Talk:Wilt Shroom

Merge Wilt Shroom with Dried Shroom
Same Japanese name, same function, no significant differences other than amount of HP restored (and items have restored different amounts of HP between games before). And considering how much the Paper Mario series references Super Mario RPG, it'd make sense for these two items to be intended to be the same thing.

Proposer: Deadline: September 19, 2015, 23:59 GMT

Support

 * 1) Per proposal.
 * 2) Per proposal.
 * 3) Per all.

Oppose

 * 1) They have different names in English, both look completely different, and they restore different amounts of HP (which may not be all that relevant, but my other points still stand). I don't understand the logic of "Japanese names instantly make it the same thing", as if the English versions mean nothing.
 * 2) SYB has a good point. Per him.
 * 3) I don't see the point to merge these two articles, especially when their appearances and English names are different. If Super Mario RPG was a Paper Mario game, I'd lean toward a merge, but they're two different games by two different developers, despite Paper Mario's being a spiritual successor. The only similar cases I can find are Maple Syrup and Honey Syrup, but they share English names across the games, so they aren't great examples. Otherwise, there isn't a great precedent to cite here other than similar Japanese names (not a strong case) and loose assumptions of succession (not a strong case either), so I'm leery about a merge.
 * 4) The Dried Shroom is a common item found that is the weakest mushroom available. The Wilt Shroom is entirely a 'joke' prize given out by Knife & Grate, plus it has a companion in the Rotten Mush which Dried Shroom does not have. The argument is that two items share the same Japanese name. May I direct your attention to Mr. E (Paper Mario) and Mr. E (Mario Party Advance). Are they the same because they share the same english name? Things share names sometimes.
 * 5) Per Mario & Shadow2
 * 6) Different design and function. English names take priority anyway.
 * 7) So you want to merge two items made by different companies, with different functions, different appearances, and different English names? yeah no thanks per all.
 * 8) - While the Japanese name is the same, everything else is different, from the appearance to the effects to the fact that unlike Dried Shroom, the Wilt Shroom isn't the worst mushroom in its game, being surpassed by both the Rotten Mush and Moldy Mush (the latter of which has the same function as Dried Shroom - recovering 1 HP). Having a separate article makes more sense and is better for searches than bending over backwards to merge this harmless little page.
 * 9) Per everyone.

Comments
It's not that English names don't matter, but Japanese names have priority in these cases. And the fact that the HP recovered is different means nothing, as shown with Fresh Pasta Bunch.
 * It's not just the names (though they're still a good argument as to these being the same thing), but these also fill the same role (shriveled old mushroom that barely restores any HP), and the Paper Mario series is notably influenced by Super Mario RPG. Binarystep (talk) 06:44, 7 September 2015 (EDT)
 * Yeah, I know Paper Mario items change effects from time-to-time, and that this is even more likely since it's from Super Mario RPG to Paper Mario, which is why I wasn't sure if it was that good of a point. I still think the very different appearance counts for something. -- 11:20, 7 September 2015 (EDT)
 * Super Mario RPG has a pretty different artstyle than Paper Mario, though. Binarystep (talk) 20:10, 7 September 2015 (EDT)

@Shadow2 I don't see how one having a counterpart proves they're different. Honey Syrup in Super Mario RPG has Royal Syrup as a stronger variant, but the Paper Mario version doesn't, does that make them different? They even look different, Honey Syrup being red in Super Mario RPG and yellow in Paper Mario. Also, the Japanese names are the original names, while the English names are created by the translators (who don't create the games themselves). Binarystep (talk) 22:40, 7 September 2015 (EDT)

Would this be as contested if Woolsey kept the name Dried Shroom for the American release of Super Mario RPG? Because that seems to be the case with the Syrups. It's pretty much the same scenario otherwise. But why is it that some seem hung up on the fact that the English names are different? That really shouldn't matter if the Japanese names are the same. Sometimes there are translation errors. And sometimes a translator will deliberately change a few things to make it sound better. Since the translator was Ted Woolsey, who is the Trope Namer for the latter, it really could be either. Plus, the Paper Mario games carried several things over from Super Mario RPG, including Heart Points, Flower Points, and the Mushrooms and Syrups that refill them. There's no way this could just be a weird coincidence, considering the similarities of the two items. I think someone in the oppose section said something about looking into these things too much. Well not everything is just spelled out for us, unfortunately, and this is a fairly obvious conclusion. Maybe it's me, but I just don't see what else is holding us back from merging the articles. Someone brought up that the design was different and that the amount of HP healed was different, but those are dismissible, as A. Things change design all the time. It doesn't make them new; it just means they have a new design. And B. The change in points restored is changed occasionally, as I have already mentioned. I just can't think of any other reason to keep these articles separate.
 * Just throwing this out there, but doesn't the fact that Super Mario RPG and Paper Mario are made by different people actually help my case of these being the same item? It makes sense that Intelligent Systems would translate the item's name differently than Square. Binarystep (talk) 01:54, 8 September 2015 (EDT)
 * That's the problem, Magikrazy, you're making a lot of assumptions in this argument. Ted Woolsey possibly being wrong and very loose connections between Paper Mario and Super Mario RPG are not solid foundations to merge Wilt Shroom and Dried Shroom. Sure, the Japanese names are the same, but merging on Japanese name alone makes for an inconsistent and therefore poor precedent. Plus, as I've stated in my oppose, the most similar cases are the syrups, but those share English names. I would be more supportive of a merge if the English names were the same, but they weren't, and combined with the existence of Moldy Mush and Rotten Mush, I think it's best to keep articles separate for the sake of organization and consistency. 16:52, 8 September 2015 (EDT)
 * First of all, thanks for responding to my comment. You make some valid points, and I did make quite a bit of assumptions. I do still feel somewhat torn on this issue due to similar Japanese names and function, though. I'm torn on this issue, and I'll remove my vote.


 * Where would this leave Rotten Mush? Shadow2 (talk) 02:17, 8 September 2015 (EDT)
 * Rotten Mush is a seperate item altogether. It wouldn't be affected for the same reason Love Noodle Dish wasn't affected after the Fresh Pasta/Fresh Pasta Bunch merge. Binarystep (talk) 04:20, 8 September 2015 (EDT)
 * Just like Wilt Shroom is a seperate item altogether. Shadow2 (talk) 16:42, 8 September 2015 (EDT)
 * That's circular reasoning. Niiue (talk) 17:04, 8 September 2015 (EDT)
 * I just want to point out, unlike those examples you cited, Wilt Shroom and Dried Mushroom are from two different series. Paper Mario may have some nods to Super Mario RPG, but Super Mario RPG is more like a distant cousin. If Wilt Shroom and Dried Mushroom were in the same series, and if Rotten Mush and Moldy Mush didn't exist in tandem, it would be a stronger case for a merge, something I'd might support. But none of them are true, which is why I myself don't want it split. 23:48, 9 September 2015 (EDT)

@NSY: How are English names the priority? They're the priority with article names, but I don't remember a rule saying that they're the main priority when it comes to splits/merges. Besides, the English names are invented by the translators, who don't actually create the games in question. If a translator called Goombas "Shroomers" in one game, would that be a new enemy? On that note, Super Mario RPG was infamous for using different names for things than pretty much the rest of the series. (Yo'ster Isle, Shy Away, Sky Troopa, Goby, The Big Boo... the list goes on) Binarystep (talk) 04:25, 8 September 2015 (EDT)
 * I feel that we've had this argument before. A lot of times. Including this tired "creator's intent" point. From Walkazo's point in the Cheep Chomp proposal: "splits on an English site based on different English names, when backed up by design and/or behavioural differences more significant than the likes of RPG enemy palette-swaps, is not silly". I sometimes think the translators make a good call when differentiating entities and you can't just disregard translators' intent as well. I don't think they would just change names around just for the hell of it in many cases. 16:52, 8 September 2015 (EDT)

@Marshal Dan Troop: How does it matter that they're made by different companies? I doubt Intelligent Systems was unaware of the existence of Super Mario RPG. Niiue (talk) 17:04, 8 September 2015 (EDT)
 * He probably meant that the games are from two different series despite the little hints at each other. 23:45, 9 September 2015 (EDT)