MarioWiki:Featured articles/Unfeature/N1/Super Mario 3D World: Difference between revisions

Line 19: Line 19:
#{{User|Baby Luigi}} Yes there is much to say in the intro. Take a look at how several others article in the wiki do it, especially at how some recently featured articles do it. ''[[Mario Party: The Top 100]]'', ''[[Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze]]'', ''[[Mario Sports Superstars]]'', and the current ''[[Mario Kart 8]]''. All of them have lengthy, adequate intros that do a good job explaining the game. In this case, how is two sentences enough to introduce readers to freaking Super Mario 3D World? If Mario Party: The Top 100 out of all games can have a decent enough intro, why does this article do only the bare minimum? Hell, did you even read my oppose? [https://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=38897.0 I'll link to you this thread again, which this article is one of the centerpiece examples of bad intros]. And you can't keep featured article status until '''after''' you wrote the changes, not before you actually make them. Results are far more important than things you'll say you do: by this logic, we should feature ''[[Mario Party: Island Tour]]'' because I am working on that article, despite its incomplete state.
#{{User|Baby Luigi}} Yes there is much to say in the intro. Take a look at how several others article in the wiki do it, especially at how some recently featured articles do it. ''[[Mario Party: The Top 100]]'', ''[[Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze]]'', ''[[Mario Sports Superstars]]'', and the current ''[[Mario Kart 8]]''. All of them have lengthy, adequate intros that do a good job explaining the game. In this case, how is two sentences enough to introduce readers to freaking Super Mario 3D World? If Mario Party: The Top 100 out of all games can have a decent enough intro, why does this article do only the bare minimum? Hell, did you even read my oppose? [https://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=38897.0 I'll link to you this thread again, which this article is one of the centerpiece examples of bad intros]. And you can't keep featured article status until '''after''' you wrote the changes, not before you actually make them. Results are far more important than things you'll say you do: by this logic, we should feature ''[[Mario Party: Island Tour]]'' because I am working on that article, despite its incomplete state.
#{{User|TheFlameChomp}} Per Baby Luigi.
#{{User|TheFlameChomp}} Per Baby Luigi.
#{{User|Time Turner}} Per all. It doesn't matter what you think you can do in the future, as it stands now, the article's not good.


==== Comments ====
==== Comments ====
48,332

edits