MarioWiki:Proposals: Difference between revisions

MarioWiki:Proposals (view source)

Revision as of 14:36, August 24, 2008

2,984 bytes added , 15 years ago

→‎Keep ''Rosalina''

The.Real.Izkat

33

edits

@@ Line 175: / Line 175: @@
 ====Keep ''Rosalina''====
+#{{User|Master Lucario}} Wearing a crown means nothing. I get a crown in my Burger King Kid's Meal. Am I a king? No. She's not royalty of any sort. I oppose this proposal.
+#{{User|Garlic Man}} -- Whoa, whoa, wait up, here. Just because it says she IS a princess, the game never calls her by the title "Princess Rosalina". It calls her Rosalina. You know how Bowser is not [[King Bowser]]? Yeah, because he's Bowser. Nowhere is Rosalina ever fully called "Princess Rosalina". I oppose. (obviously)
+#{{User|YellowYoshi398}} - Per Garlic. Plus, even if we did discover an official mention of "Princess Rosalina," just plain Rosalina would outweigh it because it is used more often.
+#{{User|Time Q}}: Per Garlic Man. Just because she ''is'' something doesn't mean the article should be called that.
+#{{User|Booster}} -- Per Garlic Man.
+#{{User|Palkia47}} - Per Garlic and AgentCH (below). If its not seen in the game or manual, then it probably had to be from a guide. We don't exactly allow information from guides (ie. seen in the MKWii Guide as Peach and Daisy are cousins).
+#{{User|Stooben Rooben}} - Per Garlic Man. There are no citations anywhere on that page to prove that she is '''in fact''' a princess. If Nintendo has given no proof, then it is clearly speculation.
+#{{user|LinkTheLefty}} - It's probably a translation error. If anyone remembers the travesty that is Sonic 2006, Blaze was called a Queen in that game's profile, yet she's supposed to be a princess. It could be a one-time thing. That, and the fact that Rosalina was a princess in concept development before ties with Peach were broken off. I think we should, however, mention it in the article... Provided it's from a tangible source (second or third party sources shouldn't make a difference).
+#{{User|Walkazo}} - Per all.
+#{{user|Moonshine}} - Per all. Another example being Mario. We all know he's a plumber, but we don't call him "Mario the Plumber" in the title.
+#{{user|InfectedShroom}} - Per all. "Princess" is not her official title.
+#{{user|MC Hammer Bro.}}- per all and see comment.
+#{{User|Pikax}} - Per Garlic. We don't call [[Baby Daisy]] and [[Baby Peach]] "Baby Princess Daisy" and "Baby Princess Peach" because they're not given such titles in the games they appear in.
+#{{User|Bob-omb buddy}}Per all. princess dosen't have to mean royalty. It can be discription, not a title.
+#{{User|Dom}} Per all, including Master Lucario's LOL comment, and in particular Garlic Man's comment.
+#{{user|AgentCH}} - Per Garlic and my own reason below.
+#{{user|Yoshikart}}- I have no proof.
+#{{User|Myles}} - Per Garlic Man and Pikax. I'd also like to add that we don't call Mario: Mario Mario, or Luigi: Luigi Mario. We call them what they are usually called. It should however be noted that she is a princess.
+#{{user|Super Fuelbot}} - Per Garlic Man.
+#{{user|Cobold}} - no source given. Check my comment below.
+#{{user|1337Yoshi}} - Per all.
+#{{user|Super-Yoshi}} - Per All.
+#{{user|Clay Mario}} - Per Garlic
 ====Comments====