User:Walkazo/Essays

Here's where I shall rant about my views on the Mario series or the Super Mario Wiki itself. I like writing these sort of spiels in the first person, so by school standards my "essays" would fail (they're supposed to be in the third person, like lab reports, and things). I also like rambling, so don't expect picture-perfect structuring either; this is for me, not English class. And because it's for me, I'm not gonna sugar-coat anything; there's not gonna be swearing or flaming or anything like that, but I'm not gonna be spending hours using a thesaurus to come up with less pejorative synonyms for "stupid", "lazy" or that sorta ilk. You've been warned.

How I'd Organize the Content of the Super Mario Wiki
Bold entries (not including parenthetical listings) are series that require full coverage (individual pages for all aspects of the series); unbolded names indicate that a series page is all that's necessary for that series. Crossovers are also in bold, however the information on individual articles pertaining to aspects of series other than Mario should only be included in respects to that specific game/crossover series. The non-Mario series listed under their crossover titles should be given series pages, which would only include aspects of the series encountered in the Mario crossovers which are not relevant enough for individual articles (i.e. Wolfen), and Mario cameos in the series' games (such as the Thwomps in The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening).

My Chart
Mario (Including Mario Kart, Mario Party, all Mario sports titles, Paper Mario, Mario & Luigi, and everything else with "Mario" in it's title.) Crossovers:
 * Yoshi
 * Wario
 * WarioWare
 * Pyoro
 * Donkey Kong
 * Donkey Konga
 * Diddy Kong Racing
 * Banjo
 * Conker
 * Mario Hoops 3-on-3
 * Final Fantasy
 * Itadaki Street DS
 * Itadaki Street
 * Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games
 * Sonic
 * Super Smash Bros
 * The Legend of Zelda
 * Kirby
 * Star Fox

My Justification
The links between Mario, Wario (including WarioWare), Donkey Kong (and its affiliates), and Yoshi are constantly being strengthened with Sports, Party and Racing games, whereas Banjo and Conker have been disassociated with the major Mario series since their beginnings in Diddy Kong Racing. This is why I feel series pages are enough coverage of these two for the time being - there's more relevant aspects of the Mario superseries (in relation to Mario and the other "core" series) that need the attention. Perhaps in the future, Banjo and Conker could be given full coverage, but that time is not yet upon us. As for Pyoro, it is still a new series, but (as far as I know), it's branching away from WarioWare too; because of this and the fact that Pyoro is as far removed from the central focus of this Wiki ("Mario" titles) as Banjo and Conker, by that same reasoning, it should only be given general coverage as well.

Now, the reason I include WarioWare under Wario, Donkey Konga and Diddy Kong Racing under Donkey Kong, and all the "Mario" games under Mario is because I feel they are all joined at the hip. The Mario Kart, Party and sports titles all bear "Mario" in their names, and feature Mario above all the other characters, so I consider them Mario titles. The same goes for all the "mainstream" Mario games: Paper Mario is no less of a Mario game than Super Mario Bros., in my opinion. The Wario games can be grouped together by the same rule: Wario Land titles and WarioWare titles both star Wario and have his name in their titles; he is an integral part in both (sub-)series. And while he may wear different clothes in WarioWare, I consider them Wario games as much as I do Wario Land. While I can apply this logic to the relationship between Donkey Kong's starring roles in the Donkey Kong and Donkey Konga titles, Diddy Kong Racing requires a bit more weaseling. DKR does not have "Donkey Kong" in its title, nor does it feature the big ape; this would be a problem, if that wasn't already a normal occurrence in the main DK titles: Donkey Kong Country 2 also features Diddy over the eponymous DK, and Donkey Kong Country 3 goes a step further and cuts out both stars of the original Donkey Kong Country. Clearley it's not "Donkey" but "Kong" that matters in the DK Country (and DK Land) games, so why should DK Racing be treated any different? - In my defense, it's not speculation, it's interpretation.

Finally, I'd like to talk about why I'd like to see series pages for the non-Mario series encountered in the crossover titles. As mentioned in the legend/overview up top, it'd be a place to dump minor out-series aspects found in the crossover games and summarize Mario stuff in relation to the series. The former would be a good compromise in the ongoing debate over what Super Smash Bros. stuff isn't worth inclusion (to go back to my example, Wolfen is pretty minor, and moving it to a Star Fox series page would preserve the information and also quiet those who wanted the Wolfen article deleted). The latter would mean the series pages would list the Mario cameos in the out-series, and their own cameos in the Mario titles (yes, we already have pages for those, but having them in one place would certainly be handy, especially for series like The Legend of Zelda, where it's harder to find a game that does not reference Mario). It's also irritating to have to read all the character articles or go to some other Wiki to learn the bare basics of a series, and a brief overview on a series page (I'm taking a paragraph only, and nothing game-specific, just series norms) isn't going to change what the Super Mario Wiki is all about.

And that's my two-cents on the whole thing.

Redirection
What merits a redirect? Plurals do, as do commonly-made spelling errors, like "Mario and Luigi" instead of "Mario & Luigi". There was once a "Bananna" redirect, but that was deleted; it had crossed that line from sensible to silly - at least, according to its deletor it had, but not its creator, which begs the question of what is "too far"? Which spelling mistakes should we compensate for? Which abbreviations should we use? Everyone is bound to have different opinions on this, so the challenge will be to look at it objectively and make sure it doesn't turn into a discussion of who's right and who's being unreasonable. A balance needs to be struck so that the Wiki is easy to use, yet not bogged down with unnecessary redirects.

The easiest way to communicate my thoughts is with an example: "Mario Kart: Double Dash!!".

This title includes punctuation marks, which are one the largest stumbling blocks for searchers. For that reason, I would allow the redirects, "Mario Kart Double Dash", "Mario Kart Double Dash!!" and "Mario Kart: Double Dash".


 * There is also a possibility that someone would only use one exclamation mark, however I feel we have no obligation to compensate for this mistake. None of the other Mario Kart titles have exclamation marks, so the searchers would not have a preconceived notion of Mario Kart titles possessing single "!"s. The exclamation marks in Mario Kart: Double Dash!! are meant to further the sense of urgency from the "dash" while at the same time emphasizing the "double" in the title; they are unique to that game, and should be memorable for that fact. Of course, no one's memory is perfect, and while someone may recall punctuation at the end of the title, they may erroneously assume there is only one "!", like in grammatically-correct exclamations; but that is no fault of ours. It should be no trouble to them if they have to re-search with different punctuation, whereas two redirects ("Mario Kart Double Dash!" and "Mario Kart: Double Dash!") eats up precious server space.

While spelling mistakes are a common place on the Internet, they should be given less leeway than punctuation mistakes.


 * Personally, I often try to spell "Double Dash" as "Double-Dash", but that's my own fault, and I think including ""Mario Kart: Double-Dash!!", ""Mario Kart Double-Dash", "Mario Kart Double-Dash!!" and "Mario Kart: Double-Dash" as redirects would not be a good idea. It's better to learn though one's mistakes, and being forced to drop the hyphen when searching or linking certainly bores the correct spelling into my brain better than simply noticing I accidentally went to a redirect would.


 * The reason I said "Mario and Luigi" is acceptable before is because symbols are another matter: "+"s, "&"s and "and"s are all used in Mario titles, so if someone forgets when "+"s and "&"s are used and defaults to "and", that is reasonable. However, substituting "+"s for "&" should not be allowed, since, like my "double-dash" error, there is a limit to how much we should enable the searchers' memory laps.


 * English spelling mistakes, with the exception of British vs. American spellings, and titles that contain unusual characters (i.e. "Pokémon" vs. "Pokemon"), should never be turned into redirects. The unusual character rule also applies to non-English languages that still use Latin characters, such as the German Club Nintendo subjects. Japanese names with no English equivalent are given more leeway, however, as many sounds can be written with many different spellings (i.e Trezyan; Treajan; Treasan and Torezyan for Torejan). Then, once an English translation is established, the Japanese redirects become redundant (as this is an English Wiki) and can slowly be phased-out.

As with all games, there are many possible abbreviations searchers may use for "Mario Kart: Double Dash!!" Personally, I use "MKDD" and "MKDD!!", though I know "MK DD", "MK DD!!", "MK:DD!!", "MK:DD", "MK: DD!!" and "MK: DD" are also used. All of these are valid redirects, however many other short-forms aren't. I often call the game "Double Dash" in conversation to save on time, but I know better than to type that in on the search bar to look for the game, and so should other searchers. The point of the Wiki is to be a user-friendly database, but anyone who feels "Double Dash", "Double Dash!!", ""DD", "DD!!" and even the unlikely "Kart: Double Dash!!" (as well as its derivatives, "Kart: Double Dash", "Kart Double Dash!!" and "Kart Double Dash") should all be redirects are simply being lazy and unreasonable.

In addition to abbreviations are alternate titles, though this is more applicable to people, places and things, rather than games like "Mario Kart: Double Dash!!". In most cases, any official name Nintendo has provided should become a redirect, which is why Peach, Princess Peach Toadstool, Princess Toadstool and Toadstool all redirect to Princess Peach - they're all valid names.


 * However, it gets difficult when nicknames are involved. While some would argue that "Weegie" is a famous enough nickname of Luigi's to merit a redirect, others would say searchers should know better than to use nicknames and simply type in an actual name or common title. Moreover, one-time nicknames (such as "M" for Mario in Mario is Missing!, or "Butterball" for Bowser in Super Paper Mario) should not get redirects either.


 * Pluralizations are much more clear-cut: they should be allowed for species and items (except for one-of-a-kind objects), as they are proper spellings in their own rights, and people may often link and/or search for them instead of for the singular names.

Finally, capitalization is a point that is often disagreed upon surrounding redirects. While it is much easier to type in the lowercase words, like abbreviations, it is also lazy, and a line has to be drawn. Game titles are proper names, and searchers should recognize this; other search engines may be able to compensate for capitalization, but we can't, and we shouldn't have any obligation to make up for that with hundreds of redirects. Therefore, I say "mario kart: double dash", "mario kart: double dash!!", "mario kart double dash!!", "mario kart double dash" and any uncapitalized abbreviations (i.e. "mkdd") should not be redirects.

Summarizing List
The following chart summarizes what I believe should and shouldn't be redirects in relation to Mario Kart: Double Dash!!. The "Grey Area" list is the redirects I'd like second opinions on, either because I'm not completely against them (the ones with parentheses after them), or because they're controversial capitalization redirects (in italics).

And just so we're clear on how many redirects you can get if you let every single capitalization, punctuation and hyphenation permutation (for "Mario Kart: Double Dash!!" and "MKDD") get a redirect, there would be all the above pages, plus 132 more.