381,838
edits
MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive/7: Difference between revisions
m
Text replacement - "Proposals\/Archive[ _]" to "Proposals/Archive/"
m (PorpleBot moved page MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive 7 to MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive/7: Text replacement - "Proposals/Archive " to "Proposals/Archive/") |
m (Text replacement - "Proposals\/Archive[ _]" to "Proposals/Archive/") |
||
| Line 336: | Line 336: | ||
Yeah, it would have to be a case-by-case basis for this sort of thing. If anyone's unsure about the quality of an article they can always ask. I also think we should also do something about one-sentence stubs, but that's another issue at the moment. -- [[User:Booster|Booster]] | Yeah, it would have to be a case-by-case basis for this sort of thing. If anyone's unsure about the quality of an article they can always ask. I also think we should also do something about one-sentence stubs, but that's another issue at the moment. -- [[User:Booster|Booster]] | ||
:I think there's already an (unwritten) rules for deleting one-liner. Heck, I think there was even a proposal about it. - {{User|Blitzwing}} | :I think there's already an (unwritten) rules for deleting one-liner. Heck, I think there was even a proposal about it. - {{User|Blitzwing}} | ||
::I remember something like this as well, but the only thing I could find in the archives is [[MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive 2#Deleting stubs|this one]] - not about deleting one-liners, but ''against the deletion of new stub articles''. {{User|Time Q}} 16:27, 4 April 2008 (EDT) | ::I remember something like this as well, but the only thing I could find in the archives is [[MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive/2#Deleting stubs|this one]] - not about deleting one-liners, but ''against the deletion of new stub articles''. {{User|Time Q}} 16:27, 4 April 2008 (EDT) | ||
Hey, Plumber! I appreciate the support! Cobold: while I'm on the topic he was discussing how it was a long time ago... go check out the history. It was long, but poorly written. Of course, now that the proposer's specified that he only meant short articles I'm not sure if it's a good example, but whatever. Instead of having this generic proposal, I'd rather the proposer come forth with a list of pages he's talking about, and then we can take care of the stinkers one by one. (seriously, who wouldn't vote yes to, "Fix Something Bad" proposals? Only people who don't like the vagueness...) {{User|Stumpers}} 17:13, 4 April 2008 (EDT) | Hey, Plumber! I appreciate the support! Cobold: while I'm on the topic he was discussing how it was a long time ago... go check out the history. It was long, but poorly written. Of course, now that the proposer's specified that he only meant short articles I'm not sure if it's a good example, but whatever. Instead of having this generic proposal, I'd rather the proposer come forth with a list of pages he's talking about, and then we can take care of the stinkers one by one. (seriously, who wouldn't vote yes to, "Fix Something Bad" proposals? Only people who don't like the vagueness...) {{User|Stumpers}} 17:13, 4 April 2008 (EDT) | ||
| Line 646: | Line 646: | ||
Hey-hey, come on! | Hey-hey, come on! | ||
Ok users, pay attention, and read carefully. | Ok users, pay attention, and read carefully. | ||
As some of you may know, there was a [[MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive 4#Quotes.3F|proposal]] that said, "Lately i've been searching around the wikis quotes, and have seen quotes like "whupee heeheeheehee!" when thats just a bunch of giberious and also something like AHHH!!! thats just someone yelling! should we get rid of these?". Now, the problem some users (including me, of course) have encountered is what to actually consider a "gibberish" quote. Now look at the quotes that have been recently removed from the [[Baby Daisy]] article: | As some of you may know, there was a [[MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive/4#Quotes.3F|proposal]] that said, "Lately i've been searching around the wikis quotes, and have seen quotes like "whupee heeheeheehee!" when thats just a bunch of giberious and also something like AHHH!!! thats just someone yelling! should we get rid of these?". Now, the problem some users (including me, of course) have encountered is what to actually consider a "gibberish" quote. Now look at the quotes that have been recently removed from the [[Baby Daisy]] article: | ||
*''"Baby Daisy!"'' – ''[[Mario Kart Wii]] | *''"Baby Daisy!"'' – ''[[Mario Kart Wii]] | ||
*''"Ha-ha! YAY!"'' – ''Mario Kart Wii | *''"Ha-ha! YAY!"'' – ''Mario Kart Wii | ||