Talk:Grab Block

Colors
What are the colors that it flashes? I'm trying to make a spritesheet of it and other items. Or, can someone point me to a PNG format sprite sheet with all of its color frames?

Roads (Talk - Me on Wikia - Me on Wikipedia) 15:48, 15 November 2011 (EST)

Name question
Isn't the Grab Block named Throw Block? Because I think it's named like that, but I'm not sure. Telinc1 04:50, 30 December 2011 (EST)

Super Mario Bros 3
Are the blocks which buster beetles are throwing the grab blocks? --78.248.232.59 07:01, 2 April 2016 (EDT)
 * Look up the Buster Beetle article and you'll find your answer. 21:25, 2 April 2016 (EDT)

Merge Super Mario Bros. 3 Ice Block with Super Mario World Grab Block
Before proposal, let's discuss first. The Ice Block found in SMB3 functions identically to the Grab Block of SMW. It doesn't feel right to group that Ice Block with the other Ice Blocks as those Ice Blocks seem to be about a slick surface or something to melt. Thoughts? -- 16:56, 6 May 2016 (EDT)


 * I think it should simply be noted on the Ice Block section that they function identically to the Grab Block of SMW. Otherwise, the (official?) name and appearance is of a common Ice Block. The Grab Block is also diverse in name and appearance.


 * 17:30, 1 August 2016 (EDT)
 * This is an old conversation, but undecided. I have found a reference for the Ice Block name in the Super Mario Advance 4: Super Mario Bros. 3 Nintendo Power guide...in many places, actually. First instance appears to be on page 51. As such, I think this section should not be merged. 18:39, 7 April 2017 (EDT)
 * Since everyone refuses to merge them, I'm adding an edit to at least ACKNOWLEDGE the similarity. - 68.117.20.106 21:04, 24 September 2017 (EDT)
 * It's already been mentioned. 21:09, 24 September 2017 (EDT)

Merge Super Mario Bros. 3 Ice Block with Super Mario World Grab Block (rebooted)
In light of some more information that has come to light since the above, I really think Wildgoosespeeder was onto something. The throwable type (アイスブロック) is not grouped together with the game's thawable type (氷ブロック) in Encyclopedia Super Mario Bros.'s Super Mario Bros. 3 section. This can also be seen in the English Encyclopedia, where the former is "Frozen Block" and the latter is "Ice Block", as well as the Super Mario Advance 4 Prima guide, which calls them "blue block" and "ice block", respectively. In all the other guides, "Ice Block" only refers to the throwable one, whereas it seems the thawable and platform ones don't have a specific name. The throwable one also has another name - White Block (しろいぶろっく / 白いブロック) - which shows up in-game in one of the letters. Additionally, it is virtually identical in function to Super Mario World's Grab Blocks (implied by the Japanese name to be a form of ice melting in your hands), even keeping the same traction as ordinary, non-ice terrain when used as a foothold as opposed to every other ice block. All in all, I think the "Ice Block" is somewhat a misnomer and it very clearly evolved into the Grab Block, not unlike how silver coins became blue coins. The only thing I'm not sure about would be which name should be the article title, as White Block is used in-game and technically appears more recently. LinkTheLefty (talk) 10:50, October 22, 2022 (EDT)

Merge Super Mario Bros. 3 Ice Block with Super Mario World Grab Block (proposal)
See "rebooted" section for details. In essence, the White Block from Super Mario Bros. 3 is identical in every way with the Grab Block from Super Mario World, with both being suggested as icy blocks that seemingly melt in Mario's hands and lacking the slippery platform traction of ordinary Ice Blocks, with which they're distinguished. As such, I think it would be a mistake to keep the Super Mario Bros. 3 version merged with the Ice Block article when the Super Mario World version is much more appropriate. Two main options are presented in this proposal. The first will simply merge White Block with Grab Block, which is a more self-explanatory name. The second will still merge, but make White Block the current name, which would be closer to policy due to being the most recent in-game name as of Super Mario Advance 4. A third option merges Grab Block with the Ice Block article, although I'm not sure I particularly recommend this since that article could probably stand to have a thing or two split already. A fourth option fully splits White Block as its own article. In any case, an will be added to note the "White Block" Semisolid Platform.

Proposer: Deadline: April 14, 2023, 23:59 GMT

Merge White Block with Grab Block

 * 1) As per reboot thoughts.
 * 2) Per proposal.
 * 3) Secondary choice. Both of these can be grabbed and flash in different colors when doing so; the biggest difference is that these are dark blue and resemble Rotating Blocks more.

Merge and use White Block as the article title

 * 1) Alternative choice.

Split White Block fully as its own article

 * 1) I prefer this, per what I said below.
 * 2) Per SmokedChili, there doesn't appear to be concrete proof that White Block and Grab Block are the same.
 * 3) I have no idea why the whiteish-light blue Brick Block is merged to Ice Block for so long when it functions entirely different from one (even distinctive from other Ice Blocks in Super Mario Bros. 3!) They also flash in different colors when grabbed (or just from cyan to orange in the SNES port), which isn't natural for ice either. If it weren't for one of the Japanese names, I would've doubted these were actually made of ice.

Keep White Block merged with Ice Block

 * 1) Identical properties doesn't sound like solid enough proof for merging. Aside from Grab Block not being explicitly described as icy, the difference is that one has its roots on Brick Blocks and the other on Rotating Blocks, so "convergent evolution" if one may. Although, I'd prefer splitting White Block to its own article for the same reasons.

Comments
@SmokedChili: Normal Ice Blocks in Super Mario World are also aesthetically Rotating Blocks, despite neither it nor Grab Block being able to rotate, and they're not really worth splitting over it. The Japanese name of the Grab Block also suggests it still has frozen properties, which is probably supposed to imply that it disappears because it warms up in Mario's hands, as mentioned above. I'll add a full split as another option, though. LinkTheLefty (talk) 13:55, April 3, 2023 (EDT)
 * The Japanese name suggests melting in Mario's hands as much as it suggests the block breaking down from frightened trembling. Too ambiguous to really say. SmokedChili (talk) 11:44, April 5, 2023 (EDT)