Two characters walk through some woods. The camera moves up showing the night and a big dark cloud. The dark cloud slowly moves away, revealing a full moon. The camera goes back to the ground and out of nowhere two Mr. Is appear. Both characters gasp and the minigame starts.
The player must move the Wii Remote in circles around a Mr. I's head about three or more times, until that Mr. I is defeated (à la Eye Sore). Precise movements are encouraged, not just frantically moving the Remote around. However in that Mr. I's place, another Mr. I (now slightly bigger) will appear. The player must then again move the Wii Remote in circles around the Mr. I.
Then after that Mr. I is defeated, a big Mr. I will appear and the player must then move the Wii Remote in circles around the Mr. I. It will then be defeated. The character that beats one of the big Mr. Is first will then be the winner of the game.
After a character defeats the Mr. I, he or she will do his or her winning pose. However, tiny Mr. I's will then appear out of nowhere, just like how the first Mr. I's appeared. The winner will then scream and start running, and run off the screen. The loser will be too shocked to move, and the Mini Mr. I's surround him or her while the big Mr. I just looks at the loser. The loser will be left crying and screaming (trying to avoid the Mini Mr. I's), and then the screen fades.
 In-game text