Talk:Shadow Sirens

Are the Shadow Sirens really undead, I mean just because they seem a bit ghost like doesn't mean they are ghosts. Personally I think they may be demons like the Shadow Queen. -- Sir Grodus I don't think that they're undead, but I don't think that anything in the Marioverse can really be considered a "demon", either. Almighty Rajah 12:48, 22 August 2006 (EDT)

But it's directly stated in PM: TTYD that the Shadow Queen is a demon sorceress. -- Sir Grodus

I'm not sure if there's any direct quote saying there ghosts but they have most ghost traits and hang around Duppliss. - Yoshi Mastar

Members of Tribe Of Darkness?
I've noticed that Count Bleck shares many similarites to these three. Therefore I doubt that Shadow Siren is the name of their species. They are likely member of the tribe of Darkness. Same goes for the Shadow Queen.--King Boo 16:24, 4 August 2007 (EDT)

The Shadow Sirens might be, but remember, thats only the Shadow Queen's soul we see, we have no real idea about what her physical form was due to it being destroyed. -- Sir Grodus