Talk:Poison Mushroom

Line 46:

===Oppose===

#{{User|Spectrogram}} These are two very different "power-ups" that function differently, have a different appearance, and a different in-game name.

#{{User|Swallow}} Per Spectogram, we don't merge distinct subjects just because they're similar, only if there is evidence that they're supposed to be the same~~. Also, the point about the worst obstacle award appears to mean the worst obstacle in the game itself, not a wiki article~~.

#{{User|Swallow}} Per Spectogram, we don't merge distinct subjects just because they're similar, only if there is evidence that they're supposed to be the same.

===Comments===

First of all, if the two had to be merged, I feel like we should merge Rotten Mushroom to Poison Mushroom instead of the other way around: the Poison Mushroom appears way more often than the Rotten Mushroom.<br>Even then, items looking and acting similar while sharing an internal filename is not exactly enough to deem the two as one and the same, I feel. We still have [[Coin Coffer]] and [[Magmaargh]] separate from [[Moneybags]] and [[Blargg]], respectively, for instance. {{User:Arend/sig}} 03:39, June 13, 2023 (EDT)

Talk:Poison Mushroom: Difference between revisions

Navigation menu

Page actions

Page actions

Personal tools

Browse

Search

Navigation

Community

Tools

@@ Line 46: / Line 46: @@
 ===Oppose===
 #{{User|Spectrogram}} These are two very different "power-ups" that function differently, have a different appearance, and a different in-game name.
-#{{User|Swallow}} Per Spectogram, we don't merge distinct subjects just because they're similar, only if there is evidence that they're supposed to be the same. Also, the point about the worst obstacle award appears to mean the worst obstacle in the game itself, not a wiki article.
+#{{User|Swallow}} Per Spectogram, we don't merge distinct subjects just because they're similar, only if there is evidence that they're supposed to be the same.
 ===Comments===
 First of all, if the two had to be merged, I feel like we should merge Rotten Mushroom to Poison Mushroom instead of the other way around: the Poison Mushroom appears way more often than the Rotten Mushroom.<br>Even then, items looking and acting similar while sharing an internal filename is not exactly enough to deem the two as one and the same, I feel. We still have [[Coin Coffer]] and [[Magmaargh]] separate from [[Moneybags]] and [[Blargg]], respectively, for instance. {{User:Arend/sig}} 03:39, June 13, 2023 (EDT)