Talk:Greenie

I don't think we should have a article about this intill the game comes out. Kingfawful4321 (talk) 10:20, 27 February 2013 (EST)
 * That would be stupid - by your logic we should delete the Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon page altogether. --Yoshi2mpds.gif  Super Yoshi  Bros  Yoshi2mpds.gif 11:01, 27 February 2013 (EST)

tushay. Kingfawful4321 (talk) 11:07, 27 February 2013 (EST)

Mummies are Grennies
If you look closey in the overview trailer you ill see a whirlwind of bandages. When it stops a Greenie appears holding two sticks with gloves on them and is on stilts. It drops these after spinning. These are most likley the mummies we have seen. - Cubeguy

Greenie Fun Facts
Greenie have 10HP and likes to taunt Luigi. He is the 1st to meet Luigi and he is a very cheeky ghost. He is green or gold His friends are Slammer and Hider. He loves showers

Sam OS

Ummm...okay...but, that information was not needed. Greenie is a species, not a character. the idea of him being friends with Slammer and Hider is not official, Greenies do appear to like water but that's not something that should be mentioned on the article.

Mummies and Knights
I think we should create a page dedicated to Medieval Knight and the Mummy, is that both are enemies but they are possessed by the ghosts of beings that exist in their own right even without the presence of ghosts. Maybe we could give it a name conjectural.

Proposer: Deadline: May 18th, 2013, 23:59 GMT

Support

 * Per proposal.
 * 1) The problem with your reasoning, Goomba, is that we are not talking about simple disguises of an enemy. The mummies and the knights are NOT the same as Scarescraper recolors. I think these enemies deserve separate articles because they have very different attacking methods (the mummies attempt to run into you and swipe you) and they make different noises as well. You can't even tell they're Greenies inside them until you unravel their wrapping. I'm not sure about knights since my sister and I haven't gotten through the game enough. Also, Jack O' Goomba has its own article, even though it's just a Goomba in a jack o' lantern. The same goes for Prickly Goomba. The mummy and the knight are also not simply Greenie equipment either. Also, mummy is not conjectural because E. Gadd has mentioned their names. It's simply, "mummy".
 * 2) Per LGM (because I basically told her reasons she should support before she cast her vote). Mummies and Knights are disguises that make a Greenie very different; it's not the same as it carrying a shovel or using kitchen equipment.
 * 3) Per LeftyGreenMario.
 * 4) Per LGM.
 * 5) Per LGM
 * 6) Per LGM.
 * 7) Per LGM.

Oppose

 * 1) We did that for the "different" boss ghosts of the ScareScraper/Thrill Tower, and it didn't work out so well.
 * 2) Same as Goomba, but Greenies are the only common ghosts that possess and disguise themselves as knights and mummies.

Comments
@LeftyGreenMario & BabyLuigi: Im sorry but your reasoning is unsound. First the disguises serve as a diffrent form of attack by the greenies and also acts as a shield much like the shovels,, helmets, swords & shield, and other objects. If so then you shold make pages for those. Not only that but greenies can be heard from inside the disguises, they do laugh, it also explains why the suits of armor attack luigi, besides the tough possessor. Also when the greenie is exposed it does not provide it with anything new making it a simple greenie. If they where to have there own page then a ghost should not be inside them. Speaking of which, greenies are the only ghosts that are found inside them so seperate articles on the greenies page for them i would have to agree to. I will say the knight statues, that can't be knocked over, are a unkown but the mummies are not. One last thing, during the Overset Possessor battle on level C-6 3 greenies spawn and dive into the ground which then mummies rise from the ground to attack luigi, after unrappiing them the greenies are exposed, so mummies are greenies in disguise, also e.gadd even states there clever for dressing up like mummies after level C-2. - Cubeguy(talk)
 * I never stated that mummies are NOT Greenies. I'm saying that mummies deserve separate pages because mummies make different noises, different attacks, and you can't really tell Greenies are inside them until you unravel their wrappings. Greenies with equipment are simply Greenies with protective equipment, and they don't have another name for them. I provided an analogy for mummies as to how Prickly Goomba (they become normal Goombas when their shield is destroyed) and Jack O' Goomba (they become normal Goombas when their pumpkins are destroyed; they also emit fire) have their own articles. BabyLuigiOnFire and I never faced knights yet, but they seem to be the same case as mummies.
 * 18:37, 7 May 2013 (EDT)
 * As stated mummies will make the occasional greenie laugh, not only that but there attack is basically the same as a greenies punch but if stobed it increases slightly as they ram luigi, and they aren't really mummies as the only ones encountered are just greenies in disguise, which i have said is stated by proffesor E.Gadd. I'll settle for sperate articles on the greenies page, but seperate pages really aren't needed. - Cubeguy2ver.pnguy(talk)

Note: The suits of armor should be discussed more as only 2 are actually ever fought. - Cubeguy(talk)
 * They may make the same laugh. The mummies even move differently than the normal Greenies (which is another reason Greenies with equipment should not get separate articles). Yes, they are Greenies are disguise, but they're called mummies as well. Also, you're not reading where I said Goombas in disguises getting separate articles. I think an analogy can be drawn from Greenie to Mummy as in Goomba is to Jack O'Goomba or Prickly Goomba.
 * 00:40, 9 May 2013 (EDT)