Talk:Spinner

Are these really considered enemies? They seem more like mobile obstacles than a live creature, just like spikes or fireballs.--Spike 20:46, 19 October 2006 (EDT)


 * I think we should make a new category for objects that are specifically made as traps. They are not really enemies as they are purely mechanical without any independent thought processes. Perhaps a Traps and Obstacles category. -- Son of Suns

Similar obstacle
Isn't there an obsticale in DKCR in the cliffs that is like Ball'n'chains? Should we include it?--YoshiGo99 21:55, 13 March 2011 (EDT)

Not Alive
WHY, do they have a Species Infobox? THEY ARE MACHINES. Mustard of Doom. It's what's for dinner. BA-DUM-BUM.


 * It's not just a species box a lot of objects have them

Two questions.
First: The Ball 'n' Chain has a Japanese name? Second: Where do you get the names of enemies? Is there some game that has the names or it's from other sources?--Deruffy 12:59, 5 May 2012 (EDT)

Pretty much all enemies have Japanese names, as the series is from Japan and few Mario games haven't been released there. Also, the names of enemies are usually found in other sources.

NSMBU Ball 'n' Chains, old or new
I recently finnished New Super Luigi U and I noticed a very special thing about the Ball'n'Chains in that game. Not only are the spiked balls connected to a spiked arm instead of chains and move in pendulum-like manner but apperently both New Super Mario Bros. U and New Super Luigi U calls them Pendulums (Pendulum Castle, Impossible Pendulums). So this obstacle might not only looks similar to the Ball'n'Chains but can actually be a completely new obstacle called Pendulums. If that´s the case we should make a new page about them, or what do you guys think.

Proposer Deadline August 27, 2013, 23:59 GMT

Support

 * 1) Per proposal.
 * 2) Per proposal.
 * 3) Per proposal.
 * 4) Per proposal. Pendulums are different (the chain will hurt you, while Ball'n'Chains will only hurt you if you hitthe ball), so there is no reason why there should not be a separate article.

Oppose

 * This proposal does not make sense, we are talking of the same object, the appearance is identical. Based on this proposal should create separate pages for each color of the Koopa Troopa, and the like, so then if we think that we should create separate pages for each of the ScareScraper ghost prcedente reversing a proposal. I am against and I sincerely hope that this proposal is not accepted.
 * 1) The wiki does not make articles about the same thing under a different name.
 * 2) Per Sonic98
 * 3) As stated in the comments, they're not directly referred to as pendulums and that alone convinces me this proposal is not a good idea.

Coments
Aside from the level names, does New Super Luigi U directly refer to these as pendulums? 13:03, 13 August 2013 (EDT)
 * No, and besides, Pendulum Castle is a New Super Mario Bros. U level, so both games refer to them as pendulums. 20:37, 13 August 2013
 * Hm, I'm convinced. Still, are there any Ball 'n' Chains from the previous games that act like pendulums? 18:25, 13 August 2013 (EDT)
 * Indeed they have (in Super Princess Peach and Super Mario 3D Land) but they still was clearly connected to chains.

Name is "Spinner". 

I explained what sense does it make voting to create different pages for each name the same enemy? It would make more sense to create separate pages for each of the boss ScareScraper that at least queli are different.--Sonic98 (talk) 07:22, 16 August 2013 (EDT)
 * Hold on, it´s not yet decided if we are gonna make a new page or not. Even if it might be a new enemy it´s still somewhat similar to the Ball 'n' Chains (it looks different from the normal Ball 'n' Chains but it might just be a redesign). Still, the spiked ball looks like it´s hold up by spiked cylinders, but Ball 'n' Chains have moved in a pendulum like manner. As with the ScareScraper ghosts the only one who might get a new page is The Brain, otherwise the pages about them needs more pictures.


 * I'd like to see an additional source of the name "Pendelum", asides from the level names. These can sometimes be misleading, as for all we know the levels could have simply been named that to give a short, catchy title, and not necessarily officially name something.


 * 03:25, 20 August 2013 (EDT)


 * Well, the IGN Star Coin Guide call them Pendulums as well as a couple of other star coin guides I found.  I mainly used Google to find them.


 * and what official source affirms that they are different enemies?--Sonic98 (talk) 15:21, 21 August 2013 (EDT)