Editing User talk:Big Super Mario Fan
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
| Latest revision | Your text | ||
| Line 91: | Line 91: | ||
:#Yeah uh, the [https://www.nintendo.com/jp/character/mario/en/history/index.html Mario Portal's History page] that you've provided? That doesn't only list mainline Mario Party titles, or only Mario Party titles: it actually lists ''every game in the Super Mario franchise, without any sort of distinction''. Using THAT as your source of ''every'' Mario Party title being a mainline Mario Party title is downright ridiculous, because, as I just said, it doesn't make any sort of distinction between any of these titles. Nowhere does it say which ones are mainlines, spinoffs or rereleases to which series, or which ones belong to which subseries to begin with. You might as well say that ''[[Super Mario Strikers]]'' is a mainline ''[[Super Mario (series)|Super Mario]]'' title just because "Super Mario" is in the title, AND is listed here as well. It's very faulty logic. I've already stated [[Talk:Super Mario (series)#Main series|here]] that using the Mario Portal as a source for what counts as a mainline ''Super Mario'' title doesn't say anything ''because'' it just haplessly lists every Mario title without making distinctions, and the same applies to what counts as mainline ''Mario Party'' games. | :#Yeah uh, the [https://www.nintendo.com/jp/character/mario/en/history/index.html Mario Portal's History page] that you've provided? That doesn't only list mainline Mario Party titles, or only Mario Party titles: it actually lists ''every game in the Super Mario franchise, without any sort of distinction''. Using THAT as your source of ''every'' Mario Party title being a mainline Mario Party title is downright ridiculous, because, as I just said, it doesn't make any sort of distinction between any of these titles. Nowhere does it say which ones are mainlines, spinoffs or rereleases to which series, or which ones belong to which subseries to begin with. You might as well say that ''[[Super Mario Strikers]]'' is a mainline ''[[Super Mario (series)|Super Mario]]'' title just because "Super Mario" is in the title, AND is listed here as well. It's very faulty logic. I've already stated [[Talk:Super Mario (series)#Main series|here]] that using the Mario Portal as a source for what counts as a mainline ''Super Mario'' title doesn't say anything ''because'' it just haplessly lists every Mario title without making distinctions, and the same applies to what counts as mainline ''Mario Party'' games. | ||
:If you wanted to ''actually'' list ''Mario Party'' games like Nintendo does... again, they do that in ''[[Mario Party: The Top 100]]'' and ''[[Mario Party Superstars]]''. Also, just so you know, basically the reason we have divided Mario Party titles by home console game and handheld game is because we're unsure where games such as ''[[Super Mario Party]]'' and ''Mario Party Superstars'' fall into, given they're still home console releases that play like the classic Mario Party games from 1 to 8, but aren't numbered. {{User:Arend/sig}} 18:35, May 18, 2024 (EDT) | :If you wanted to ''actually'' list ''Mario Party'' games like Nintendo does... again, they do that in ''[[Mario Party: The Top 100]]'' and ''[[Mario Party Superstars]]''. Also, just so you know, basically the reason we have divided Mario Party titles by home console game and handheld game is because we're unsure where games such as ''[[Super Mario Party]]'' and ''Mario Party Superstars'' fall into, given they're still home console releases that play like the classic Mario Party games from 1 to 8, but aren't numbered. {{User:Arend/sig}} 18:35, May 18, 2024 (EDT) | ||
== Asking others users to vote in your proposals == | == Asking others users to vote in your proposals == | ||
