41,706
edits
MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/Bowser: Difference between revisions
m
Porplemontage moved page MarioWiki:Featured Articles/N1/Bowser to MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/Bowser: Fix
m (You don't add a reason for a support vote) |
m (Porplemontage moved page MarioWiki:Featured Articles/N1/Bowser to MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/Bowser: Fix) |
||
| (36 intermediate revisions by 23 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
__NOTOC__ | __NOTOC__ | ||
===[[{{#titleparts:{{PAGENAME}}||3}}]]=== | ===[[{{#titleparts:{{PAGENAME}}||3}}]]=== | ||
{{ | {{FANOMFAIL | ||
|nominated=3:00, 23, | |nominated=3:00, May 23, 2011 (GMT) | ||
| | |lastedit=10:44, April 29, 2012 | ||
}} | |nosupport=false}} | ||
==== Support ==== | ==== Support ==== | ||
#{{User|Catboy41}} Now, I'm new, so maybe I'm not reading the rules correctly, But I am pretty sure I did, so with that in mind, I think that this article Is AWESOME. I was actually suprised It wasn't featured when I joined. I didn't spot any bad templates, and I believe It should be featured. It's written in correct verb tense, as far as I know. It has a lot of info, and I believe It is indeed, one of the best. | #{{User|Catboy41}} Now, I'm new, so maybe I'm not reading the rules correctly, But I am pretty sure I did, so with that in mind, I think that this article Is AWESOME. I was actually suprised It wasn't featured when I joined. I didn't spot any bad templates, and I believe It should be featured. It's written in correct verb tense, as far as I know. It has a lot of info, and I believe It is indeed, one of the best. | ||
| Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
#{{User|MysteryGirl2012}} | #{{User|MysteryGirl2012}} | ||
#{{User|SuperPickle}} | #{{User|SuperPickle}} | ||
#{{User|Yoshi10}} | #{{User|Yoshi10}} | ||
#{{User| | #{{User|Toadshroom}} | ||
# | #{{User|New Super Yoshi}} | ||
#{{User|Toa 95}} | |||
#{{User|Bjdill}} | |||
#{{User|Big Koopa}} | |||
#{{User|Mrcrackerpants}} | |||
#{{User|Jose17796}} | |||
#{{User|Caf772000}} | |||
#{{User|Cortez}} | |||
#{{User|The legend of zelda rocks}} | |||
#{{User|Smb1}} | |||
==== Oppose ==== | ==== Oppose ==== | ||
| Line 44: | Line 53: | ||
#{{User|Greentoad}} Per all. It as a LOT of work to be done. | #{{User|Greentoad}} Per all. It as a LOT of work to be done. | ||
#{{User|Bobosmith01}} There is many mistakes. Als many wrong verbs and there tenses. If it has one of thse bars...... why should it even be thought of nomination? | #{{User|Bobosmith01}} There is many mistakes. Als many wrong verbs and there tenses. If it has one of thse bars...... why should it even be thought of nomination? | ||
#{{User|KS3}} Is is just me, or do I see two rewrite templates at the top of the page? The Mario Party section also needs expansion. | #{{User|KS3}} Is is just me, or do I see two rewrite templates at the top of the page? The Mario Party section also needs expansion. | ||
#{{User|Commander Code-8}} | #{{User|Commander Code-8}} The way this article orders his biography is rubbish. It's got the main series first, which is right, then it's got all of the cartoon tv series and movies before the major spinoff series'. | ||
#{{User|Spidey665}} '''Strongest Possible Oppose'''. There are wrong verbs and typos on this page, maybe if we'd all get to work on it, it'd help. | #{{User|Spidey665}} '''Strongest Possible Oppose'''. There are wrong verbs and typos on this page, maybe if we'd all get to work on it, it'd help. | ||
#{{User|Enriquevv75}} Per all | #{{User|Enriquevv75}} Per all | ||
#{{User|SuperYoshiBros}} Per DKPetey99 and Goomba's Shoe 15 | #{{User|SuperYoshiBros}} Per DKPetey99 and Goomba's Shoe 15 | ||
#{{User|Propeller Toad}} I'm afraid I'm going to have go with a no here. Aside from the templates and missing sections, Bowser's article also lacks images from most of his appearances (aside from the mainstream Super Mario games). It is crucial to include images in the sections with large amounts of information in order to illustrate Bowser's appearances in these games and media appearances, and by adding this to the fact of the other flaws in this article, I personally do not think Bowser's article is ready to be featured just yet. Essentially per all. | #{{User|Propeller Toad}} I'm afraid I'm going to have go with a no here. Aside from the templates and missing sections, Bowser's article also lacks images from most of his appearances (aside from the mainstream Super Mario games). It is crucial to include images in the sections with large amounts of information in order to illustrate Bowser's appearances in these games and media appearances, and by adding this to the fact of the other flaws in this article, I personally do not think Bowser's article is ready to be featured just yet. Essentially per all. | ||
#{{User|YoshiKong}} This is quite a long article, but '''quality, not quantity'''. | |||
#{{User|Super Famicom 64}} …per all… How in the world a guy can nominate an article with so much less information… and with '''{{tem|rewrite-expand}}'''?! | |||
#{{User|Kamek126}} I oppose because it's missing data about some of the games and i'm afraid it lacks many images of him from older titles. | |||
#Since Bowser IS the main villain of the Mario series most people would already have seen him I think the spot should go to a lesser know char. so we can keep fans interested in new articles.[[User:The real yoshi]] | |||
==== Removal of Opposes ==== | ==== Removal of Opposes ==== | ||
=====All Opposes===== | |||
#{{User|New Super Yoshi}} Look how much the article has changed. All of your opposes are now outdated. | |||
#{{User|Toa 95}} - Most, if not all arguments on the above comments are invalid at this point. Rewrite templates are gone, every game appearance has been noted, sufficient information has been added to each section, all game appearances have been added, verb tense has been corrected, images have been added, etc. | |||
==== Comments ==== | ==== Comments ==== | ||
| Line 65: | Line 79: | ||
@DKPetey99... Bowser IS in Hoops 3-on-3! Next time read the whole article before you bother to oppose it! {{User|MysteryGirl2012}} | @DKPetey99... Bowser IS in Hoops 3-on-3! Next time read the whole article before you bother to oppose it! {{User|MysteryGirl2012}} | ||
:Err... She meant to get a ''point'' across? {{User|Lost Mini Star09}} | |||
:He meant that one needs to be added. :B [[User:Lord Grammaticus|Lord Grammaticus]] 15:16, 15 February 2012 (EST) | :He meant that one needs to be added. :B [[User:Lord Grammaticus|Lord Grammaticus]] 15:16, 15 February 2012 (EST) | ||
Even the Mario page has construction going on. {{User | :I meant to get a ''point'' across, Lost Mini Star09! [[User:MysteryGirl2012|MysteryGirl2012]] | ||
Even the Mario page has construction going on. {{User|Spidey665}} 17:49, 9 January 2012 (EST) | |||
Do we really need another section for ports or remakes? Unless there are major changes in the remakes, it doesn't need to be here.--[[User:Toadshroom|Toadshroom]] 22:47, 18 February 2012 (EST) | |||
@Toa 95 It's still missing information {{unsigned|Raven Effect}} | |||
: | |||
While the section on Mario Roulette can't be expanded much more, I would like to see some more detail. Where did Bowser appear? It's not a mandatory thing, but I would like to see the section on Super Mario-Kun expanded with added detail as well. Some sections can be rewritten to a more neutral tone instead of a storybook type. The tense aslo has to be consistent, as I see the future tense in areas such as Yoshi's Universal Gravitation. The image in the Super Mario Galaxy section needs to be refitted in the section. The Super Mario Bros. film section shouldn't be there. Some more images can be used in the Nintendo Comics system section. Mario's Early Years section can be more detailed. The images in the Super Smash Bros. section can be refitted as well. Finally, some of the grammar can be touched up. {{User|LeftyGreenMario}} | |||
Also, I seem to have trouble reading through this page in one sitting. I really appreciate the massive amount of information, but it seems kind of overwhelming. I don't know if personal issues should be taken into account. I'm not trying to discourage adding information, by the way. I just want to point this out. {{User|LeftyGreenMario}} | |||
:Well, Bowser is a major character who appeared in many games. It's impossible to shorten the article any further other than removing unnecessary fluff. {{User|BabyLuigiOnFire}} | |||
So, any other noteworthy problems? - [[User:Toa 95|Toa 95]] | |||