Talk:Rocky Wrench

"A few Rocky Wrenches man a three barreled cannon in Super Mario Sunshine. Shooting Bullet Bills and Missile Bills." Is this info correct? The species that control the cannons in Super Mario Sunshine don't have shells, yet the ones in SMB3 have Buzzy Beetle like shells. They may be Monty Moles or a new species. Can anyone confirm it, because there is no mention of Rocky Wrenches on any faq or guide.--Spike


 * Monty Moles man the cannons, not Rocky Wrenches. The text will remain deleted. -- Son of Suns

Should it be mentioned that the manual to Super Mario Bros. 3 clearly states they're a kind of turtle- and thus possibly related to Koopas? 21:18, 30 May 2007 (EDT)


 * SERIOUSLY?!?!?!?!?

It said something along the lines of, "They may look like moles, but they're actually turtles". It seems that, at the least, there's a possibility the two species could be related. 21:23, 30 May 2007 (EDT)

Hmm. Intersting.

Here it is:

"Rocky is a turtle who kind of looks like a mole." It's possible they're related, as they look almost as much like a typical Koopa Troopa as does a Lakitu. 21:27, 30 May 2007 (EDT)

Am I the only one whose noticed the shell? And where does it say they're related to Monty Moles? - Yoshi Mastar

I was saying that it's possible they're related to Koopas- being turtles that allied with them is some good circumstancial evidence. 12:57, 4 June 2007 (EDT)

I don't think they should be compared to either Monty Moles or Koopa Troopas. For now we call them "turtle-like mole creatures" or maybe "mole-like turtle creatures". 13:47, 11 June 2007 (EDT)

It seems that Rocky Wrenches are shell-less in Super Mario Galaxy... --Someone Else 17:34, 22 November 2007 (EST)

How are they koopas? they look like moles to me and they even act like moles. 14:57, 8 March 2009 (EDT)

Galaxy pic
Nothing too big, but does anyone have a picture of Rocky Wrench as he appears in Super Mario Galaxy? There are many other screenshots and pictures of who characters look in-game, I was just curious if anyone has managed to get a pic of him. - Smashgoom202 01:00, 26 October 2009 (EDT)

right here! -User:superpokezillabros

Sub-Species
Aren't Rocky Wrenches sub-species of Monty Moles? Even that they appear earlier in a game, their most recent look (in NSMBWii) is a Monty Mole with black glasses and blue frame, with the manhole on their head.
 * Montey moles do not have shells, also, we can't put that in the article because we have no proofs.
 * I have (this pic was ripped by a user, and not fanon made)

Hmm...I'm not sure about that pic.Even if it's real, it isn't mentioned anywhere that rockies are monty moles.I bellive it's better to get a screenshot, then maybe mention that they look like montey moles in Trivia.

Koopa or Monty Mole?
There seems to be a lot of debate about Rocky Wrenches' species of origin. I think its safe to say that in the early years of Mario they were just mole-like Koopas, but since the release of Super Mario Galaxy their signature Koopa shells were removed making them resemble Undergrunts (a species of Monty Mole) and as of New Super Mario Bros. they've been completely redesigned to be regular Monty Moles with goggles and wrenches. So wouldn't it be safe to say that Nintendo now intends them to be Monty Moles and to retcon the idea that they were once Koopas? - Four Paper   Heroes   01:09, 12 July 2011 (EDT)
 * No that is speculation until a source says they are monty moles they should be considered koopas since the only source says they look like moles but are actually koopas
 * I'm just saying that this picture seems to imply their conversion from Koopa to Monty Mole... <:/ - Four Paper  Heroes  FourPaperHeroes.jpg 01:17, 12 July 2011 (EDT)
 * So what look at a shellcreeper they look a lot like koopas but there not koopas there just turtles a source has called rocky wrenchs koopas but never monty moles and just look at the guides that have come out for games with rocky wrenches in them and none of them have called them monty moles

This is actually up for discussion?
Seriously? Everyone on this website says that Rocky Wrench is a koopa? Can someone PLEASE link me to some kind of source that says this, even for the older games? Yeah, he may have had a shell in the past, but that doesn't make him a Koopa. Buzzy Beetles have shells, why don't we call them Koopas? Getting passed the older stuff, let's examine his new design: Fur. Buck Teeth. Whiskers. Claws. Pads in his hands. Big white belly. Little black nose. He is a carbon copy of Monty Mole, with goggles. The fact that anyone can say it's speculation to call him a Monty Mole is astounding. At the VERY least, if there IS an actual source that says he was once a Koopa, it needs to be fixed to say that he was retconned into a Monty Mole. However, based on his old design (claws, little nose on a snout), I'd say he was originally NOT meant to be a Koopa and the writers of this article are out of their minds. --Youreserious 02:13, 12 July 2011 (EDT)
 * I personally never saw Rocky Wrenches as Koopas, I always thought they wore the shells for protection. - Four Paper  Heroes  FourPaperHeroes.jpg 02:25, 12 July 2011 (EDT)
 * There is a source it's the Super Mario Bros. 3 booklet it calls them turtles that look like moles and moles, also they are called koopas on the Super Mario Bros. 3 page, also it would be even worse for this site to call them Monty Moles since like ive said multiple times there is no source that has ever called them Monty Moles and until one calls them that they are not Monty Moles

Um, this was sorted out when I was a noob here, guys... Look at the top. Ah, how I miss some of those good old boys who've moved on. Begins to yodel a song about 3D 02:49, 12 July 2011 (EDT)
 * I repeat: Turtle does not instantly mean Koopa. If the manual had said "Is a koopa that looks like a mole" then yes, you'd put koopa. For now, it's just a turtle. And Goomba's Shoe: Seriously, are you blind or retarded?--Youreserious 00:22, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * You mad that i'm right cause fact of the matter is that Rocky Wrenchs arent Monty Moles in fact there not even related cause the only source says that they are turtles that look like moles so you can back off your little rant until you back your claims up sir

I edited the article to be as correct as possible. The manual, the only source for this information, says "Rocky Wrench is a turtle that looks like a mole." It does not say "Rocky Wrench is a Koopa that looks like a mole." Being a turtle does not instantly mean it's a Koopa (see: Shellcreepers. Turtles, but not Koopas.) Since there is only one source for all of this information, I edited the article to reflect the source. As it stands it is misleading and damages the integrity of the site due to how off it is. Thank you.--Youreserious 01:20, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * I've said it more than once now.
 * Everything else points to them being Koopas even the Super Mario Bros. 3 page on are site lists them in the Koopa enemies section so something had to have called them Koopas at some point


 * Nothing points to them being Koopas. The one source we have is from a manual that refers to them as turtles. Everything else on this site has been edited by regular users, not by Nintendo. That just means the other pages need to be fixed as well.--Youreserious 01:41, 13 July 2011 (EDT)

How about this: the Rocky Wrench page always states there were Koopas. In Super Mario Bros. 3, they have shells. 07:43, 13 July 2011 (EDT) @DKPetey: Once again, the Rocky Wrench Page is wrong. This website is not canon information, it's an archive of information. We don't make things up and they're automatically right. Buzzy Beetles also have shells. Are they Koopas?
 * My opinion still stands that they were originally Koopas in the old games, but now in modern games Monty Moles have taken their place (as seen in the modern artwork and sprites), so in the past, yes they were Koopas/Turtles whatever, but now in the present they are intended to be Monty Moles, unless of course there's two separate species of Rocky Wrenches, one that's a Koopa/Turtle whatever and one that's a Monty Mole wearing goggles... - Four Paper  Heroes  FourPaperHeroes.jpg 12:38, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * And btw, is that comment about them being turtles from the english manual? If so couldn't it be a possibility that the whole turtle thing is only exclusive to them in the american version? - Four Paper  Heroes  FourPaperHeroes.jpg 12:41, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * And i'll tell you all what ive said every time until a source comes and says they ae related to monty moles they arent related to monty moles there just koopa/turtles who like moles
 * @DKPetey: The only reason the Rocky Wrench page says they are Koopas is because some user equated being a mole-like turtle to being a Koopa. They are members of the Koopa Troop, but they're not Koopas, especially not now, no more than Goombas are. Nintendo has never stated that they were; therefore, any claim that they are is nothing more than an assumption. @Goomba's Shoe15: They're not turtles anymore. 12:49, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * Do you have a guide that says there not not turtles cause unless you do they are turtles
 * RockyWrenchNSMBW.png Does this look like a turtle to you? I don't see a shell. Just because they were turtles in SMB3 doesn't mean they are now. 12:54, 13 July 2011 (EDT)

They are both. Let's stop arguing! The page is already protected! 12:57, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * No they are not moles the only source says there turtles who look like moles therefore there turtles until something says otherwise
 * That source only describes Rocky Wrenches in SMB3. It does not describe those in SMG or NSMBWii because they no longer fit the definition of "turtles that look like moles." 13:01, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * If you can find a source that calls them monty moles than go ahead an change it but as of now no source has called them moles only that they look like moles

As Mario4Ever said, this image speaks louder than words: they are no longer meant to be Koopas, they are Monty Moles now, and again that whole comment about them being turtles only exists in the american guide (which are not always perfect) translators aren't perfect you know... - Four Paper  Heroes   13:09, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * No true there japanses name is Tortopo which is a Portmanteau of "tortuga" (tortoise) and "topo" (mole). and no they don't not when i can cite my info and you can't until a source calls them moles they are turtles who look like moles
 * I'm not saying they're now Monty Moles (at best, we could only call them mole-like). All I'm saying is that they're not turtles anymore. They don't have shells anymore. The almost 23 year-old definition doesn't stand when one looks at the Rocky Wrench as seen in the recent games. Unfortunately, Nintendo no longer lists its enemies in its instruction booklets, so there's no way to officially resolve the issue. 13:15, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * Exactly. - Four Paper  Heroes  FourPaperHeroes.jpg 13:16, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * Yes there is one call them turtles which the source calls them thats the only option cause there not moles and we have a source that says there turtles that look like moles
 * You cannot say that shell-less mole-like creatures are turtles according to a definition that describes a mole-like shelled creature as a turtle. 13:21, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * I can and i have and i will according to are only source which has not been discredited by and official source they are turtles and thats what they shall remain

Does anyone have a japanese version of the guide? If it says their turtles fine, but as of Super Mario Galaxy they are no longer turtles, maybe they evolved, maybe they made a wish to the stars to be mole-ish, or maybe the guys at Nintendo thought "you know what lets make them look like monty moles so they'll be cuter and less silly looking". - Four Paper  Heroes   14:50, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * If you change the species you are making edits based of speculation the eyes are misleadng the source is not the source calls them turtles and no matter how much they look like monty moles they are to remain turtles until a source says they are monty moles they are to remain turtles

I found something on a few japanese sites, apparently the japanese name for the Rocky Wrench from SMB 3 is Pū (プー) and the one from SMG and onward is Mogu (モグ), does this mean something? - Four Paper  Heroes   15:27, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * Here's a list of Japanese-speaking users. I suggest asking one of them. 17:18, 13 July 2011 (EDT)
 * Hey what sites did those names come from

@DKPetey: Once again, the Rocky Wrench Page is wrong. This website is not canon information, it's an archive of information. We don't make things up and they're automatically right. Buzzy Beetles also have shells. Are they Koopas? No. Every argument here has said that Rocky Wrenches are turtles. I'll bite on that, the manual says that. But turtles =/= koopas. The article is wrong and hurts the integrity of the website. Change koopa to "turtle" or "mole-like turtle" and it'll be accurate. Remove all references to it being a Koopa throughout the site.--Youreserious 18:20, 14 July 2011 (EDT)
 * Additionally, mogu means "mole".--Youreserious 02:33, 15 July 2011 (EDT)

So discussion is dead
And my argument still stands. No one has proven me wrong. Please fix the article now. ONE source calls them turtles, and turtles are not necessarily koopas. His japanese name is "Mole" in all appearances after SMB3. Remove all references to him being a Koopa from this article and throughout the site. If you can't call him a mole, call him a Turtle-Like Mole, but do NOT call him a Koopa. It hurts the integrity of the site to have such terrible information up.--Youreserious 23:38, 15 July 2011 (EDT)
 * Finally, the Monty Mole/Koopa issue is over, but in a negative way to say "don't you ever write the Rocky Wrench is a Koopa or a Monty Mole again until there's a official source that tells that the Rocky Wrench is really a Monty Mole or a Koopa". Honestly, I vote for Rocky Wrench being a Monty Mole. Still stating that Rocky Wrench is a turtle is really nasty, unless he's a turtle in a disguise of a Monty Mole. LOL just kidding. XD--Prince Ludwig 00:45, 18 July 2011 (EDT)
 * Saying it's a Monty Mole based on the above source calling it a Mole, is the Koopa/Turle debate all over again.
 * Let's wait until the future confirms that wether the Rocky Wrench is really a Monty Mole or a Koopa/Turtle (SMB3's Rocky Wrench, I admit, has kind of a body to that of a Hammer Bro., the artwork of the Rocky Wrench makes it look both like a mole and a Koopa).

Rocky Wrenches are Monty Moles
According to, Rocky Wrenches are a type of turtle rather than a Monty Mole, and his reasons are that the English manual of SMB3 (from more than 20 years ago) mentions that they are turtles that look like moles, but modern images clearly shown them as Monty Moles now so the manual's info is clearly outdated and they have clearly been redesigned into Monty Moles (and as they say, pictures speak louder than words), plus they have no traces of their "turtle" origin aka no shell. But whatever the wiki chooses then let it be.

Proposer: Deadline: January 2, 2012, 23:59 GMT

Support

 * 1) - Per my proposal.
 * 2) The artwork for New Super Mario Bros. Wii does not show them with a shell meaning that they are not turtles. Per proposal.
 * 3) - Per all.
 * 4) - Per all.
 * 5) - Per all.

Oppose

 * 1) No Source has called them a Monty mole and most names suggest that they are a mole turtle hybrid and being a mole does not equal being a Monty mole

Comments
It doesn't matter what they look like saying there a type of Monty Mole because they look like one is Speculation
 * Whatever the case may be it is clear that the present Rocky Wrenches are no longer "turtles" so we either reclassify them as Monty Moles or someone decides that Rocky Wrenches should be split into two articles, one for the ones that clearly look like Monty Moles and one for Raven Effect's "turtles". Although I'm still in favor of the reclassification. - Four Paper  Heroes  FourPaperHeroes.jpg 19:46, 19 December 2011 (EST)
 * Per the comparisons of the Monty Mole and Rocky Wrench, it is obviously a goggle-wearing, wrench-wielding Monty Mole with a manhole on his head. --YoshiMP8a.PNG Super YoshiBros YoshiMP8a.PNG 19:47, 19 December 2011 (EST)