Paper Mario: Sticker Star

Paper Mario: Sticker Star (known as Paper Mario: Super Seal in Japan) is a RPG for the Nintendo 3DS developed by Intelligent Systems. As the fourth installment in the Paper Mario series, it is the first Paper Mario title to be released for a handheld console.

Storyline
The story starts during the night of the annual holiday, the Sticker Fest, where the citizens come to witness the Sticker Comet fly by in the sky. It is said that the Sticker Comet will make everyone's wishes come true. Princess Peach, on stage, shows the audience (which consists of Mario and a myriad of Toads) the comet as it floats down to the scene. Suddenly, Bowser and his troops appear and crash the festivities. Out of want for the comet, Bowser decides to take it as his own. Three Toads attempt to pull Bowser away but inadvertently have him crash into the Sticker Comet, breaking it into six pieces and sprawling them across the Mushroom Kingdom. One of them happens to fall on Bowser’s head making him more powerful, and unleashing a tornado which scares away the Toads. A furious Mario tries to attack him, but is overpowered and later wakes up with the Sticker Fest in a disaster: Toads have been stuck everywhere by Bowser, and the Princess missing. After regaining conciousness, Mario meets Kersti, a sticker fairy and the caretaker of the Royal Stickers. After a conversation with her, Mario then suggests that he will help her get the Royal Stickers back, and Kersti finally agrees with him and gives him a Sticker Album.

Mario starts by freeing the Toads affixed in tape placed by Bowser in the damaged festival, gaining a hammer in the process. Mario heads to the main town, Decalburg. After liberating the Toads, Mario heads towards the plaza east of town and discovers the area rolled up. The Toads, led by one Green Toad, together push to unroll the Plaza and bring it back to normal, accidentally trapping the Green Toad under the fountain in the process. As Mario leaves the town, he gets ambushed by a trio of Goombas. Kersti uses the opportunity to explain how battling foes with stickers work and Mario manages to defeat them, causing the trio of Goombas to flee.

World 1
Mario then starts his travels through the grasslands and across mountains, fighting many foes. In the Warm Fuzzy Plains, Mario and Kersti meet a group of Toads hunting for stickers. They stumbled onto one Toad who dropped a rare Scissors sticker and quickly flees before warning them about Bowser Jr. As true to his word, Bowser Jr. arrives in his Clown Car and demands that they give up the sticker. Mario manages to defeat him using the Scissors sticker but infuriated that he is not get the sticker, Bowser Jr. tears up the bridge and throws the bridge up onto a high ledge Mario cannot jump onto.

Mario and Kersti get help from the group of Toads, who form stairs for them to walk onto the ledge. When Mario obtains the broken bridge, Kersti teaches Mario the ability to paperize. After passing through the plains, they reach the Bouquet Gardens, where they find a flower garden's contents to be ruined by a strong wind. The source of the wind turns out to be a fan and Mario turns it off and obtains it. They are now able to pass through the garden, helping a Toad with his ruined flowers and a Toad traveler attacked by Goombas if they choose to do so, but get attacked by five Goombas, who make a dramatic entrance in the form of a Goomba Tower and a wheel. Seeing the higher amount of enemies than usual, Kersti explains the Battle Spinner for Mario and afterwards, the five Goombas concede.

In Water's Edge Way, Mario and Kersti bump into the same Toad who found the Scissors sticker and drops an Album Page for the Sticker Album. After the Toad flees, Mario and Kersti meet Kamek, who proceeds to be defeated in battle. In anger of his loss, Kamek uses paperization to toss away the Sticker Comet, making it impossible to proceed. Eventually, Mario and Kersti find the Sticker Comet and via a passageway through a windmill or Whammino Mountain, they eventually arrive at Goomba's Fortress, where the first Royal Sticker is being held. Mario travels through the fortress, but his presence is alerted by a Goomba who uses a trumpet to wake up nearby Bob-ombs. Passing through the Para Bob-ombs and Goombas, Mario reaches the top where he and Kersti confront a corrupted Goomba and his Goomba minions. During the battle, the corrupted Goomba and his minions form into Megasparkle Goomba, a giant Goomba. Eventually, Mario defeats them and obtains the first Royal Sticker.

World 2
Continuing into the desert, Mario discovers at Drybake Stadium that the three tablet pieces must be obtained in order to advance. At the location of the piece hidden at Yoshi Sphinx, before Mario could get it, he faces Kamek again; this time, however, Kamek converts all of Mario's stickers into Flip-Flop Stickers. The other tablet pieces are uncovered at Damp Oasis, where a Vacuum is used to remove the sandstorm, and Drybake Desert. After restoring Drybake Stadium, Mario faces Tower Power Pokey, the guardian of the second Royal Sticker, at the top. By defeating him, Mario and Kersti recover the second of the Royal Stickers.

World 3
The next location is a forest. Here, however, a massive Wiggler is encountered, blocking the entrance. After he is awakened by Mario, Wiggler says that he was looking for food, due to the entire forest being polluted by poison. Outraged, Kersti decides to help Wiggler. However, as they advance deeper into the forest, Wiggler is snatched by a flashy-looking tentacle. When Mario and Kersti arrive at Wiggler's Tree House, they find that Wiggler has been reduced to a head; Wiggler reveals that he was broken into five segments by Kamek's magic, so it is up to Mario and Kersti to track down the other four segments. After Mario and Kersti reattach him, Wiggler decides to help them by transporting them to a nearby island where the pollution is being created. At this island, it is shown that Gooper Blooper is the cause of the poison in the forest. After defeating the Blooper, the forest is reverted to its normal state and the poison is removed.

Mario and Kersti cannot continue on, however, because to reach the other continent requires a boat. At Surfshine Harbor they find a boat, but it is broken. Inside the warehouse, they find the ship's wheel, and must use the Scissors to cut the rope connecting it to the dock. However, even after this, they still cannot set sail, as a massive Cheep-Cheep attacks the ship. After defeating this creature, Mario is able to use the boat to sail to the next area.

World 4
The world they arrive at next is a snow-covered area. In this world, they come across The Enigmansion, where Mario must seal all 100 escaped Boos inside the Book of Sealing. Kamek reveals that he had originally unsealed the book, he frees the Boos once again, this time merging into a single Big Boo. After defeating it, all the Boos are finally laid to rest in the book. Later, Mario and Kersti reach the attraction-like Bowser's Snow Fort. Here, Mario faces the Bowser Snow Statue, allowing him to obtain the fourth Royal Sticker. Yet, by leaving the area, Mario is intercepted by Bowser Jr., who notices that he once again has rare stickers and wishes to face him again. By defeating him again, Bowser Jr. retreats once more, returning to his father's castle.

World 5
At the next world, Mario and Kersti travel through a forested area, challenging forest enemies, going on a raft, seeing the Travelling Toad again, and getting chased by a massive cardboard Cheep Chomp. This is followed by Chomp Ruins, where Mario has to battle a massive Chain Chomp, afterwards is a more volcanic area. At Rumble Volcano, it is discovered that the guardian of the next Royal Sticker is Petey Piranha, who eats Kersti. After reaching and defeating Petey, Mario is able to both free Kersti and retrieve the fifth Royal Sticker.

World 6
Arriving at the Gate Cliff, the five Royal Stickers that Mario and Kersti have collected begin to react. As Mario places them on the wall, the prophecy stated in the book at the Enigmansion comes true, as Mario is able to paperize the wall and flip it, allowing access Bowser's castle. The castle immediately flies into the air, out of Mario's reach. With no way to fly, Mario and Kersti are forced to return to the mainland. But upon hearing mention of a creature flying over the forest and by heading to Wiggler's house, they find out Wiggler has grown up into Flutter. Wanting to repay Mario and Kersti for restoring the forest, Wiggler flies the pair up to Bowser Jr.'s Flotilla. Here, Mario defeats Bowser Jr. for the final time, and is able to reach Bowser's Sky Castle.

At the castle, Mario again faces and defeats Kamek. With him out of the way, Mario is able to continue on to Bowser. At the final area of the castle, Mario and Kersti find Princess Peach, taped to a chain, though Bowser appears before they are able to free her. During their final showdown, Bowser is defeated, and he falls down into a pit with the Royal Sticker. However, he emerges seconds later as a massive cardboard version of himself. With any attack dealing little damage to him, Kersti powers-up Mario to face him by sacrificing herself, apologizing for all the hassle she has caused him. With this power boost, Mario defeats Bowser, thus releasing him from the Royal Sticker's control and incapacitating him. Mario frees Peach, who says that the stickers are meant to be used for good and not evil. Mario uses the Royal Stickers to return everything to normal. After Peach congratulates Mario and the rest of the kingdom for their success, Bowser attempts to steal the Royal Stickers again, only for a revived Kersti to intervene. She jokes that she wants to change her career, and Mario, Peach, and Bowser laugh.

Gameplay
After forgoing the classic battle system in favor of a sidescrolling platformer-style system in Super Paper Mario, Paper Mario: Sticker Star returns to the turn-based system from the first two installments. However, players have to gather stickers, which are necessary both for solving puzzles and gaining battle commands. Stickers are a major part of the gameplay and storyline. Some real-world objects (called Things) appear in the form of stickers, and they also have the ability to be used to attack and overcome obstacles. Instead of levelling up from experience points as in the previous installments, Mario must find HP-Up Hearts, which each increase his current HP by 5. Stickers replace Badges from the first two installments of the series. A new feature is the "Battle Spinner" slot machine which allows Mario to attack with multiple stickers in one turn, gain coins, or cause a different event to occur, depending on the combination received. .

In addition, the gameplay places a lot more emphasis on the "paper" aspect than the previous games, containing status elements directly related to paper materials such as "soggy," "clipped," or "tacked;" additionally, the enemies sometimes transform themselves to better reflect the papery nature of their designs (eg, a Goomba occasionally becoming a cone Goomba), transform as part of an attack (eg, the Koopa Troopas), or simply resemble paper to begin with (eg, the Big Boo fought in World 4-3). Many characters actively refer to themselves as existing within a paper world, most notably Kersti. The world's environments also resemble craft materials like cardboard.

Although the player grows stronger as the game progresses, there isn't an explicit level up gameplay mechanic, unlike the other RPG games or even Super Paper Mario. In addition, beyond a certain point, the player can also effectively skip battles by jumping on or hammering enemies of a certain HP range (like Goombas by World 3), instantly defeating them.

Stickers
Stickers are the only items to appear in Sticker Star. They serve as the only method of attack, items to solve puzzles, and the like. Stickers can be found anywhere in levels, being stuck across the environment and inside blocks, and can also be purchased in shops. Any stickers collected are stored in the album.

Types of stickers
There are many types of stickers, but the two main types are Jump stickers and Hammer stickers. Jump stickers include Jump, Hopslipper, Line Jump, and Iron Jump. Most Jump stickers can attack all enemies that are not spiked or have some other hazard on top of them. Hammer stickers include Hammer, Eekhammer, Slaphammer, and Hurlhammer. Most of them can hit all enemies except ones that wield wings, Spear Guys when holding their spear horizontally, or some other type of flying device, such as Kamek's broom.

There are also stickers that support Mario in battle, such as Spike Helmets that give Mario a helmet that damages all enemies that attack him from above. Also in this category are Mushrooms that heal Mario and Leaf stickers that execute all action commands perfectly for one turn.

Other types of attack stickers include Fire Flower and Ice Flower stickers that burn and freeze enemies, respectively. Certain enemies also occasionally drop stickers that represent their weapons - for example, Sombrero Guys occasionally drop Sombrero stickers, and Bob-ombs drop Bomb stickers.

There are 2 special stickers that only appear in battle and then disappear when the battle is finished. Kamek turns all of Mario's stickers into Flip-flop stickers during the Kamek battles in World 2-2 and 6-3. Flip-flop stickers are similar to Eekhammers because they strike multiple times in a hammer-like fashion. Flip-flop stickers also retain their power status, i.e. a Shiny Jump sticker is a Shiny Flip-flop, a Megaflash Slaphammer is a Megaflash Flip-flop, etc. Flip-flops of the same size will appear the same, even if it is Shiny or Flashy. Once Flip-flops are used, they are gone from the sticker book, meaning that the player cannot get that sticker back once the battle is completed and their inventory is returned to normal.

The second sticker of this kind is none other than Kersti, who will enter Mario's sticker book during the final stage of the Bowser battle. She will activate the Battle Spinner and will automatically give Mario a whopping five slots for stickers per turn. Even though Kersti will disappear from the sticker book once used, Mario wishes her to be alive again, so he can still Paperize and talk to Kersti after the battle.

Although neither sticker can be tossed or sold in shops, selling Kersti is mentioned twice in the game: entering Decalburg's shop for the first time, and right before Kersti enters Mario's sticker book when battling Bowser. Also, if Mario is able to overpower Bowser without using the Kersti sticker, he is able to toss Kersti away. However, this action does not alter the storyline.

Finally, there are Secret Door stickers that Mario is able to paste onto the environment via the Paperize ability. These doors reveal secret underground rooms containing rare stickers and/or Things that are usually not used for storyline purposes, such as a Thumbtack and a Squirt Gun.

Sticker traits
Every single sticker except Thing stickers sometimes have special traits applied to them, such as "Shiny", "Flashy", and "Big". These stickers usually sparkle in Mario's Sticker Album and do more damage than usual to enemies. Stickers that have traits like "Big" and "Megaflash" take up more space in the album, not unlike Secret Door and certain Thing stickers. Typically, stickers wielding special traits are rarer than normal stickers. Battle Stickers and Thing Stickers come in three sizes: Small (4 Spaces), Medium (9 Spaces), and Large (16 Spaces).

Protagonists

 * Mario
 * Kersti

Allies

 * Toads
 * Traveling Toad
 * Shady Toad
 * Sling-a-Thing Toad
 * Mansion Steward
 * Mansion Forebear
 * Museum Curator
 * Oasis Toad
 * Luigi (5 cameos)
 * Birdo
 * Wiggler/Flutter
 * Princess Peach

Followers
These allies temporarily join Mario's party and follow him around until they are taken to a certain location, where they perform an action or advance the storyline. In the Wiggler Segment's case, they must tire out before they join Mario and go back to Wiggler's Tree House.
 * A stack of Toads
 * Green Toad
 * Wiggler Segments

Obstacles

 * Bowser Tape
 * Cheep Chomp
 * Lakitu
 * Cooligan
 * Bomp
 * Podoboo
 * Fishbone

Bosses (in order)
Highlights signify world bosses.

Locations
Unlike previous installments, the game has a level progression system. Each level course is unlocked after collecting a Comet Piece in the preceding area. The map is reminiscent of the one used in Super Mario RPG, though it is more open-ended and not linear. Many levels contain alternate exits that lead to other levels, and the goal of entering a level is not always to "finish" it by touching the Comet Stickers.


 * Decalburg
 * World 1, both the grassy plains and the high stone moutains, containing 6 levels. The main boss of this world is Megasparkle Goomba:
 * W1-1: Warm Fuzzy Plains
 * W1-2: Bouquet Gardens
 * W1-3: Water's Edge Way
 * W1-4: Hither Thither Hill
 * W1-5: Whammino Mountain
 * W1-6: Goomba's Fortress
 * World 2, A desert with pyramids, containing 5 levels. The main boss of this world is Tower Power Pokey:
 * W2-1: Drybake Desert
 * W2-2: Yoshi Sphinx
 * W2-3: Sandshifter Ruins
 * W2-4: Damp Oasis
 * W2-5: Drybake Stadium
 * World 3, A dark and dense forest area, containing 12 levels. When Mario first arrives, the area is covered in poisonous goop. The main boss of this world is Gooper Blooper:
 * W3-1: Leaflitter Path
 * W3-2: The Bafflewood
 * W3-3: Wiggler's Tree House
 * W3-4: Strike Lake
 * W3-5: Loop Loop River
 * W3-6: Outlook Point
 * W3-7: Rustle Burrow
 * W3-8: Tree Branch Trail
 * W3-9: Gauntlet Pond
 * W3-10: Stump Glade
 * W3-11: Holey Thicket
 * W3-12: Whitecap Beach
 * Surfshine Harbor
 * World 4, a snowy plains, containing 6 levels. The main boss of this world is Mizzter Blizzard:
 * W4-1: Snow Rise
 * W4-2: Ice Flow
 * W4-3: The Enigmansion
 * W4-4: Shaved-Ice Cave
 * W4-5: Whiteout Valley
 * W4-6: Bowser's Snow Fort
 * World 5, a thick jungle and volcano area, containing 6 levels. The main boss of this world is Petey Piranha:
 * W5-1: Shy Guy Jungle
 * W5-2: Jungle Rapids
 * W5-3: Long Fall Falls
 * W5-4: Chomp Ruins
 * W5-5: Rugged Road
 * W5-6: Rumble Volcano
 * World 6, the final world of the game, taking place in the sky. There are 3 levels, one being Bowser's Castle, where the final battle against Bowser takes place:
 * W6-1: Gate Cliff
 * W6-2: Bowser Jr.'s Flotilla
 * W6-3: Bowser's Sky Castle

Nintendo eShop description
''When an accident scatters stickers across the land, Mario sets off on an adventure to repair a torn world. Searching Forests, Deserts and Mountains, Mario collects stickers to solve puzzles and battle monsters. In a first for the series, there are no experience points, so finding power-ups to improve Mario's abilities is more important than ever. Mixing sticker-based gameplay elements with the traditional action-battle system of the Paper Mario series delivers a new twist on a classic franchise. Flatten-out characters, roll out towns, and walk through living, breathing dioramas in a brand-new Paper Mario adventure on the Nintendo 3DS system!''

Similarities to other Paper Mario games

 * Bowser once again becomes invincible with one of the game's key objects, much like the first game.
 * The first chapter takes place in a grassland, and once again contains a boss that's fought in a castle/fortress-like setting.
 * The second chapter takes place within a desert, as with the first game.
 * The third chapter contains a darkened forest area, much like Forever Forest in Paper Mario.
 * Additionally, The Bafflewood contains similar maze/puzzle elements.
 * A giant Blooper is fought in this game, as with the previous three installments.
 * The fourth chapter contains a multitude of Shy Guys, as with the first installment.
 * The fifth world takes place within a tropical locale, just like Paper Mario and Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door.
 * This world also has a cave or volcanic setting, much like the previous games.
 * A plant-themed boss is fought in this world/chapter, as with the first game and Super Paper Mario.
 * A parade takes place during the ending, just like the first Paper Mario.
 * Similar to the original game, there is no post-game content (though a Green Toad will appear on the festival grounds)
 * Therefore, the final boss can be fought again.
 * A story epilogue occurs after each chapter is completed.
 * Adding onto the above, all four installments contain rhyming dialogue in some way, shape, or form.

Differences from other Paper Mario games

 * This is the first Paper Mario title released for a handheld console.
 * Paper Mario: Sticker Star is the first Paper Mario game to not start at Mario's House, nor feature this place at all.
 * Unlike the first two Paper Mario games which have a turn-based battle system, Sticker Star does not have Flower Points, Star Points, Experience Points, Badges, or Items. Mario also has no partners to battle by his side (with the exception of Kersti at some points).
 * This is the only game in the Paper Mario series where Lady Bow does not make an appearance in any form.
 * Mario does not level up from battling as in previous Paper Mario games.
 * All the bosses in Sticker Star are not unique to the Paper Mario series, as they are all more powerful versions of preexisting enemies or bosses featured in other Mario games. Similarly, the game does not feature any new enemies, only enemies from other Mario games and new variants thereof.
 * Kamek takes on the role filled by Kammy Koopa in the first two Paper Mario games.
 * This is the first Paper Mario game where Bowser and Luigi have no lines of dialogue.
 * The world map is now used to get to other locations, unlike the other installments. Also, the map does not have a description of each location.
 * Unlike Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door and Super Paper Mario, the game does not feature an Audience.
 * While Mario does possess a hammer given to him by a Toad, he cannot use it in-battle without consuming a hammer sticker, but only as a way to get a First Strike, unlike the first two installments.
 * Mario also doesn't get the Super Hammer or the Ultra Hammer later in the game, due to the various Hammer stickers.
 * This is the first Paper Mario game that is not split into separate chapters, instead opting to use worlds, like Super Mario RPG. If it were, there would only be 6 chapters, whereas the first three installments all possessed 8 chapters.
 * Paper Mario: Sticker Star only has 55 enemies and 18 bosses, for a total of 73 different enemies; each of the first three installments had over 100 enemies.
 * Unlike the first three installments, Paper Mario: Sticker Star has two counterparts to Jr. Troopa, Lord Crump, and O'Chunks, instead of one, since Bowser Jr. and Kamek are fought three times each (not including four Wiggler Segments who are each fought once).
 * Unlike Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door and Super Paper Mario, Mario does not have any voice clips recorded by Charles Martinet in Paper Mario: Sticker Star.
 * Paper Mario: Sticker Star doesn't have a superboss (a boss that can be fought after the final main boss, and generally has higher stats).
 * This is the first Paper Mario game not to include enemy Tattles, recipes, Clubbas, Koopatrols, Crazy Dayzees, Amazy Dayzees, Gloombas, Frost Piranhas, Putrid Piranhas, Clefts, the Merlon clan, or Whacka. This is because Shigeru Miyamoto did not want characters exclusive to the Paper Mario series in the game, besides Kersti.
 * On a related note, it is also the first game where enemy Koopas do not possess eyewear of any sort.
 * Due to the lack of a Tattle ability, several aspects of it have been incorporated into regular battle. For example, an HP bar showing the collective health of all enemies on screen displays during battle. The enemies' names are also all displayed while Mario is choosing stickers, similar to the Mario & Luigi series.
 * This is the first in the series to have only one playable character. Moreover, it's the only one to not feature Peach as a playable character. Peach's role in this game is also significantly less vital than the first three.
 * It is the first Paper Mario where Mario can't turn into an 8-bit version of himself.
 * Ninjis in Paper Mario: Sticker Star are now actual enemies. In their previous appearance in Paper Mario, they were friendly NPCs who acted as caretakers for the Star Kids.
 * Other than Wiggler, Toads are the only friendly NPCs in Sticker Star; there are no friendly Goombas, Koopas, Bob-ombs, or other enemies. However, a Koopa does volunteer for Mario to use for the shell attack stickers, as does a Bob-omb for the bomb attack sticker.
 * Mario can't choose which enemy to attack if there are multiple ones; he defaults to the one in front.
 * Unlike the first 3 installments, Mario starts his journey with 20 HP.
 * When Mario's current HP is at most 30% of its total, the in-battle music changes to a "tired" remix of itself, replacing the alarm sound heard in the other Paper Mario games while being in critical health conditions.
 * Unlike the first 3 installments, Paper Mario: Sticker Star only has 3 save files instead of 4.
 * The game does not feature an opening story before the title screen as the other Paper Mario games; the opening story is instead shown when starting a new game.
 * This is the first Paper Mario installment since the original N64 installment to lack an endless play feature.
 * This is the only installment to not feature the main antagonist on the box art.
 * Due to this being a handheld game, this is the only installment in the Paper Mario series not to be playable on the Wii, as Paper Mario can be played on the Virtual Console, its sequel is playable due to GameCube backwards compatibility, and Super Paper Mario is a Wii game.
 * This is the only game in the Paper Mario series to have the maximum number of coins be 9,999 instead of 999.

Development
Paper Mario: Sticker Star started development at the end of 2009. The development team thought Paper Mario was a good fit for the 3DS and initially developed it as a RPG making use of the 3DS's stereoscopic display. After E3 2010, a demo of this build was previewed to Shigeru Miyamoto, who was reportedly unimpressed, dismissing it as "just a port of the GC version".

Miyamoto requested the development team to "make a big change". Said development team was mostly composed of developers new to Paper Mario (planning and design staff being "about 90%" new, according to Kenji Nakajima"), with a few veterans brought in to help with the usage of old assets . Naohiko Aoyama, who conceived the original Paper Mario's visual direction but had little involvement with its sequels, was brought in as the director.

Following Miyamoto's impression, the development team brainstormed ideas to make the game stand out. It was eventually decided to expand the Sticker mechanic, which had initially being designed for use in puzzles, and expand it to the rest of the game. As the sticker system expanded, the development team decided to abandon the partner system and traditional RPG elements such as an experience point system, with progression instead being outlined by the player getting progressively stronger stickers.

Early in development, Miyamoto also encouraged the developers to keep the story to a minimum and only use pre-established Mario characters. The decision to not focus on the storyline was also influenced by Super Paper Mario's Club Nintendo survey, which had less than 1% of the respondents citing its plotline as a strong point. Producer Kensuke Tanabe also asked the team to focus on the "paper" aspect of the visuals.

Reception
Paper Mario: Sticker Star has received generally positive reviews, gaining an average of 75.97% based on forty-nine reviews on GameRankings and 75 based on sixty-nine reviews on Metacritic. .

Cam Shea of IGN gave the game an 8.3, praising the fresh take on the Paper Mario series, the charming design, and the sense of humor, but criticized the sticker system for not working and some frustrating design elements. He wrote, "In spite of all my criticisms, Sticker Star is still compelling to play and a great deal of fun. The game’s infectious spirit and sense of humour is irresistible, and it’s big, too – you’re not beating this one in a weekend. It’s just a shame that putting stickers at the heart of the game didn’t turn out to be the master-stroke it so readily could have been. Paper Mario fans will enjoy Sticker Star, but ultimately it’s just as notable for its failures as its successes." Edge Magazine UK gave the game an 8, praising Intelligent Systems's effort to shape its RPG for portable play. Destructoid gave the game an 8/10 praised the game for the impressive effort but warned that the game will disappoint previous Paper Mario fans. Mike Wehner of The Escapist gave the game 4.5 stars out of 5, praising the game for its artistic style and its perfect gameplay while criticizing the frustrating puzzles. He wrote as the bottom line, "There's just no getting around it: Paper Mario: Sticker Star is yet another high-quality entry into Nintendo's cherished library of first party titles. The experience is high on satisfaction and low on frustration, making it an undeniably perfect fit for the company's mobile console. It's not entirely flawless, but as Mario games go, it's one of the best."

JC Fletcher of Joystick gave the game 3.5 out of 5 stars. He praised the easygoing funny nature of the game but criticized the frustrating game design, saying that the existence of FAQs will improve the game and sacrificing turn-based battles with awkward platforming. Carolyn Petit of Gamespot gave the game a 7.5 out of 10. She praised the smart and witty writing, the good puzzles, and the overall charm of the game, but criticized the frustration of getting stuck and the seemingly pointless combat system. She ended with, "Sticker Star falls into a rut at times and may even drive you crazy, but in the end, Paper Mario's unwaveringly cheerful attitude, and fond memories of the game's many great moments, will be what stays with you."

However, GameXplain were more critical on the game, giving it a score of two stars out of five. They criticised the story as "one of the biggest and most unfortunate changes" and the puzzles, by saying that "the things you need [to solve them] could be found anywhere" and "the game provides no clues on where to find them". They also said that the battle system is "fresh and fun at first" but then started criticising it, saying that there is "no sense of accomplishment after winning a battle", and ultimately referring to the combat as a "chore". However, they did praise the game for "trying some new things" and for its "flashes of typical Paper Mario brilliance".

References to other games

 * Super Mario Bros.: Part of the overworld theme can be heard in the Warm Fuzzy Plains theme (along with a remix of said theme that plays when Gooper Blooper is poisoned during his fight), as well as in the game's credits. Also, a baseball-styled rendition of the "Course Clear" theme from this game can be heard when Mario uses a battering Thing sticker.
 * Super Mario Bros. 2: Shy Guys, Snifits, Pokeys and Ninjis, which were introduced in this game, appear in this game. Some Pokeys are designed like their first appearance from this game as well. The main theme is a jazzy version of the credits theme.
 * Super Mario Bros. 3: The Goomba's Shoe, Super Leaf and Frog Suit return directly from this game, now as stickers. An Airship also appears. The athletic overworld theme is remixed for the ski lift ride in 4-5. The Clone Jump sticker resembles Kuribo's Shoe. Also, the King's theme is remixed for the afterward to a Royal Sticker boss battle in Sticker Star.
 * Super Mario World: Portions of the music inside the Enigmansion, along with the music played when talking to the owner while he waits outside, are remixed from the Ghost House theme.
 * Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island: During the very final battle phase with Bowser, a portion of the music that plays is based on the Superstar Mario theme from this game.
 * Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars: The beginning of Paper Mario: Sticker Star has a cosmic object being shattered into pieces, and the main character has to retrieve the pieces of the object, similar to this game. In addition, the main bad guys are implied to have left at least one of the pieces to be guarded by a monster, similar to Smithy's Gang. When walking down the hallway in Bowser's Sky Castle, the camera is in an angled position that is similar to the camera position in this game. Lastly, during the final battle, Bowser uses a Chain Chomp as a weapon, much like he did in Super Mario RPG. Also, the parade in the end credits is similar to the one from this game.
 * Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins: The music played when using the Boom-Box is a snippet of the Space Zone theme from this game.
 * Super Mario 64: During the mine cart ride in World 4-6, a remix of The Princess's Secret Slide plays.
 * Paper Mario: Similar to the first Paper Mario, Bowser ends up becoming nigh-invincible from a magical wish-granting object. In this case, however, it was purely by accident. Also, in both games' climax, Mario confronts Bowser at a flying castle, and Bowser also ends up growing larger in a last ditch effort to beat Mario after his initial invincibility was temporarily disabled, also significantly bolstering his invincibility to be absolute. The game ends with a parade, much like this game. Enemies like Spear Guys and Ninjis make their re-appearance in the series since this game. Also, a letter written by Parakarry may be found in Shy Guy Jungle in the garbage before Mario uses the vacuum item. Mario's design and expressions are more based off him in this game, as well as the scenery. If the worlds in Sticker Star are completed in numerical order, the boss of the fifth "chapter," as in Paper Mario, is a Piranha Plant fought inside a volcano. Additionally, a slight remix of the Dry Dry Ruins theme (combined with the Super Mario Bros. underworld song) can be heard in the cavern of World 2-1.
 * Mario Kart: Super Circuit: The Yoshi Sphinx in this game is similar to the one found in the background of Yoshi Desert.
 * Super Mario Sunshine: Gooper Blooper and Petey Piranha, which made their first and main appearances in this game, return. Also, one of the questions Snifit or Whiffit afirm that Princess Peach is Bowser Jr.'s mother, possibly referencing the story of Super Mario Sunshine.
 * Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door: Searching the dump in Shy Guy Jungle before using the Goat or the Vacuum reveals a memo from Goombella, who is apparently still attending University of Goom and doing research on the Chomp Ruins during the events of the game, but is never seen. The miniboss theme is a remix of this game's. Mario's expression when first seeing a Boo is the same as Doopliss' when his name is guessed. Also, the outline of this game's logo is used in the "Paper Mario" part of the Sticker Star logo.
 * Super Paper Mario: At the beginning of the game, after Mario saves one of the Toads in Decalburg, the latter will say that Bowser crumpled him up 256 times, which is a nod to the running joke in Super Paper Mario, starting with Dimentio claiming that Dimension D makes his attacks "256 times more powerful", followed by Flint Cragley's camera crew stating that the "Rainbowzilla" story was apparently told that amount of times. This number is also the number of cards in the game.
 * Super Mario Galaxy: Portions of the music inside the Enigmansion are remixed from the Ghostly Galaxy theme.
 * New Super Mario Bros. Wii: Some of the enemies, such as Ice Bros. and Scaredy Rats that appeared in this game return in this game. Most of the enemies and the areas are also designed from their appearances from this game. The Big Buzzy Beetle was a beta element from New Super Mario Bros. Wii.
 * Super Mario 3D Land: The Poison Mushroom has the same design as in this game. Also, one part of the title screen music sounds like the beginning of Special 2-1's music from this game. Some of the designs, such as the trees in World 7, are reused in this game.

References in later games

 * New Super Mario Bros. U: The Big Buzzy Beetle who debuts in Paper Mario: Sticker Star reappears as a species in New Super Mario Bros. U, although it was a beta element in New Super Mario Bros. Wii. Also, Bony Beetle has the same design as in this game and Bowser Jr. uses the same glass dome in his Koopa Clown Car.
 * Mario & Luigi: Dream Team: The Snifit or Whiffit quiz show has the same ✔ and ✘ blocks as to the ✔ and ✘ panels in the Check-X Quiz in this game.

Glitches
In Yoshi Sphinx, if the player hits a Koopa Paratroopa and a wall at the same time after the fight with the Koopa Paratroopa with wall will push Mario through the floor and give the player a game over.

Beta elements
Originally, Bowser's Sky Castle was meant to have minigames, but due to development time restraints it was cut. Pre-release screenshots also showed a Chain Chomp partner as well as a Monty Mole boss, though both were removed from the final game.

Staff
The game was directed by Naohiko Aoyama and produced by Kensuke Tanabe and Toshiyuki Nakamura, with Satoru Iwata serving as the executive producer.

Trivia

 * Whenever a new character is introduced, the game pauses to show the player their name, similar to Super Smash Bros. Brawl.
 * From its release for download onto the Nintendo eShop until January 6, 2013, Club Nintendo members in North America who downloaded Paper Mario: Sticker Star and registered it on Club Nintendo also received Donkey Kong: Original Edition for free.
 * The in-game manual for the game states that Mario can also get a Game Over if he falls off a course. However, there is no way to fall off a course without the use of glitches.
 * All the bosses except for Bowser says "Shiny" at least once.
 * No matter how many enemies are beaten, the maximum coin bonus Mario can get at the end of a level is 300.