Talk:Peach Blossom: Difference between revisions

Talk:Peach Blossom (edit)

Revision as of 14:05, October 20, 2019

700 bytes added , 4 years ago

Added a proper talk page proposal clearly getting the desired point across.

Memoryman3

837

edits

@@ Line 56: / Line 56: @@
 Daisy's versions of moves straight up have different designs though. It's not like they just changed the color and be done with it. Plus, merging moves/items would get messy on search engines. If you type on Google for "Daisy Blossom" you don't get redirected to Daisy Blossom at all. --[[User:Memoryman3|Memoryman3]] ([[User talk:Memoryman3|talk]]) 07:17, October 20, 2019 (EDT)
-== Splitting Daisy's named moves - Search engines and intent. ==
+==Proposal: Daisy's moves==
-I did not explain this clearly in the previous slide and the failing proposal, but a key reason why I want Daisy's moves to be split is the content it generates in search engines. When someone is looking for Daisy Blossom or Daisy Bomber or Daisy Parasol, I am pretty sure they specifically want information, whether visual or otherwise, on Daisy's variants specifically. Content like Peach's version and the trophies are not relevant to them at that point. I am not arguing for other pages to be merged, but for Daisy's moves to be seperated because they look different, have different names, and are on a different character. Merging Peach and Daisy under Peach is just messy - and as a result, Daisy's moves are buried lower in search engines. --[[File:MK8DX_Daisy_Icon.png|30px]] memoryman3 11:35, October 20, 2019 (EDT)
+Currently, Daisy's moves, despite having different names and appearances and being used on a different character, are merged with Peach's articles with little relevant information on Daisy's variants. There is a precedent for entites which are almost identical in every way, such as several color swapped Mario Kart wheels, getting seperate articles solely based on their names and appearances and not gameplay changes. With this in mind, I propose seperating Daisy's moves into their own pages, removing visual/gameplay information pertaining to the moves in games which the variants do not appear in, such as [[Super Smash Bros. Brawl]], in order to keep the pages clean and information on the variant easy to find.
+Relevant articles include: [[Daisy Blossom]], [[Daisy Bomber]], [[Daisy Parasol]], [[Azure Roller]], [[Cyber Slick]], [[Hot Monster]], [[Retro Off-Road]]
+'''Proposer''': {{User|Memoryman3}}<br>
+'''Deadline''': November 3, 2019, 23:59 GMT
+====Support====
+#{{User|Memoryman3}} I believe it is generally cleaner to seperate the articles, despite the lack of gameplay differences. Having a different name and being assigned to a different character, along with different visual themes, is enough in my mind to justify the seperation. Also, I believe making the seperation is friendlier to the end user looking for a specific move - and each of the moves are already given their own segments in the game's training guide. Daisy's named moves are unique in that they are the only ones to not be seperated.
+====Oppose====
+====Comments====
+Th