MarioWiki:Featured Articles/N/Toad
From the Super Mario Wiki
- Toad was nominated at 19:56, 2 May 2008 (EDT).
[edit] Toad
[edit] Support
- Superb. 19:56, 2 May 2008 (EDT)
Glitchman (talk · contribs) While the Super Paper Mario and the New Super Mario Bros. sections should be expanded, overall its worthy of being featured.
- --Toadster 04 20:25, 2 May 2008 (EDT) It's definitely shaping up as a great article! Problems like differentiating Toad and the species of Toads are being/are fixed.
- <<< Knife, you're a Featured Articles/N/Toad 12:34, 3 June 2008 (EDT) Good content and a few problems with spelling and punctuation. I'll let the Toad/Toads controversy slide because sometimes it cannot be confirmed.
- Dom --- McTalk
I've found no spelling or grammar errors, so it's good in that sense. It can't really be helped that the character Toad is easily confused with Toads in general.
- GSXR4S2 (Talk) This article pretty much covers everything Toad does, and in SPM he doesn't do anything anyway.
- KingBoo&PeteyPirahna (Talk) Well, its not like a Toad will never get to be famous!This is his time to shine, but people know him alot so his sub-species should.Right?
- goombalord345 (Talk)Toad is an important character who has helped mario and peach multiple times. He is also a frequent playable character, making him a good featured article. The article itself is informant and well written, with no grammerical or spelling errors.
[edit] Oppose
- ForeverDaisy09 (Talk) Like one of the supporters even said, there are many parts of this that refer to Toads not the Toad.
- Stumpers (Talk) The Bio from The Adventures of Super Mario Bros. 3 Writers Bible, Trophies, and Catch Cards should be merged with the "Statistics" section (which really should be Official Profiles and Statistics based on the information currently in it.) The sections about the cartoons (and the comics if you can) should say where in the storyline they fit in and mention Toad's role in the story. Currently, they just talk about his role in the show. Also, either both entries in the Mario Baseball series should be mentioned or neither should be. Currently only a passing reference is made to Super Mario Sluggers.
[edit] Comments
About the opposition, I said that those particular parts of the article were being fixed, and that was one full month ago. I believe that now, with the addition of the "Confusion with Appearances" section and the statistics for games like Mario Superstar Baseball and the Mario Strikers series being linked directly to the Toad Species page, the article no longer has any ambiguities regarding the species and the character itself anywhere in it. - Toadster_04
