MarioWiki:Appeals: Difference between revisions

From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
m (Undo revision 1815775 by 70.113.13.176 (talk) That's an IP, and not Stonehill's account, that's making the edit.)
(→‎Stonehill: Sorry, I accidentally used an IP.)
Line 33: Line 33:
*[[User talk:Stonehill#Reminder]]
*[[User talk:Stonehill#Reminder]]
====Stonehill====
====Stonehill====
*Even though I would do the same without the Reminder, this user never actually said that he (or she) was planning on creating the ''Mario Party 10'' minigames - '''''at all''''' prior to the reminder, so, what could I do?
*Even though I would do the same without the Reminder, and I would understand myself, you never made it as clear as possible. In order to prevent edit sniping in the first place, you absolutely '''''NEED''''' to state what you're planning '''as "loud and clear" as possible'''! Plus, planning something and then abandoning it for 5 days doesn't necessarily count as edit sniping.
 
====Viper26====
====Viper26====
*I posted that I was creating the ''[[Mario Party 10]]'' minigames back in January or so on my userpage. So what you did is edit sniping, a form of discourteous behavior, which is also a [[MarioWiki:Warning Policy#Level Two Offenses|level two offense]].
*I posted that I was creating the ''[[Mario Party 10]]'' minigames back in January or so on my userpage. So what you did is edit sniping, a form of discourteous behavior, which is also a [[MarioWiki:Warning Policy#Level Two Offenses|level two offense]].

Revision as of 18:45, March 27, 2015

This page is an appeal system for Reminders, Warnings, and Last Warnings. If you feel you have wrongly received a reminder or a warning, follow the instructions below to appeal the reminder/warning to the administrators. Please keep discussions civil.

Archived Appeals can be found here.

This page observes the No-Signature Policy.

Notes

If you feel that you have been wrongfully given a reminder and/or warning, you can have your case heard here. Please read through the "How To" and the "Rules" carefully. Please note that both the users appealing the reminder/warning and the users who issued the reminder/warning are given a chance to present the administrators with reasons to rule in their favor. However, said comments can only be edited once; this will not expand into lengthy, back-and-forth arguments such as the ones found in proposal comments and talk page discussions.

Rules

  1. Reminders and/or Warnings given by an administrator cannot be appealed.
  2. No case can be heard more than once. Once a decision is made, that decision is final.
  3. If the reminder or warning you issued is overturned, do not re-add it, or it will be removed immediately, and you may be reprimanded yourself if the administrators feel it is necessary.

How-to

This is an example of what your appeal should look like; improperly formatted appeals will be deleted. If you are inexperienced or unsure how to set up this format, simply copy the following template and paste it into the fitting section. Then replace the "[subject]" variables (including the squared brackets) with information to customize your proposal.

===[Your username here]===
*[Insert link to reminder/warning from your talk page]
====[Your username here]====
*[Insert your comments on why the reminder/warning was unnecessary]
====[The issuer of the warning's Username here]====
*[Insert your comments on why the reminder/warning was necessary (this section is for the issuer only)]
----

Important: After posting your appeal, make sure that you use {{AppealNotice}} to inform the issuer that his or her warning/reminder is under dispute.

Cases

Stonehill

Stonehill

  • Even though I would do the same without the Reminder, and I would understand myself, you never made it as clear as possible. In order to prevent edit sniping in the first place, you absolutely NEED to state what you're planning as "loud and clear" as possible! Plus, planning something and then abandoning it for 5 days doesn't necessarily count as edit sniping.

Viper26

  • I posted that I was creating the Mario Party 10 minigames back in January or so on my userpage. So what you did is edit sniping, a form of discourteous behavior, which is also a level two offense.