Talk:Coin

Should we put how coins work on Club Nintendo?


 * Well maybe a quick mention (if they are Mario coins), but it seems such information would be more beneficial on a Club Nintendo page. --
 * I suggested here that we could have a page on the Club Nintendo loyalty program. --Grandy02 07:43, 2 January 2009 (EST)


 * We should - it's a major Nintendo program that releases some exclusive Mario products. Unfortunately I don't know enough about it to actually start the article. --

Mario Kart 7
Is the maximum amount of coins you can get in a GP 40 because you can get 10 coins per level, or does it add up ALL the coins you collect even if they don't count towards your total during the race? Because 40 coins per GP would mean you have to play 125 grand prix to get a Ghastly Glider and 250 GPs for Gold Glider and etc...Mastergiygas 16:47, 28 December 2011 (EST)

Coins compared to american dollars
Someone has found out how much a "Mushroom Kingdom Coin" is compared to a U.S. Dollar. (dollar as they are probably american) i can't remember how much it was, but it was said on a video, if i find it should i link the source? 109.145.44.126 15:42, 26 February 2013 (EST)

More pictures less writing.
It needs more pics. There really isn't that much. Also It needs less writing. I am goombob and I love paper mario games (talk) 18:27, 17 May 2013 (EDT)Goombob
 * The pictures and their useless captions seem adequate to me. I don't see how there is too much writing. We don't have any overblown plot "synopsizes" here. 00:08, 18 May 2013 (EDT)

Merge 5 Gold Coin and 50 Gold Coin with Coin
The articles 5 Gold Coin and 50 Gold Coin are stubs, and they always will. There's nothing to say about them; they're just coins with a different value. The article Coin already covers different types of coins which do not deserve their own articles. I'm not sure this even needs a TPP, frankly

Proposer: Deadline: January 13, 2016, 23:59 GMT

Support

 * 1) Per proposal
 * 2) I agree because red and blue coins from Super Mario 64 are covered by Coin.

Oppose

 * 1) Stubs are not short articles. Stubs are articles that are lacking in information. The items have different values than a regular coin, and are distinguished with unique appearances and names. By all means, they should have individual articles. This proposal also fails to account for 10 Gold Coin, 20 Blue Coin, the WL4 Coin, Large Coin, and Giant Coin.
 * 2) - Per Time Turner. Better to have many small articles for many different things (officially named or otherwise) rather than only having the info in one conglomerated page, which is harder to pick relevant details out of, more awkward to deal with for navigation, and which may not net as much search traffic.
 * 3) This would be like merging Super Mushroom, 1-Up Mushroom, etc. into the main Mushroom article.
 * 4) Per all.
 * 5) Per TT.
 * 6) Per all.
 * 7) – Per all.
 * 8) Per all.

Comments
Fair enough. Are the names even official? Some of them are tagged as conjectural, and none of them include references. I might have to change my proposal to include those articles, but I don't see the point of:
 * Coin (Wario Land 4). The talk page mentions an organization by game is more efficient, but as far as I know that's the only case. The coins do not act differently in WL4. It was apparently supposed to prevent "making an article for all the different types of Coin name", which happened anyway.
 * Coin (Diddy Kong Racing DS). If the Mario Kart coins, which have a different effect than regular coins, are covered in the Coin article, then these should too.
 * Large Coin. Conjectural name, should be merged with 5 Gold Coin (and then be merged with Coin if my original proposal passes)
 * Giant Coin. If a source for the name doesn't come up, should become 100 Gold Coin (and then be merged with Coin if my original proposal passes)
 * 20 Blue Coin. Only appears in one game, and doesn't appear along regular Blue coins. Could be merged with Blue Coin, although I admit they're not collectibles as usual.
 * X Gold Coin. Per proposal. 16:10, 30 December 2015 (EST)
 * The main point is that all of those coins have different values, different from the rest, with different appearances, and that's what warrants their different articles. Besides that, though, why? As far as I can tell, the Coin article doesn't have any other coins nested inside, instead preferring to briefly mention them while linking to their main article. I don't think it'd be particularly neater to nest all of the information and images from the several Coins you'd like to merge in the various subsections instead of one-off articles. On that note, is there anything wrong with having them be separate articles? There isn't a standard for merging articles like these, so the argument can't rest on that. Don't fix what isn't broken.
 * You're right in that the coin article doesn't cover different types of coin, my bad. I went back and noticed that the examples that I'd seen actually link to a separate article. Anyway, apparently I don't understand what is deserving of its own page, but to me it seems rather silly to create articles for all types of coins. 18:49, 30 December 2015 (EST)
 * Is there any particular reason you think it's silly? The general trend of the wiki is to split instead of merge, to give articles to multiple subjects instead of bunching them into one article, and this is another example of that, imo.
 * Well, contrary to the various Mushroom items, these coins are not differentiated by their names (until a reference comes up, I'll consider those titles are conjectural), or by their effects (they both increase your coin total; not by the same amount, granted, but still. It's a basic coin. Collecting 5 or 8 of those doesn't unlock anything, unlike the Dragon Coins and Red Coins). They admittedly have a different appearance, but is that enough variation to warrant a separate article? The shape and color is the same. Should we split the Koopa Troopa article based on shell color because of AI difference? It seems like the wiki's saying those types of coins are fundamentally different than the regular coins, but the way I see it, they're not. 20:36, 30 December 2015 (EST)
 * A penny is different from a dime, which is different from a quarter, which is different from a dollar, and so on. They all add to the same pool, but they're all fundamentally different. The coins up there are different denominations for the Mushroom World's money.
 * The fact that they increase your coin total by different amounts is a large enough difference to keep them separate articles. We already have precedent with the Heart/3-Up Heart, not to mention all those giant enemies that otherwise act exactly the same as their normal counterparts. Niiue (talk) 21:03, 30 December 2015 (EST)
 * This might seem like a very silly example, but consider this for a moment. Let's say ladders are a reccuring element in the Mario series, and that most of them have 10 steps. Those are officially called "Ladders". However, in some games, Mario interact with some ladders which have 11 steps. And in other games, you can find ladders with 15 steps! Those ladders are different, but they are not given a name. In that hypothetical situation, would you be in favor of creating the articles and ? To me, the Coin situation is analogous to this one.  10:25, 31 December 2015 (EST)
 * That's not really a perfect analogy, though. A better analogy is something like the Heart/3-Up Heart example from earlier. They're the same (e.g. HP-refilling hearts), except one's bigger and refills more HP. And imo, two items giving you different amounts of [whatever] is a more significant difference than two ladders with different amounts of steps (that's veering into the direction of splitting Koopas/Shy Guys/etc by color). Niiue (talk) 10:49, 31 December 2015 (EST)
 * Then again, Green and Red Koopas often have different AI. Yet it'd be silly to split them. 11:25, 31 December 2015 (EST)
 * They're interchangeable in other appearances, so again, not a fair comparison. - 11:50, 31 December 2015 (EST)

Consider that Giant enemies have different names and they're supposed to be different enemies. I don't think it's a fair comparison. As for the 3-Up Heart, I agree it's the same situation, but I don't think that's a solid counter-argument. Although I acknowledge that my proposal could have benefited from more research and that it's not complete, if it passed, then we would have to merge both Heart articles. I mean, we both agree it's the same situation, but neither side can use this as an argument. "It's how we've done it in the past" isn't a good enough argument. 12:05, 31 December 2015 (EST)

Opposers: so, should we split Smash Coin into four articles (Bronze Smash Coin, Silver Smash Coin, Gold Smash Coin, Smash Bill)? I'm not implying that your reasons are invalid, but I like to bring up a very close parallel here and see how you'd deal with it. 16:03, 31 December 2015 (EST)
 * And what about Gold Bar x 3? 13:54, 2 January 2016 (EST)
 * Or the three kinds of Extra Life Balloons? 17:27, 2 January 2016 (EST)
 * Gold Bar x3 should probably be split, imo. Niiue (talk) 20:12, 2 January 2016 (EST)

@Wildgoosespeeder: Red and blue coins still have their own articles, though. Niiue (talk) 20:12, 2 January 2016 (EST)


 * I'd also agree with splitting Gold Bar x3. As for the Smash Coins, afaik, they don't have specific official names for each coin type, so there's less impetus to split them (like how every item in Food isn't named and doesn't deserve a separate article because overkill), but one could argue to make a specific Smash Bill page. As for Extra Life Balloons, there already are separate pages for the DKCR Green and Blue Balloons, and while they have different functions from Extra Life Balloons, I think it would be worth noting the original DKC trilogy's life-granting features of those colours of balloons on those articles as well as the one central page. - 12:48, 4 January 2016 (EST)