User:Knife/Policy

Warning templates have been around since the creation of the Super Mario Wiki and are used to keep track of a user's disciplinary history as well as provide justification for blocks/bans. Once a warning has been issued, it cannot be removed without going through an appeal. Removing a warning template without going through an appeal is grounds for another warning. You can archive talk pages that have warnings as long as the warnings are not removed from the archive page or are otherwise tampered with.

The following templates are considered warning templates:



In this page, the above templates are collectively referred to as "warnings" for simplicity. Capitalized "Warning" refers to the specific template, and all other specific templates are capitalized as well.

Procedure
If you feel like another user has violated a rule, you may issue a warning. Before doing so, contemplate whether the user really deserves the warning. Since warnings are serious accusations, use them responsibly. Abuse of warning privileges is grounds for a warning of your own or block. Follow these steps:


 * 1) Identify the problem. If the problem is something that can be resolved through discussion (such as edit conflicts), try contacting the user.
 * 2) Determine the right template for the situation, based on the nature and severity of the offense. A list of offenses and what templates should be used can be found below, but here are the general rules of thumb:
 * 3) *If it's the user's first time creating that particular problem, give them the default template. In general, minor issues get Reminders and userspace issues get the Userspace notice, while problematic behavior gets Warnings, and serious offenses get Last Warnings or even instant bans. See below for details and a list of what specific offenses get which template.
 * 4) **If you give someone a Last Warning, contact an admin to that they can keep an eye on the user and block them if they continue to break the rules.
 * 5) **If you see someone doing something that deserves an instant ban, alert an admin immediately.
 * 6) *If the user has already received the default template, give them a warning from the next level. If they have received both the default and the nest tier up, give them the tier above that. I.e. if they already have a Reminder or Userspace template, give them a Warning template, and if they persist with their action, give them a Last Warning.
 * 7) *If the user has not caused that particular problem before, but has accumulated numerous warnings for various other offenses, they can be issued a higher-level warning for this latest offense. I.e. if they have numerous Reminders, rather than give them another Reminder, give them a Warning, even if it was a minor offense - it becomes the straw that broke the camel's back.
 * 8) *If you go to warn someone and find they have already been given a Last Warning for any issue, contact an admin, as that user most likely needs to be blocked for their latest misdemeanor.
 * 9) Place the template on the user's talk page and include the specific offense in the template. If necessary, accompany the template with a paragraph detailing exactly what the users was doing wrong and maybe even how they can avoid the problem in the future. It is extremely important that you make it clear what the warning was for.

Alternatively, you may contact a Sysop or Patroller and ask them to deal with the problem. If you don't feel comfortable asking them in public, you may also PM an administrator on the forums.

Warnable Offenses
Here are some common reasons for warnings on the Super Mario Wiki. Offenses are organized by four levels and are given a fitting warning template for the initial offense. Reasons other than the ones listed below may be used depending on the situation. As explained in the Procedure, each time the offense is repeated, the severity of the warning issued is increased to the next level.

An asterisk (*) marks offenses that can only be issued by administrators:

Level One Offenses
Level one offenses are low level offenses and are given through the and  templates. Infractions that deserve a Reminder template include:


 * Not marking minor edits as "minor"
 * Not marking a flood of edits as "minor"
 * Consistently writing with bad grammar/spelling (some leniency for non-native English speakers)
 * Not entering coding correctly
 * Entering speculation into articles
 * Making too many consecutive edits to one page
 * Creating new stub articles
 * Having too many personal images (can also be given through )
 * Violating signature guidelines (can also be given through )
 * Using mainspace talk pages for unconstructive purposes
 * Failure to follow Writing Guidelines

Infractions that deserve a Userspace template include:


 * Editing user page too much in a short period of time
 * Having a large ratio of user space contributions compared to mainspace contributions
 * Creating user pages that are not for constructive purposes
 * Violating the user space policy

Level Two Offenses
Level two offenses are mid level offenses and are given through the template. Infractions that deserve a Warning template include:


 * Making major changes without approval
 * Enforcing a proposal before it has been passed
 * Entering false information into articles
 * Removing/altering other users' content (votes, comments, etc.)
 * The only exceptions to this is when fixing coding issues and enforcing policy (replacing red links with, replacing a personal signature with on No-Signature pages, etc.)
 * Participating in an edit war
 * Abusing warning privileges*
 * Spamming on the recent changes
 * Removing a warning without an appeal
 * Editing an archive without good reason
 * Failure to follow most policies

Level Three Offenses
Level three offenses are high level offenses and given through the template. Infractions that deserve a Lastwarn template include:


 * Minor vandalism (like capitalizing all words, moving information to the wrong section, adding comments to an article, etc.)
 * Impersonating another user
 * Falsely claiming to be an admin
 * Creating sockpuppets*
 * Undermining admin authority*
 * Flaming, spamming, and making disruptive comments towards other users

Level Four Offenses
Level four offenses are offenses which warrant an automatic infinite ban. Infractions which are considered level four offenses include:


 * Major vandalism (like blanking pages, uploading inappropriate images, unprovoked flaming, etc.)
 * Possessing an inappropriate username
 * Creating sockpuppets during a temporary block (will extend the block the first time and become an infinite ban the second time)
 * Creating an account for advertising purposes
 * Creating an account just to make inflammatory comments

Please note that any sockpuppets of an existing account are automatically banned.

If you see a user committing a level three or level four offense, notify an administrator immediately.

Reasons other than the ones listed above may be used depending on the situation. Depending on the severity of the offense, repeated offenses may be escalated more than one level.

FAQ
Q. Does my warning ever expire? A. No, warnings are permanent records.

Q. Can anyone give out warnings? A. Yes, all users have the right to warn other users.

'''Q. I don't think I deserve my warning. What should I do?''' A. If you feel you don't deserve the warning, you have the option to appeal it as long as the warning in question was not given by an administrator. When appealing warnings, it is best to do so as soon as possible.

Q. Can I still be promoted even if I have warnings? A. Absolutely. Warnings are meant to keep track of your past activities, not to evaluate your current performance.

Q. Can I still be blocked without any warnings? A. If the offense is severe enough, it is possible to be blocked without any kind of warning.