Talk:Big Ninji

Merge into Ninji or make article
(Wasn't sure which talk page to put this on, I'm sorry if someone thinks this is in the wrong place)

I have noticed that while the giant Ninji has a seperate article, the giant Shy Guy variety from Super Mario Advance is only mentioned in the Shy Guy article. Since a giant Ninji is no more different from a Ninji than a giant Shy Guy is from a Shy Guy, I propose to either merge this into Ninji or make a seperate article for the giant Shy Guy to achieve some uniformness.

(NOTE: The "Giant Shy Guy" title is just an example, based on this article's title; I don't know if "Giant ..." is the official name, or if there is an official name, but if no official name is known, I figured it would work well as a conjectural placeholder title.)

Proposer: Deadline: 21 January, 2010, 17:00

Merge Giant Ninji with Ninji

 * 1) -- It is more efficient to have both on the same page.
 * 2) We merged Mega Urchin to Urchin, so why not this?
 * 3) Per all.
 * 4) I am Zero! Giant Ninji only appeared in one game (not includeing its remakes) and there is not that much difference beside there size, merging will be a good idea . Zero signing out.

Seperate Giant Shy Guy from Shy Guy

 * 1) We have a giant everything else, so let's be consistent.
 * 2) Both are considered two different species, therefore they both get different articles. And like Reversinator said, we have giant everything else, even Mario and Mega Mario.
 * 3) Per Reversinator.

Comments
Well we do have a number of articles based on "Giant" versions of enemies/characters/items/etc., e.g. Giant Bowser, Giant Donkey Kong, Grand Goomba, Giant Bob-omb, Giant Blue Shell, Giant Banana, even Giant Kirby, Giant Yoshi Egg, Giant Spear Man, Giant Red Shell, Giant ? Block, Giant ! Block, Gargantua Koopa Troopa, etc, etc. --
 * All right, all right, that's enough giant stuff. Anyways, I think that shows that Giant Shy Guy should be made.


 * I think that Giant Bob-omb, Giant Blue Shell, Giant Red Shell, Giant ? Block, and Giant ! Block should be merged into their respective article because most are stubs and are just giant versions of their smaller counterparts, nothing different.--

@Zero: That's a really bad reason. There are numerous sub-species of enemies that have only appeared in one game, like Headbonk Goomba.