3,267
edits
Boo Diddly (talk | contribs) m (→Oppose) |
|||
Line 54: | Line 54: | ||
#{{User|Walkazo}} - I think this would be going too far. The rules are changing a bit now that DLC means Nintendo doesn't have to be so choosy about who they include: we'll probably see more and more alt forms of characters in spinoffs now, and it's going to get silly if they all get pages. I feel like moving forward, if duplicates of characters appear in sport/kart games, that alone shouldn't be enough to split them, like how we don't give every ''SSB'' palette swap a page despite the fact they can all coexist too. As for our existing pages, [[Metal Mario (character)|Metal Mario]] also exists independently as a boss in ''[[Dr. Mario 64]]'', and [[Dry Bowser]] gets a page using the same logic that sees things like [[Dark Fawful]] split - which is that splitting the boss info up makes it easier for readers to find and understand. But there's a threshold when partitioning stops being more convenient, and I think we've reached it here. | #{{User|Walkazo}} - I think this would be going too far. The rules are changing a bit now that DLC means Nintendo doesn't have to be so choosy about who they include: we'll probably see more and more alt forms of characters in spinoffs now, and it's going to get silly if they all get pages. I feel like moving forward, if duplicates of characters appear in sport/kart games, that alone shouldn't be enough to split them, like how we don't give every ''SSB'' palette swap a page despite the fact they can all coexist too. As for our existing pages, [[Metal Mario (character)|Metal Mario]] also exists independently as a boss in ''[[Dr. Mario 64]]'', and [[Dry Bowser]] gets a page using the same logic that sees things like [[Dark Fawful]] split - which is that splitting the boss info up makes it easier for readers to find and understand. But there's a threshold when partitioning stops being more convenient, and I think we've reached it here. | ||
#{{User|Mario}} Cat Peach isn't a distinct character as outlined above. If she gets more distinct playable appearances, then I'll reconsider. | #{{User|Mario}} Cat Peach isn't a distinct character as outlined above. If she gets more distinct playable appearances, then I'll reconsider. | ||
#{{User|Boo4761}} No way, it's just stupid clone cat bell form. And we would have to create other articles like Stone Leaf Toad. | |||
====Comments==== | ====Comments==== |
edits