MarioWiki:Proposals

Line 163:

#{{User|7feetunder}} Second choice.

#{{user|TheDarkStar}} - second choice

#{{User|Results May Vary}} - I have been eyeing this proposal for a couple of days now, wondering how I should word my statement. Originally I saw ''Super Smash Bros.'' as a ''Mario'' franchise spinoff, but someone talked me out of it otherwise. However, there's so much ''Super Smash Bros.'' content on this wiki that has already been written that it would be a shame if it all want to waste. It would be overkill if the trophy, spirit, and sticker lists were all removed (especially to emphasize ''Mario'' being the flagship of the franchise), although Subspace Army and Smash Run is more understandable. I've been hard at work on a solution for those who are unsatisfied about the content being removed from this wiki.

====Support (excluding any spirits, assists, etc of subjects we already have individual pages for, such as Knuckles, fighters, and Blinky)====

Line 176:

Line 175:

#{{User|TheFlameChomp}} Initially, I supported this proposal. However, after considering it more, I have decided that I agree with some of the points brought up by Waluigi Time, MrConcreteDonkey, and Tails777. I do personally still believe that the lists of trophies, stickers, and spirits should definitely be cut down, as there is no reason for them to be among the longest articles on the wiki. However, I agree that Assist Trophies and the Subspace and Smash Run enemies have a much more significant role, and thus I do not feel it makes sense to group them in with the lists of collectibles, since it would be inconsistent with how we currently cover other items that have a larger impact on gameplay. I fully agree with the idea of possibly limiting ''Super Smash Bros.'' content, but I feel this proposal currently combines subjects that do not have a completely similar impact on gameplay.

MarioWiki:Proposals: Difference between revisions

Navigation menu

Page actions

Page actions

Personal tools

Browse

Search

Navigation

Community

Tools

@@ Line 163: / Line 163: @@
 #{{User|7feetunder}} Second choice.
 #{{user|TheDarkStar}} - second choice
-#{{User|Results May Vary}} - I have been eyeing this proposal for a couple of days now, wondering how I should word my statement. Originally I saw ''Super Smash Bros.'' as a ''Mario'' franchise spinoff, but someone talked me out of it otherwise. However, there's so much ''Super Smash Bros.'' content on this wiki that has already been written that it would be a shame if it all want to  waste. It would be overkill if the trophy, spirit, and sticker lists were all removed (especially to emphasize ''Mario'' being the flagship of the franchise), although Subspace Army and Smash Run is more understandable. I've been hard at work on a solution for those who are unsatisfied about the content being removed from this wiki.
 ====Support (excluding any spirits, assists, etc of subjects we already have individual pages for, such as Knuckles, fighters, and Blinky)====
@@ Line 176: / Line 175: @@
 #{{User|TheFlameChomp}} Initially, I supported this proposal. However, after considering it more, I have decided that I agree with some of the points brought up by Waluigi Time, MrConcreteDonkey, and Tails777. I do personally still believe that the lists of trophies, stickers, and spirits should definitely be cut down, as there is no reason for them to be among the longest articles on the wiki. However, I agree that Assist Trophies and the Subspace and Smash Run enemies have a much more significant role, and thus I do not feel it makes sense to group them in with the lists of collectibles, since it would be inconsistent with how we currently cover other items that have a larger impact on gameplay. I fully agree with the idea of possibly limiting ''Super Smash Bros.'' content, but I feel this proposal currently combines subjects that do not have a completely similar impact on gameplay.
 #{{User|Niiue}} Per all. I've never been a fan of reducing SSB coverage anyway.
+#{{User|Results May Vary}} Too much will be removed in the process.
 ====Comments====