Talk:Rocky Wrench: Difference between revisions

Line 822: Line 822:
#{{user|Nintendo101}} - I think prior discussions were too bogged-down on the idea of Rocky Wrenches and Monty Moles as creatures to be taxonomically categorized, rather than characters designed by people not bound by such limitations. It also did not help that Monty Moles are generally more recurring in the franchise, and that the redesigns for Rocky Wrenches in ''NSMBW'' onward essentially looked like "Monty Mole, but with more stuff". Their history and shared Japanese names are particularly revealing, and site policy has been amended to promote conceptual and design relatedness in infoboxes, not just taxonomy. (As an aside, I do hope Nintendo continues to use the Super Mario Bros. 3 design for Rocky Wrench in the future, even if just occasionally. I've always been a fan.) EDIT: I also agree it is too declarative to say they are Koopas in the infobox.
#{{user|Nintendo101}} - I think prior discussions were too bogged-down on the idea of Rocky Wrenches and Monty Moles as creatures to be taxonomically categorized, rather than characters designed by people not bound by such limitations. It also did not help that Monty Moles are generally more recurring in the franchise, and that the redesigns for Rocky Wrenches in ''NSMBW'' onward essentially looked like "Monty Mole, but with more stuff". Their history and shared Japanese names are particularly revealing, and site policy has been amended to promote conceptual and design relatedness in infoboxes, not just taxonomy. (As an aside, I do hope Nintendo continues to use the Super Mario Bros. 3 design for Rocky Wrench in the future, even if just occasionally. I've always been a fan.) EDIT: I also agree it is too declarative to say they are Koopas in the infobox.
#{{User|SolemnStormcloud}} Per proposal.
#{{User|SolemnStormcloud}} Per proposal.
#{{User|LinkTheLefty}} Looks are deceiving when Koopas are involved.


===Oppose===
===Oppose===
94,848

edits