cape Feather, and merge it to [[Wing Cap]] (as they got pretty much the same effect)

*Split it from Cape Feather, and make a new article for it

I'd choose the second option myself, but I think you all would choose the first option instead. But if we make a new article, there are two more options:

*Call the new article "Feather (Super Mario 64 DS)"

*Call it "Wing Feather" instead

I would choose the second option (again), but I think that would be a conjectural name, so I think the first one's more official. But I might be wrong.<br/>

Tell me what you think about it. {{User:Arend/Sig}}

Talk:Cape Feather: Difference between revisions

Navigation menu

Page actions

Page actions

Personal tools

Browse

Search

Navigation

Community

Tools

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 Why is the feather from Super Mario RPG on here?  It doesn't provide a cape at all.  Either it should be removed from the article or the whole article should be moved simply to "Feather". ~ [[User:Joshi|Joshi]] 04:40, 24 April 2009 (EDT)
+== "Wing Feather" ==
+{{talk}}
+Why is the Feather that turns Mario in [[Wing Mario]] in SM64DS merged to Cape Feather? I know they're both feathers, but they look different and turn Mario into something else. Although both Power-Ups (Cape Mario and Wing Mario) make Mario fly, they have different attributes (Cape Mario: The cape on Mario's neck, Wing Mario: the wings on his cap), and the method of flying is different as well (Cape Mario: First a Jump, then up & down simulative (if I'm correct), Wing Mario: Triple Jump, then steer (Up = Dive, Down = raise) (again, if I'm correct)). I don't think I'll start a proposal yet, but I think to do either these things with this "Wing Feather":
+*Split it from Cape Feather, and merge it to [[Wing Cap]] (as they got pretty much the same effect)
+*Split it from Cape Feather, and make a new article for it
+I'd choose the second option myself, but I think you all would choose the first option instead. But if we make a new article, there are two more options:
+*Call the new article "Feather (Super Mario 64 DS)"
+*Call it "Wing Feather" instead
+I would choose the second option (again), but I think that would be a conjectural name, so I think the first one's more official. But I might be wrong.<br/>
+Tell me what you think about it. {{User:Arend/Sig}}