44,417
edits
Talk:Mario Party: Star Rush: Difference between revisions
→The separate modes do not get their own articles.: new section
(→The separate modes do not get their own articles.: new section) |
|||
| Line 107: | Line 107: | ||
:::Ninja'd by Zooks: Yeah but I still think it's a minor thing to be accomplished. By the way, I don't think there's a level above Super Star Rush, I've gotten as much as 20 stars and still haven't gotten it. Maps may have different Star Rush requirements but I feel that belongs on each respective map article. I really think an article on Star Rush is almost as valid as, say, Superstar or getting articles on Stars in the Mario Kart games. {{User:Baby Luigi/sig}} 20:53, 28 November 2016 (EST) | :::Ninja'd by Zooks: Yeah but I still think it's a minor thing to be accomplished. By the way, I don't think there's a level above Super Star Rush, I've gotten as much as 20 stars and still haven't gotten it. Maps may have different Star Rush requirements but I feel that belongs on each respective map article. I really think an article on Star Rush is almost as valid as, say, Superstar or getting articles on Stars in the Mario Kart games. {{User:Baby Luigi/sig}} 20:53, 28 November 2016 (EST) | ||
::::It would only work for Toad Scramble. For Balloon Bash, I think it would be best to put it on that article instead of the three boards of that mode. We should wait for more users filling in on this before we start putting it on the articles. I am also quite busy for the next two weeks approximately. {{User:Yoshi the Space Station Manager/sig}} 21:04, 28 November 2016 (EST) | ::::It would only work for Toad Scramble. For Balloon Bash, I think it would be best to put it on that article instead of the three boards of that mode. We should wait for more users filling in on this before we start putting it on the articles. I am also quite busy for the next two weeks approximately. {{User:Yoshi the Space Station Manager/sig}} 21:04, 28 November 2016 (EST) | ||
== The separate modes do not get their own articles. == | |||
Ok (directed primarily at {{user|3D Player 2010}}) , so I keep reverting edits because some people (cough3DPlayer2010coughcough)think Toad Scramble, Coinathlon, Boo's Block Bash, etc. deserve to get their own articles. I firmly don't, and I'll explain why. First of all, your comparisons are very weak. [[Lab Brats]] for starters ''is'' a selectable minigame in the minigame mode alongside the other rare minigames like [[Seer Terror]], [[Dunk Bros.]], so that's the reason it gets its own article. [[Super Duel Mode]] is far more in-depth and plays a lot differently than any mode of this game, and the only reason it got an article compared to Coinathlon because it has its own set of unlockables, maps, stats, and well, tons of separate content in this mode that can easily make it into a designated article without bloating the page up. Here, Boo's Block Party is a simple side mode in a similar vein to the side minigame games like Treetop Bingo, Battle Bridge, etc and it doesn't have enough content in it to justify its own article without being redundant or information that can be easily stated in this article. For [[Beach Volley Folley]], it's in a similar situation as Super Duel Mode, but it has appeared in more than one game as well as being classified as a minigame rather than its own mode like Coinathlon. All modes easily fit in this article: Toad Scramble is the main meat of the game and the article should cover it without splitting things up. Coinathlon isn't a hard-to-understand mode with tons and tons of its own content, its analogous to Balloon Battle from the Mario Kart games. Balloon Bash plays very similarly to Toad Scramble except there's a different goal and some slightly different mechanics here and there. Rhythm Recital is in the same situation as Coinathlon, it doesn't have enough separate content in there to justify its own article, just like the minigame side modes in Minigame Modes in earlier Mario Parties. Challenge Tower can fit in this article too, everything that is needed to be said about Challenge Tower, this article covers. Hell, the rest of the modes are like that: everything that needs to be said can be said in the Gameplay section of this article and it doesn't look too overly bloated. The only mode that got its own article was the [[Character Museum]], and for good reasons too, because it's a collectible list thing of the game like the Star Bank or something like that. | |||
Finally, if you really think they deserve their own articles, put more effort in linking the modes in the first place in this article instead of lazily tying all links to the single level-up table. Doing that gives me the impression that you haven't thought this through enough. {{User:Baby Luigi/sig}} 21:44, 3 December 2016 (EST) | |||