Talk:1-Up Mushroom

Split and Merge the "Mario and Luigi series section" from 1-Up Mushroom into the regular Mushroom article
DO NOTHING 2-5

We merged all the other RPG mushrooms, except for the 1-Up Super, so we should merge this one. EDIT: There was a talk page proposal that proposed to merge all the Mario & Luigi series mushrooms, made by Baby Mario Bloops. Now, the recent 1-Up Super TPP said to merge that article into 1-Up Mushroom, and then I knew that not all the M&L series mushrooms were merged. I propose to clean up some stuff by merging the Mario and Luigi series section with the Mushroom article.

Split 1-up Super from 1-up Mushroom
Why was the 1-Up Super merged with the 1-Up Mushroom. It is also a super mushroom, and since it is a combination of both, it doesn't make any sense to put all the info into 1-Up Mushroom. So I propose what the heading says, "Split the 1-Up Super from 1-Up Mushroom."

Proposer: Deadline: July 10 2010, 24:00

Support

 * 1) Per my own proposal.
 * 2) I agree it makes no sense.
 * 3) - As I said in my opposition of the proposal to merge them in the first place: "[The 1-Up Super is] both a Super Mushroom and a 1-Up Mushroom, so merging it with either would be a mistake, as would sticking it into the Mushroom article: it's unique, and should remain as a stand-alone article."
 * 4) pretty much per all.

Oppose

 * 1) It makes perfect sense. It is a variety of the 1-Up Mushroom, and not a very common one at that.
 * 2) - Come on! We have the M&L Mushroom thing merged, and they are different in healing. Max Mushroom, Ultra Mushroom, Super Mushroom (which could be with the Super Mushroom Page), Mushroom, they are similar in the case of 1-up Mushroom and 1-up super! It is consistent as it is now, and if this pass, we have to undo all the merging with the mushrooms and syrups and nuts. I'm sure that you don't want to have to redo all that...
 * 3) They both do the same thing.
 * 4) I am Zero! There was a reason why they were split and per HR. Zero signing out.

Comments
@Homestar Runner: If they both do the same thing then why don't we merge the 1-Up Mushroom and the 1-Up Super into the regular Mushroom article. 15:18, 11 July 2010 (UTC)

Um, because those don't do the same thing? 1-Up Mushroom gives the player an extra life/revives a Mario Bro. Regular mushrooms do other stuff. 

The 1-up and the 1-up super arent exactly the same thing even though they look the same. one gives you 1/2 HP and the Super gives you full. So they are different items.-

@BMB: I'm willing to split the other Mushrooms in the Mushroom article for consistency if this fails.
 * Well also, we don't need to split it since it will more than likely be a stub such as the Mushrooms from my proposals on this talk page. If we this pass, it will not last by itself since it is so small, and we will just have to merge it back into with the 1-UP Mushroom Page. Also, it fits in the 1-UP page since in Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story they call it a 1-UP Deluxe.
 * Why was it merged into the 1-up mushroom article if its also a super mushroom?It's also pointless to have a section about the same thing in two articles. So why not give it its own article, and I think we can cram enough information and pictures into it to make it not a stub.