MarioWiki:Proposals

Writing guidelines
None at the moment.

New features
None at the moment.

Removals
None at the moment.

Changes
None at the moment.

Decide if obscure media filenames from Nintendo's websites qualify as sources for subject names
In my efforts to cover Nintendo's diverse promotional online material on the wiki, I've come across a number of images whose filenames provide unique spellings of a subject's name, or even new names altogether. I am aware this wiki, by and large, has allowed the citing of internal filenames as sources for the names of certain subjects, such as Uckykong and the Super Mario Galaxy planets, but I find the aforementioned website filenames to be of a different nature: in-game filenames originate from a game's developers, who are arguably a much higher authority over how a subject is called than the person who mistypes the filenames in a press kit, officially endued as they may be. Furthermore, these website filenames can be rather poorly formatted. Take this image from Play Nintendo, for example; the subject it depicts, the Ice Hockey minigame from Mario Party Superstars, is mispelled as "Ive Hockey" in the picture's filename. An official mispelling for sure, but a mispelling nevertheless, and I have my doubts on how well it would reflect on the wiki to acknowledge Ive Hockey as an alternate name for that minigame on its article, given the "source".

I believe we should draw a hard line on whether we can acknowledge any and all of these website filenames, or none at all. I've listed several subjects concerned by this proposal:
 * Metal Mario -- referred to as "Gem Mario" in a Play Nintendo filename
 * Professor Elvin Gadd -- referred to as "Professor Edgar" in a Play Nintendo filename. The file itself is hosted on cloudfront, but is embedded as a thumbnail for Professor E. Gadd's Research Journal in the search suggestions on Play Nintendo, so it's official media.
 * Mario Party: The Top 100 -- abbreviated as "MPTOH" (Mario Party Top One Hundred) in a Play Nintendo filename
 * Bumper Balloon Cars -- referred to as "Balloon Cars" in a Play Nintendo filename
 * Hot Rope Jump -- referred to as "Hot Jump Rope" in a Play Nintendo filename
 * Rocky Road (minigame) -- mispelled as "Rockey Road" in a Play Nintendo filename
 * Cat Goomba -- referred to as "Munster" (possibly a mispelling of "monster") in a Nintendo Kids Club filename
 * Crazee Dayzee -- referred to as "Blume" (German for "flower") in a Nintendo Kids Club filename
 * Shy Guy -- referred to as "Ghost" in a Nintendo Kids Club filename
 * Flutter -- Japanese name ("Hanachan") was mispelled as "Hanachyan" in a filename on the official Mario Party: Island Tour website.

From taking the liberty to refer to an established character as "Professor Edgar", to bum writing mishaps like "Rockey Road", I think it's clear now that these filenames are a horse of a different colour. This is why I am calling upon other editors to help assess their quality as sources. I myself am leaning towards using them, purely because they are official, but I sense others may have objections given the things I've stated above.

Proposer: Deadline: December 28, 2021, 23:59 GMT

Acknowledge these names/misspellings in articles and use them as redirects

 * 1) First choice.

Only use these names/misspellings as redirects

 * 1) Second choice.
 * 2) Might as well document them somewhere, but I think treating obvious mistakes like these as actual, official names on par with any other source would make us look ridiculous. The same could be said for Prima's countless gaffes, but at least those were in published material that are more likely to be seen by the general public. These are just filenames that would only be seen when digging through obscure Play Nintendo games. See also my thoughts on Talk:Gooigi.

Do not cite these filenames at all

 * 1) Nobody is going to see these, and they're blatant mistakes. We know that Cat Goomba isn't named "Munster", and nobody's going to call it that. Creating a redirect from "Ive Hockey" to "Ice Hockey" because some obscure filename did it seems excessive. This is reminding me of Ahehehauhe.