Talk:Assist Trophy

Come to think about it, they're very similar to Pokeballs. Should We mention that?----


 * Two things. 1:We should probably mention that it's like Pokeball with wider variety. 2:Should we have a template of Assist Trophies (possibly Poke Balls, too).-- 09:08, 2 July 2007 (EDT)

We don't have an article on every Pokemon, yet we're getting an article for every Assist Trophy character... I guess the Assist Trophy template is plausible. -- Booster

I think the Assist Trophy articles should just be merged into a single article, I mean, they really don't seem any different then Pokemon. -- Sir Grodus

True that, merging. 18:19, 14 July 2007 (EDT)
 * Yeah, merging sounds like a good idea

If all the Assist Trophy articles are merged here, maybe we could make some sort of table, having they're names, effects, an image and, if possible, rarerity; something similar to this Bowser, but more expansive. -- Sir Grodus

Or maybe more like the Pokemon article. 21:51, 14 July 2007 (EDT)

Yeah, that's a reasonable idea: Wait for the game to come out! -Dodo

Yeah, that could be done. -- Sir Grodus

Both Samurai Goro and Dr. Wright have trophies in Melee. Should we post their info somewhere here? Dodo


 * I vote for Aisst Trophies and all Pokemon getting their own articles. THAT IS MY OPINION KILL ME IF YOU WANT Paper Jorge, the one who gives paper cuts.


 * I think so too, but I'm not gonna fight the majority. -Dodo

Dodo: Then again every Pokemon in Melee has a Trophy too, but we didn't list them. Maybe we should stick every Trophy description on the Trophy page. PJ: Yeah, any reasons backing your opinion?


 * Well, Mr. I-don't-sign, that is my opinion. They're characters like Redead and Like Likes. I don't see why not have aritlces for them. Paper Jorge, the one who gives paper cuts.
 * We are not Smashwiki. So, we do not need seperate articles for the Assist Trophy or Pokemon. Additionally, that's what I suggested, but, putting Trophy Bios on the actual Trophy page would be messy.

I think they should be seperate, they each do a unique effect.

So do Pokemon. -- Sir Grodus

Well then, here's an idea for the trophies; Make a seperate page for the descriptions. -Ye Olde Dodo

That sounds good.

Let's wait and see how many Assist Trophies are actually used. There will most likely be more Assist Trophies than Pokemon, but let's leave them all on one page for now. We can't give too much focus to the crossover series, especially one that isn't released yet. 00:21, 16 July 2007 (EDT)

Oh, come on. I don't want to unmerge later. And I was going to give each Pokemon its own article.

OK, here is my opinion. Do not make seperate articles. It won't work, cos' most of the info will not be from the Marioverse. I also completely agree with Knife.
 * We should have a poll on this issue. And the decision can be changed when the game has been released. - 06:47, 16 July 2007 (EDT)
 * Good idea.

Poll
NOTE: The result of this poll is temporary. A new decision can be made when the game has been released.

Create Articles for Assist Trophy Characters

 * 1)  Dodoman
 * 2)  Booster
 * 3)  [[Image:Paperjorgesp.png]]  P  J   } 

Leave them all on this Article

 * 17:18, 16 July 2007 (EDT)
 * 1) This page, AND the Pokemon Page.
 * 17:18, 16 July 2007 (EDT)
 * 1) This page, AND the Pokemon Page.

Comments
Yes, we need to decide now. It can't be that action for both solutions is taken. There has to be a unique policy. - 11:13, 16 July 2007 (EDT)

I feel that they should get seperate articles. (Yes, I signed with my full username.) -Dodo

I think that both the Assist Trophies and Pokemon are worthy of seperate articles. This isn't Wikipedia, which has a super strict "importance policy". Sure, we have an importance policy of our own, but if you read it go down to the "Penalties" section, you'll find, in bold text: '''Also, there are no article limits for any area of focus. ''' - Booster.

Then maybe you should vote... 17:20, 16 July 2007 (EDT)