MarioWiki:Featured articles/N1/Princess Peach's Castle

Princess Peach's Castle

Support

1. Princess Peach's Castle is a very well written article and follows the required criteria to become a featured article. --ElPilotoDi 17:25, 14 December 2009 (EST)ElPilotoDi
2. User:Yoshionfire
3. Resbusha (talk)
4. Ralphfan (talk)
5. Jamdonaldson (talk)
6. Azela (talk)
7. Mario Fan 123

Oppose

1. Fawfulfury65 (talk) Hello? One liner section. Look under Other Appearances. Needs expanding.
2. Baby Mario Bloops (talk) Per FF65 with the image stuff. Needs a lot more images throughout the article, lots of information in the M&L series missing, and much more errors needed to be fixed.
3. Reversinator (talk) Images, images, images, images, where are all the glorious images?
4. Commander Code-8 (talk)I cannot believe the New Super Mario Bros. Wii image. IT'S HORRIBLE.
5. KS3 (talk) Hello? rewrite tag. Per all. Or I tried to put the rewrite tag on it and someone (I don't know who) removed. a lot of places need expanding, like the New Super Mario Bros section and the beginning. Too many short areas, that's why I tried to put the rewrite-expand template on it. Per all.

Comments

I don't know. I'm not sure if this is all of the game's appearances. But I'm pretty sure her castle does not appear in 11 games out of all. An F.A. must list all appearances it made in. Plus, I'm iffy about the "More Castles" section, because that has nothing to do with Peach's Castle itself. The layout seems wrong too (Mario Kart section in the middle of the Super Mario section and some other stuff, I think I can fix it). Otherwise, it's good, but not good enough. That's why I'm not supporting or opposing. BabyLuigiOnFire (talk)

Ummmmmmm....KS3, I think your vote may be a little invalid. Baby Mario Bloops (talk)