23,679
edits
MarioWiki:Featured articles/N2/Macho Grubba: Difference between revisions
MarioWiki:Featured articles/N2/Macho Grubba (view source)
Revision as of 17:18, February 13, 2014
, 10 years ago→Comments
No edit summary |
m (→Comments) |
||
| Line 20: | Line 20: | ||
::::::FA Rule 11 says that articles must be at least 9000 bytes, this is around 8300. {{User|Yoshi876}} | ::::::FA Rule 11 says that articles must be at least 9000 bytes, this is around 8300. {{User|Yoshi876}} | ||
:::::::This is ridiculous. Using that rule, we can just pad out the article until it reaches 9000 bytes. Thank goodness Pinkie Pie retracted his vote. Quantity is nice, yes, but we're not gonna sacrifice the quality of an article just for the sake of reaching byte requirements; that's stupid. It's simply a guideline, not a rule. Hell, Miracle Book barely passes that amount: it was featured because it was complete and filled with high quality images, not because of how long or how much words it uses. {{User|Baby Luigi}} | :::::::This is ridiculous. Using that rule, we can just pad out the article until it reaches 9000 bytes. Thank goodness Pinkie Pie retracted his vote. Quantity is nice, yes, but we're not gonna sacrifice the quality of an article just for the sake of reaching byte requirements; that's stupid. It's simply a guideline, not a rule. Hell, Miracle Book barely passes that amount: it was featured because it was complete and filled with high quality images, not because of how long or how much words it uses. {{User|Baby Luigi}} | ||
:::::::Exactly, it's an FA because it has quality writing and images as well as passing the byte size requirement. We're not going to go, "Ph this article is past 9000 bytes therefore it can be featured" if the writing is awful. {{User|Yoshi876}} | |||
Would a small quotes section be necessary or helpful? I mean he does have some notable quotes that could be added. {{User|Tails777}} | Would a small quotes section be necessary or helpful? I mean he does have some notable quotes that could be added. {{User|Tails777}} | ||
:Definitely {{User|Baby Luigi}} | :Definitely {{User|Baby Luigi}} | ||