Talk:Golden Mushroom

"Endless grey for a limited time" It doesn't make sence… Both endless and limited… My brain hurts…
 * ? -- 18:30, 4 January 2011 (EST)

It means you can use it as many times as you want/can during the time it is active. Makes perfect sense to me... Zsashas (talk) 22:21, 16 August 2012 (EDT)

Gold Mushroom
The things in NSMB2 aren't Golden Mushrooms. They're Gold Mushrooms. They are not supposed to be these things, they're just Mushrooms colored gold to fit with the game's gold theme.

I agree with this. It's completely diferent too. I think we should split it

Superstar Saga
Shouldn't we state where the five Golden Mushrooms in M&L:SS are, I can give you 3, one from the Beanlet Sidequest, one from the Popple & Birdo fight, & one from the 2nd Fawful fight, should we add this? -Yellowyoshi(Guest)

There's also one in a 2D sidescrolling section near Bean town place on possession of a Golden Monty. -Yellowyoshi(Guest)

Split this page's distinct items
This page has been used as a dumping ground for every mushy that happens to be yellow and shiny and is starting to turn into Reverse Mushroom mark II. There are at least four distinct items listed here:


 * Golden Dash Mushroom (formerly Super Mushroom and Golden Mushroom)
 * Japanese: Powerful Dash Kinoko (formerly Powerful Kinoko)

This is a rare item based primarily around coins, like everything else in NSMB2. It has a light stem and cap with dark spots and has been consistently called "Gold Mushroom," not "Golden Mushroom."

Anyways, I think the ideal solution is to just split all four of these (while merging Golden Dash and Super to their respective pages), though I'm open to suggestions on alternate methods.

Proposer: Deadline: August 2, 2021, 23:59 GMT

Support

 * 1) Per proposal
 * 2) - per proposal
 * 3) - I think it's a good idea to split them, since there is indeed the Mario Kart item, the Mario Party item, and the M&L item, though I don't know what would be optimal to do about the Super Nintendo World and the NSMB2 ones... I'd say probably split the items in 4 also, but the Super Nintendo World one would be merged into the NSMB2 Gold Mushroom page, since that one is the only Gold Mushroom that seems the most basic of them all, while the others all have special things about them (lots of boost in MK, ability to use 3 dices in MP, health in M&L).
 * 4) - This Golden Mushroom page sure has a lot of variants and effects in different games. Per Proposal.
 * 5) - Per proposal.
 * 6) Personally, splitting them for now based on their effects and maybe coming up with further plans for these articles later down the line sounds like a good idea. For now, splitting them seems like the... golden option.
 * 7) Per all, bothered me that these three items all act super differently from each other and have different designs.
 * 8) While I am unsure as to where the Super Nintendo World Gold Mushroom should go, I otherwise support this. Per all.
 * 9) Per everyone.
 * 10) Per all.

Comments
I’m kind of on the fence on splitting the NSMB2 one, but i’m all in for splitting the Kart and Party ones. Somethingone (talk) 19:17, July 19, 2021 (EDT)

I'm thinking if this passes, this page could be turned into a disambiguation. 20:47, July 19, 2021 (EDT)

Regarding Gold and Golden Kinoko, I think the colors being consistently different along with them making a new render indicate they are intended as separate. Doc von Schmeltwick (talk) 21:06, July 19, 2021 (EDT)


 * I guess. At this point, making it a disambiguation seems reasonable considering the vast amount of redesigns and effects it has across the games it is in. I’ll support this now. Somethingone (talk) 21:43, July 19, 2021 (EDT)

If this passes, then would the Golden Dash Mushroom that's currently on this page be merged with the Golden Dash Mushroom of Mario Party? Because if so, I will support it. 15:34, July 23, 2021 (EDT)
 * Yes, that's covered in the last line. Doc von Schmeltwick (talk) 15:35, July 23, 2021 (EDT)