Request for Piranha Plant templateEdit
Could anyone make one of those thingies that say Piranha Plant Species and Piranha Plant characters I think it's called a template, yeah, could someone put the Piranha Plant template on the Lava Bud page and the Naval Bud page? User:Lemmy Koopa Fan
Merge to Lava PiranhaEdit
|
This talk page proposal has already been settled. Please do not edit any of the sections in the proposal. If you wish to discuss the article, do so in a new header below the proposal. |
merge 4-1
This enemy is only ever encountered in battle alongside the Lava Piranha, and is in fact attached to it. Lava Buds are merely different heads of the same creature. A rose bush encompasses all the roses, despite them being different stems. It makes no sense to split this enemy, when we already contain similar examples on single articles. Even the official art of the Lava Piranha features Lava Buds alongside them, which suggests they are the same enemy. The difference in name merely suggests a description of development rather than of specieal difference.
Proposer: Redstar (talk)
Deadline: December 30th, 2009, 23:59 GMT
Merge to Lava PiranhaEdit
- Redstar (talk) - Per proposal.
- Zero777 (talk) I am Zero! Tough treated like a seperate being Lava buds are still part of Lava Piranha. Zero signing out.
- library_girl (talk) - Redstar's explanation in the comments section makes sense. Per it
- Walkazo (talk) - The tattle clearly states that the Lava Buds branch out of the main Lava Piranha stem, meaning they are all part of a single organism and deserve a single page.
Leave un-mergedEdit
- Bloc Partier (talk) -- Though it may be an underdeveloped Lava Piranha, it shouldn't be merged. It is a quite different creature at this stage of development, or whatever you wish to call it. Different attacks, appearance, and it cannot talk. Also, if I recall correctly, it can spawn Petit Piranhas, while the mother plant cannot.
CommentsEdit
I recently removed my vote on the Petit Piranha page after careful consideration. I don't know what caused me to think a living being spawned from another living thing is still the original (children aren't their parents, for example). Despite that, I still support the merge of this enemy into the main Lava Piranha page. Same bush, different stem. As for your example of the mother stem being unable to spawn Petit Piranhas, Bloc, I have this for a response: (pardon the analogy, but it's the closest there is to a real-life example) An animal can shoot sperm from their penis, but not any species I know of can do it from their head. Even more specifically, plants are known to have certain parts as the body, and other parts as the sexual reproductive area, in a division far more distant than animal bodies divide their functions. I think the same thing can be held true for this enemy. Redstar 01:08, 19 December 2009 (EST)
- Ha. Nice analogy. I definitely see your point, but I guess I'm still voting for the separation since I view it as a separate enemy. .
- Earthworms secrete gametes out of their anterior end... Besides that, however, Redstar's got the biology right: same organism, different organs. A better analogy would be Obelia, a genus of animals related to corals and jellyfish that spends most of its life-cycle as a colony of buds, half of which are used for feeding (like Lava Piranha's biting head), half of which are used for reproduction (like the Lava Buds). - Walkazo 00:56, 24 December 2009 (EST)
PictureEdit
Is the picture that we have for this monster its sprite or is it official box art. We usually use the former, but it seems like the latter. If it is box art, can we get a sprite instead? Jdrawer 17:03, 3 February 2012 (EST)
Merge Lava Bud to Lava PiranhaEdit
|
|
This talk page proposal has already been settled. Please do not edit any of the sections in the proposal. If you wish to discuss the article, do so in a new header below the proposal. |
deleted by user request
Above, their is a proposal that was made to merge Lava Bud to Lava Piranha on december 2009 and nothing was made to merge it even if the proposal passed. Well, I will recreate it with the same arguments from this proposal. This enemy is only ever encountered in battle alongside the Lava Piranha, and is in fact attached to it. Lava Buds are merely different heads of the same creature. A rose bush encompasses all the roses, despite them being different stems. It makes no sense to split this enemy, when we already contain similar examples on single articles. Even the official art of the Lava Piranha features Lava Buds alongside them, which suggests they are the same enemy. The difference in name merely suggests a description of development rather than of specieal difference. Like Crystal King and Crystal Bit are merge for the moments.
Proposer: LudwigVon (talk)
Deadline: August 22, 2015, 23:59 GMT
Merge to Lava PiranhaEdit
OpposeEdit
CommentsEdit
I don't think a follow up proposal is necessary in this situation, the previous proposal clearly passed in favor of merge. Unless you think there will be a different outcome this time, I'd say go ahead and perform the merger. -- Ghost Jam
20:40, 7 August 2015 (EDT)
